4 ms·
Worked for them as a Product SWE for 2 years. For the record, I would not recommend it if you have good alternatives as a SWE. That being said, I want to give
by Prospektor4ever 7y ago
Worked for them as a Product SWE for 2 years. For the record, I would not recommend it if you have good alternatives as a SWE.
That being said, I want to give a more nuanced comment because, in my opinion, crisis require some pragmatism which I find to be surprisingly lacking from the usually reasonable HN crowd.
I understand why Palantir create this epidermic reaction and in most cases I would agree that they are justified. There is an issue of sovereignty, countries should aim be self-sufficient in critical areas like Defense, Healthcare, Counter-terrorism. It is a shame that it is not the case. Many Palantir employees are motivated to help their country but concluded that the most straight-forward path, if they did not want to spend many years in a bureaucracy hell, was to join a startup/software style company, that would respect their value-added as young/bright engineers and make some of them (the majority in commercial works on boring stuff) able to work on those topics.
Yes, compared to many cool tech companies, there is nothing great about their tech. It's a glorified Spark wrapper with a pretty UI and terrible UX. Nothing with significant tech depth is built-in house. However, THAT is compared to cool/good tech companies. Compared to a lot of what big corp and bureaucratic governments can readily provide TODAY, it's a significant improvement and it is ready, TODAY. It is also more secure compared to what an in-house gov team could build, as in, they actually encrypt things and there is no obvious security flaws. Now is the time to use the tool that can reduce the death tools without compromising security, tomorrow is the time to ask our politics to invest in their own technology sector and promote young/bright engineers to build state-of-the-art data platform that does not involve Palantir.
Why Palantir is doing such action is not to gather data (they do not), or to earn money (it's likely pro bono) but to establish a relationship with governments, a trojan horse if you will, so that they can sell their services to more departments. The pragmatic action would be to accept the help now in crisis time and leverage their tools and somewhat competent Forward Deployed Engineer workforce, but decline their expansion when we are past the crisis.
- jacobush 7y agoIt really shows how weak the State is when it to a company like this appear as new territory to be colonized. Send in the scouts! Bring blankets and trinkets, try to sign agreements with local leaders, bring any intel back.
- yters 7y agoAlso, their big principle is human insight over algorithms and machine learning. This was derived from experience in Paypal, where human in the loop approaches worked much better for fraud detection than algorithmic approaches.