15 ms·
‘War Dialing’ tool exposes Zoom’s password problems
- curiousgal 7y agoHey look it's Mr "it's 2020 but I still don't give a shit about mobile users". Why would anyone want to alienate a substantial amount of users especially if they're serving ads on their blog?
- ebg13 7y ago> Hey look it's Mr "it's 2020 but I still don't give a shit about mobile users". Nobody owes you their site behaving a certain way on your phone.
- gjs278 7y agoare those metal implants for your head?
- curiousgal 7y agoIt's not really about entitlement. He's the one benefiting from people consuming his content, why not make it more accessible? All at the cost of some CSS rules.
- ebg13 7y ago> It's not really about entitlement. The tone of your opening sentence fooled me then. > why not make it more accessible? Maybe because he doesn't give a shit about mobile users.
- catalogia 7y ago> accessible For what it's worth, his website works better with my screen-reader than most modern-style websites.
- criddell 7y agoMaybe it isn't a substantial number of users? FWIW I loaded the article on my Pixel 2 and it looks fine. In the Chrome browser if you double tap on the article text it zooms in to the article.
- saagarjha 7y agoNot having password protection enabled seems like an unfortunate default, but I guess it's not that surprising given the number of "barriers" that Zoom attempts to bypass when you join a call.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- devit 7y agoNot a good idea to use 9 to 11 digit long IDs with no password requirement by default; they should have used at least 128-bit random ids, i.e. 21 character long base64-encoded strings.
- spacehunt 7y agoHow would that support phone dial-ins? (Yes, lots of people still dial into meetings all the time.)
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoI enjoy being able to dial meeting IDs into my phone
- wgjordan 7y agoI would also enjoy being able to punch in '12345' as my password everywhere instead of launching LastPass all the time, but I accept that some conveniences aren't worth security consequences.
- kube-system 7y agoThat's a fine compromise for internal teams. For those working with current or potential customers remotely, you have to use a solution that is convenient or you don't make money.
- umvi 7y agoYeah but then it sucks for people calling in to have to punch in a 21+ character long meeting ID
- toomuchtodo 7y agoCould you not use a telephone intent, where the meeting ID is the suffix to the dial in number with commas for any necessary pauses? Skype for business meeting invites have this. Zoom might then support inviting mobile phone conference participants using SMS, containing the link (think weak 2FA). Example: tel://18005551212,,<meeting_id>#
- andrewstuart 7y agoHow hard is this for them to fix?
- saagarjha 7y agoNot hard, everyone needs to password-protect their meetings.
- rayvd 7y agoWhy?
- diebeforei485 7y agoGenerating a random 6-digit passcode for each meeting by default? Not hard at all. Rate-limiting incorrect password attempts could take a bit longer to implement, but still not a particularly difficult problem to solve.
- chrismarlow9 7y agoI never understood "presenter will let you in" security. It's based on someone letting me in if they recognize my recorded name and that I work there? Surely that wont backfire in a world where everyone post every detail about every day of their life online. I mean who even uses LinkedIn anyway?
- JadeNB 7y agoYou can also require users to be authenticated (through SSO or other mechanism) before they log in, which could defeat some impersonation attempts.
- wolco 7y agoThey may decide there is nothing to fix. If you want to use a password you can.. but don't force it on the average user who would trade having no password with the potential of someone random joining. If you want to keep it private use a password.
- _bxg1 7y ago[deleted]
- saagarjha 7y agoThat wasn't really arbitrary code execution.
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoIt's 1985 all over again: I'm in my bedroom running a ProDOS wardialer on my 300/1200 baud AppleModem; I have found zero computers, but it is fun watching the numbers flick past, hoping that I, too, can discover a WOPR and start global thermonuclear war.
- softwaredoug 7y agoYeah but this time, it’s an easy as guessing a world leaders zoom meeting, and tricking them into believing something preposterous
- wolco 7y agoI remember a Montreal morning show doing this via phone and tricking a few world leaders. Hopefully some funny things come out of this.
- saagarjha 7y agoHopefully we don't have any unfunny things come out of this.
- chefandy 7y agoModern Version: "Shall we play a game?" "Love to" "‼To play Global Thermonuclear War, you must first update your flash player. Click here‼️"
- the_af 7y agoAn even more modern version: "Shall we play a game of Global Thermonuclear War?" "Sure!" "Updating Steam client... It seems you're connecting from a new device! Please check the 2FA code sent to your email... Downloading more updates... Here are some popups about unrelated games... Please register an account with MS Game Live!... Downloading patches... [error in wopr.dll]"
- kortilla 7y agoThose red exclamation points have convinced me this is legitimate.
- kardos 7y agoZoom is pretty lucky to get so much free security scrutiny. I hope they make the most of it and fix all of these issues..
- floatingatoll 7y agoThree of the big issues reported in the past week have also been corrected in the past week, so they’re certainly trying.
- varelaz 7y agoTLDR: With 17 digits meeting password is not needed at all. If meeting will be 17 numbers it will be the same as to protect 11 length digit number with 6 digit password. So basically that's the trade off. One could say that password is not the same as meeting ID, but usually they both sent in one email/message and lifetime and protection for them is equal. Also it's easier to input one number than 2 different.
- diebeforei485 7y agoPlease don't think of this in entropy terms alone. There is a massive usability difference between the two.
- jascii 7y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. The usability of clicking a link stays equal regardless of the amount of digits in the ID. Adding a password reduces the usability.
- madeofpalk 7y agoSecurity pretty much always reduces usability - that’s the trade off.
- jtaft 7y agoI've been thinking about security and usability for a while. IMO a big part of use-ability issues are related to interfaces people have to interact with. This is mainly concerning authentication and crypto related processes. I generally like the idea of smartcards, or having some physical thing you carry around which is used to authenticate with systems.
- madeofpalk 7y agoTwo factor auth - some physical thing you carry around with you to authenticate with systems - is the very definition of decreasing usability in order to increase security.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- heipei 7y agoOh the number of times I've been on 20+ people Zoom meetings which were interrupted after a minute by someone asking "Hold on folks, who is the phone-user who just dialed in?" Or whenever someone connected who had the wrong nick set (happened on Linux) and hadn't turned the video on yet, which basically meant the conversation stopped until the new arrival had identified himself.
- rsync 7y agoShout outs to l0pht and cdc, but not to Minor Threat[1] ? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Lamprecht https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Lamprecht
- cs702 7y agoOne positive thing about all these horrendous security flaws that have been recently discovered in Zoom, due to its popularity, is that the company seems to be taking them seriously, recently instituting a feature freeze to focus on fixing them: https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/04/01/a-message-to-our-users/ https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/04/01/a-message-to-our-u... As a consequence, I suspect Zoom's security is more likely than not to improve going forward... although it will surely take a long while. Security is Capital-H Hard. Also, I cannot think of any other multi-video-conferencing solution that "just works" and has been as thoroughly stress-tested and attacked by bad actors in the wild at such a large scale. If Zoom does a decent-to-good job fixing all the security issues, it looks likely to continue to dominate its market.
- bluntfang 7y ago>recently instituting a feature freeze to focus on fixing them Or they're having productivity problems like every other company right now and are spinning it to seem like they are on top of things. These security issues have been around for years.
- dang 7y agoDiscussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22757697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22757697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22756730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22756730
- ryandrake 7y agoPro: A worldwide, motivated, unpaid volunteer team is doing their thorough security audit, privacy review and QA testing for them. Con: After the product was released :)
- Spooky23 7y agoI'm not a fan of Zoom... But the pile-on of grief is ridiculous. The "war dialing" issue is a great example. Webex has had the exact same "flaw" for a decade, with the exact same solution - set a meeting password. Other solutions like Google Meet or Skype have the "lobby" approach.
- jascii 7y agoI always wondered why teleconferencing systems don't incorporate a workflow where people connecting in need an approval from the organizer before actually entering the meeting.
- Twirrim 7y agoI feel a little bit sorry for the Zoom devs. All of a sudden there are a _lot_ of eyes on Zoom. Every design decision and mistake are under a big microscope, while also presumably having to deal with some major scaling.
- tpmx 7y agoIt's a ~2k person company with a market cap of $34B. So the valuation is $17M per employee. I don't feel sorry for them. Also: this crisis is giving them vast amounts of marketing for free. I'm based in Sweden. I was just vaguely aware of Zoom until a few days ago - now I suddenly hear of them all of the time from Late Night hosts on Youtube.
- Twirrim 7y agoThe developers are still people. Doesn't matter the size of the company, it's still a bunch of individuals who are likely suddenly dealing with a lot of stress and pressure that could never have been predicted, or have opportunity to scale up their engineering to meet.
- obmelvin 7y agoI'm sure there are plenty of people who would be delighted to be in that situation. At the end of the day Zoom is looking to stay a run-away success - assuming eng is being compensated appropriately it's really one of the best problems one could have in a job.
- tpmx 7y agoYeah.. no. Only on HN could these winners become "victims".
- jeffhuys 7y ago> Only on HN could these winners become "victims". Maybe because the users on here have an unique perspective on developers / development?
- catalogia 7y ago> "KrebsOnSecurity is not naming the companies involved" This chart suggests that one of the companies they found was an aerospace company: https://krebsonsecurity.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/zwardialmeetingsbyindustry.png https://krebsonsecurity.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/zward... I wonder if this is related to the news yesterday that SpaceX has banned the use of Zoom.
- moftz 7y agoSpaceX seems big enough that they pay for a self-hosted meeting suite. I've worked at a couple places that use WebEx that is self-hosted. You can only access it via dialing the number (from any phone) or by being on the VPN to see the shared presentation. Trying to log into the public version of WebEx gives you an unknown user error. Someone could still wardial their way into the call but it would require getting the non-public phone number and guessing the meeting number AND possibly guessing a meeting password.
- jfjrjri9nn 7y agoThey’re explaining how seriously they take security using Wordpress.
- david_shaw 7y agoI know that WordPress doesn't have the greatest security record, but it seems unfair to judge an organization for using WP. Many, many respectable businesses use WordPress for their brochureware or corporate blogs. In my experience, it's not a security nightmare if it's well maintained.
- gchamonlive 7y agoSometimes it is not just a matter of good maintenance. WP has a bad quality control for plugins and that can be catastrophic: https://wordpress.org/support/topic/amazon-cloudfront-invalidations/ https://wordpress.org/support/topic/amazon-cloudfront-invali... > I have had the same issue with the plugin. This was on a simple WooCommerce site with a few thousand products. Notice it incurred over $6,000 in fees. > Amazon CloudFront Invalidations $6,485.76 > $0.000 per URL – first 1,000 URLs / month.1,000 URL$0.00 > $0.005 per URL – over 1,000 URLs / month.1,297,151 URL$6,485.76 After a user reporting a plugin costing his business over 6000 USD, months go by without proper attention to this issue. If there was good quality control, the plugin should have been pulled. It just shows how the ecosystem is not designed with robustness and security in mind. But I agree, WP cannot be a proxy to judge how companies treat security. This just illustrates how bad WP itself is.
- elwell 7y agoIf you think you can find a security hole in their blog, ask them for a bug bounty.
- motohagiography 7y agoThis is what technical debt gets you. I really don't know that zoom has a lot or much at all, but I do know that the number of viable solutions to this could be taken off the table internally because they probably made tech debt commitments in their architecture during their scale up phase that prevents bolting on obvious fixes. I have a lot of sympathy for their position. They aren't evil or bad, but they could do a massive mea culpa PR coup on the level of the netflix culture deck if they did a case study retrospective about the effect of tech debt on scale at critical moments. It's also a product management fail, where that lack of transparency on encryption is what a project-manager would pull, where a smarter product manager would have weighed the cost of losing their e2e-crypto compliance market. I can also see why they have security issues because today, security people are on a much longer tailed skill distribution than they were 10y ago and it's hard to listen to most of us. Getting someone to approach it as, "ok, we get that a 9-digit key is literally your product selling UX advantage, let's see what else we can do" is exceedingly rare. Privacy has massive brand implications. Remember blackberry? They launched a new flagship tablet product while their CEO got into an issue with government surveillance and the story became about their risk in India and Asian markets and not whatever that product was called. Zooms story is becoming about privacy problems too. PMs need to be smarter about this.
- deegles 7y ago> This is what technical debt gets you. Becoming one of the top names in video conferencing and displacing dozens of established players virtually overnight? Sign me up.
- chrismarlow9 7y ago> Becoming one of the top names in video conferencing and displacing dozens of established players virtually overnight? Sign me up. What!? That's small thinking. You could be so many greater things than that if you're willing to compromise peoples security and personal information.
- deegles 7y ago
- crazygringo 7y agoI worked in videoconferencing for a while. When it comes to meeting identifiers, striking the right balance between ease of use and security is really hard. On the one side, maximum ease-of-use is a name or code short enough for someone to say over the phone. "Here, just jump into the videoconferencing meeting 'mikefred' or 'john10' or '39584'". That works particularly well for small meetings where it's immediate obvious if someone else joins and you can stop talking and ask them who they are and kick them out if they shouldn't be there. On the other hand is long random identifiers in a space large enough they're impossible to guess. If you're joining a meeting from a link then nobody cares, but if you're telling someone over the phone or typing it into the phone it sucks. (And you are very often needing to jump from one form of communication to videoconferencing, where there's no way to "just paste a link" into the initial form.) There's also no real difference between a short meeting name plus password and a long meeting name, except that passwords tend not to be displayed on screen so it's even harder to find it to tell someone over the phone. Also there's another big issue in how easy or convenient you make it for people from within your domain/company to join, versus outsiders. Half the company wants to make it harder for outsiders to join (for security), the other half (salespeople) want it to be easier. The only solution, unfortunately, is educating users to understand the differences. Zoom already has most if not all the necessary options, even modes like "waiting room". But the same options will never work for every meeting. Whoever hosts a meeting needs to understand the options. There's just no substitute.
- xboxnolifes 7y agoWhat about a long, unique identifier for the baseline, and the ability to generate temporary, single (or `n`) use, short identifiers that can be used when speaking the id? Clicking a long I'd link takes practically training, and entering a short ID would only require training the salespeople how to generate one (would should only be a few clicks tops). This way, a conference is secure by default and easy for people to join by link, and is still easily accessable by code for when needed.
- wyattpeak 7y agoWhen I think about having two different solutions for two slightly different usecases, my mind always goes to Microsoft's decade-long battle to teach their users the difference between Standby and Hibernate. There was very real value in the distinction to those who used it, but it proved so irresolvably confusing to the vast majority of users that eventually they pulled the plug and just gave the one Sleep option. Educating users about technicalities they've probably never thought about is really hard. Doing so without an actual training session, just through interface, verges on impossible. And if Microsoft couldn't convince businesses to train their users, I doubt Zoom can.
- afrcnc 7y agoHey... I created a tool that can hack Zoom meetings faster.... let me tip Brian Krebs about it and advertise it to the world. I don't understand why this article exists. It's like a beacon for all the bored skidz now.
- twistedpair 7y agoWhy doesn't Google Hangouts/Meet have this issue?
- beckingz 7y agoHangouts has this issue as well.
- elwell 7y agoChatroulette Zoom Edition
- fock 7y agoI think a tool which is basically yet another webchat-solution but tries too push their omnipotent app onto you, no matter what, has some issues beyond security. All the "user"-friendly execution looks like some 2002 nigerian adware. I guess userfriendly is really easy if your app can never be closed (not sure about that), can't be uninstalled and you nag the user twice to actually really start that app before allowing to use a runtime under his/her control.
- markthethomas 7y agohttps://unicorn.computer/zoom-wins-malware-of-the-year-march-2020 https://unicorn.computer/zoom-wins-malware-of-the-year-march...
- kerng 7y agoMaybe naive, but why doesnt Zooom do something like SSO? Why is the identity of attendees not validated? Wouldn't that solve the problem?
- hrrsn 7y agoThen they'd need to charge extra for the SSO tax ;) https://sso.tax https://sso.tax
- TheDesolate0 7y agowow! haven't heard that term in a while. we used to do this looking for modems to dial into.
- aembleton 7y agoI remember WarDriving - driving around to pick up WiFi SSIDs. That was about 20 years ago.
- momo156 7y agozoom is not showing real effort to hunker down on privacy. and can feel its consequences as its stock is already down by 8% over the week
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]