4 ms·
>> He heard something about these two drugs, and without any scientific evidence he announced it, causing a panic-grab for the drugs. Unfortunately even the CDC
by phkahler 7y ago
>> He heard something about these two drugs, and without any scientific evidence he announced it, causing a panic-grab for the drugs. Unfortunately even the CDC was saying we don't have evidence supporting it.
He simply reported that it looked promising in early studies, like we had already seen reported here on HN. His other action was apparently to lean the FDA to find out ASAP rather than heming and hawing for years following standard beaurocratic protocols. I think it was fine to do both those things. Responsible even.
- dlp211 7y agoI can't believe I have to say this, but the POTUS is not some hacker news comment. What they say has large and far reaching consequences and they shouldn't be spouting off about anecdotal evidence. Their comments had already caused a shortage of HCQ, and led to at least one death.
- bart_spoon 7y ago> Their comments had already caused a shortage of HCQ HCQ can only be obtained via a doctor's prescription. If there is a shortage of HCQ, its because actual physicians are writing it more, either for their own benefit or for their patients. This isn't the average person panic buying toilet paper. Its trained medical professionals. If you are implying that they are incapably of thinking rationally and professionally in response to a short, offhanded comment by the President, then the issue is far graver than anything Trump is saying. > led to at least one death Which occured because an elderly couple saw the news, realized that HCQ is in a chemical used to treat their fish tank, drank it, and one of them died. If I read an article saying a drinking alcohol in moderation can reduce heart disease, and in response I go out and chug a bottle of isopropyl alcohol, the consequences wouldn't be blamed on anyone but myself. If anything, it supports the idea that any partisanship in this situation is coming from those who are trying to pin every instance of something bad occurring, literally at the level of a single idiotic individual, on the POTUS.
- phkahler 7y ago>> I can't believe I have to say this, but the POTUS is not some hacker news comment. No, hes a guy charged with making high level decisions in a crisis. He also has some very competent advisors at places like the NIH, FDA, CDC etc... I dont think he was just some redneck responding to a tabloid article. If the doctor now publicly claiming 699 treatments with 0 deaths using HCQ turns out to be a blatant fraud I think he may well lose his license given the situation. But yeah, let's fuck around and try nothing and see how that goes.
- zimpenfish 7y ago> If the doctor now publicly claiming 699 treatments with 0 deaths using HCQ turns out to be a blatant fraud The odds seem good on that one. "Zelenko’s claims, however, rest solely on taking him at his word: He has published no data, described no study design, and reported no analysis."
- dlp211 7y agoNo one is saying try nothing. That is a bad faith argument. He is also incredibly poor at making good use those experts at the NIH, FDA, CDC, etc and and even poorer communicator of what those experts have to say.
- frank2 7y ago>If the doctor now publicly claiming 699 treatments with 0 deaths using HCQ turns out to be a blatant fraud I think he may well lose his license given the situation. I don't think the boards of medical quality assurance of the 50 states care enough about public statements to yank the license of (or even to discipline) a doctor for making a public statement the doctor knew to be false. In general the US medical profession doesn't have the commit to truth that, e.g., physicists do.
- phkahler 7y agoNo, but in a case like this our current POTUS might. Not right, but he might.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoYou are talking about the president as if he is just some guy BSing at a BBQ. By discussing an unproven treatment he knowingly or not put his thumb on the scale of science, which is generally something we do not want. We don't want scientific investments made because the president seems into them. We want those choices made by experts who are hopefully disinterested as possible. We want them considering the most likely successful treatments from their expert point of view. You essentially can't have that now. And this goes beyond influence. The administration has been leaning on the FDA to give this ememgency approval. This appears safe from the very preliminary studies we have but problems can develop at scale. These drugs are known to cause heart rhythm issues. It's conceivable that deploying then at scale in an emergency could lead to increase in fatal cardiac episodes. Were this drug not to actually work, large scale deployment would almost certainly do more harm than good. The presidential podium confers added weight to everything a person says for good or ill and therefore should be used cautiously.