6 ms·
Key section: > Over the next 90 days, we are committed to... Enacting a feature freeze, effectively immediately, and shifting all our engineering resources to
by crazygringo 7y ago
Key section:
> Over the next 90 days, we are committed to... Enacting a feature freeze, effectively immediately, and shifting all our engineering resources to focus on our biggest trust, safety, and privacy issues.
I see a lot of comments here claiming that this blog post is bland corporate apologia, doesn't take responsibility, doesn't change anything.
But this seems like a pretty legit turnaround. Overall, they seem to be addressing pretty much everything that's been brought up. They removed the Facebook SDK, they removed attention tracking, they've clarified their encryption policies in detail.
One commenter here is asking for more, for punishment, another demands their security team be fired. And I mean, if someone wants to try to sue Zoom for misusing the term E2EE then go for it, but obviously Zoom can't "punish itself" in a blog post, and pinning it on a few bad engineers feels like a scapegoat.
This seems to be positive steps, folks. Genuinely not sure what more you could be asking for from a regular for-profit business.
- gizmo385 7y ago> One commenter here is asking for more, for punishment, another demands their security team be fired. And I mean, if someone wants to try to sue Zoom for misusing the term E2EE then go for it, but obviously Zoom can't "punish itself" in a blog post, and pinning it on a few bad engineers feels like a scapegoat. A portion of the development community loves to talk about blameless post-mortems and a blame-free culture until a tech company like Zoom does something they don't like.
- tprynn 7y agoI think it's generally a poor assumption to assume that any two internet "crowds" are the same people. Some commenters care about X and some about Y and we can almost never tell what the overlap between those groups is. The hivemind is not as uniform as that.
- jolmg 7y agoWell said, and it applies beyond just "internet" crowds. Some people think whole nationalities work as uniform hiveminds.
- originalbryan2 7y agoIf the citizens of the internet didn't vehemently demand blood for any misstep, would it still be the Internet?
- Lex-2008 7y agoWhile I agree with you, I can imagine people who prefer being blameless towards accidental mistakes (engineer ssh'd into a wrong host and dropped prod DB instead of testing) but demand proper punishment of "misfeatures" created on purpose (like spying on users).
- luckylion 7y ago> until a tech company like Zoom does something they don't like. Consistently does something they don't like. Most people forgive single instances, but they don't forgive patterns as much. Especially when the patterns look like they are on purpose.
- kemonocode 7y agoWell, speaking solely for myself, I am more willing to forgive genuine bugs or even targeted attacks (supposing the company being attacked was doing the right things e.g. no weakly hashed passwords, keeping as little PIA as they can get away with, proper isolation) over misfeatures that hint at deep company culture problems ("Hmmm, how can we profit from our users' data, even though they're already paying us?")
- kerng 7y agoThey are making a lot of money at the cost of putting their users at risk - a big fine seems in order.
- shadowgovt 7y agoOn what legal grounds?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kerng 7y agoGDPR, CCPA, etc. Things are changing in the industry and law makers are slowly catching up to protect their citizens.
- shadowgovt 7y agoI can't help but wonder if a Zoom that had, hypothetically, needed to be ultra-paranoid about GDPR or CCPA compliance would have a product on the market capable of wide adoption at the time the world suddenly needs a videoconferencing tool. Everything has tradeoffs.
- GordonS 7y agoZoom has been around for a while, it didn't just spring up when COVID-19 hit. Which part of the GDPR do you think would have significantly delayed development?
- shadowgovt 7y agoWhich part do we think would be grounds for a lawsuit?
- GordonS 7y agoYou're avoiding my question. I really don't agree with your argument that caring about user security and privacy would have a substantial effect on development time, certainly not in respect of GDPR.
- chronofar 7y agoI agree. I'm just as skeptical as the next person about PR corporate-speak, but there's a clear action plan here and addressing of concerns. At least give them a chance to make good on their claims right? We've become such a cynical culture, once pitchforks are brandished they appear to be unsheathable, rather they grow sharper and more wild as the chorus of internet echos grow. While there is value in discouraging certain behaviors (and thus "make an example"), and encouraging new ones (some level of noise was needed to warrant a response at all), surely there must be a path to redemption, an acknowledgement of misaligned incentives in lieu of the demonization of individuals. There are too many true enemies in the world (most of them not processes not people) to harbor such disgruntlement against a platform which is by at least basic measures doing good (providing a service that is obviously loved and used by many and jobs and economic well-being to those who make and support it). I personally have been wary of Zoom since the first reports of their apps doing shady things (and the forcefulness with which they attempt to make you use it) and don't find it provides any value over a multitude of other services. But this wariness warrants a mere "meh, I'll go elsewhere," not a crucifixion. Yet as the frothiness grows from this current story (and it's really not much of a story) it becomes more difficult to see just what sort of blood sacrifice will satiate the mob.
- short_sells_poo 7y agoI think that's unfortunately a climate that arose as a reaction to the sustained appalling behavior by FAANG and wannabe-FAANG cowboys. When you have a handful of tech companies who systematically, unashamedly and deliberately abuse people's trust and privacy, it ruins the landscape for everyone. As it stands today, our trust has been betrayed so many times that a default assumption that the other actor is malicious and will do the wrong thing is almost always correct. It's a shame, but this seems to be the case for every industry that is consumed by greed, and almost as a rule, every successful industry will eventually be consumed by greed. It's a local minimum that our society in it's current form cannot seem to avoid.
- jospoortvliet 7y agoWell, yes, but now you're saying our trust is limited because other companies do bad. But we have a pretty good reason, beyond that, to not trust Zoom - THEY clearly never gave a shit about security, given in a few weeks of people taking a slightly deeper look we've had pretty much every possible leak and bug and problem you can imagine crop up. How long did it take Microsoft to go from "no-shits-are-given-security" to "security-is-core"? 2 decades, something like that? So yeah, sure, 90 days, that's... well, maybe the beginnings of a start.
- frogpelt 7y agoPeople need to put the pitchforks away. I don't think Zoom has done anything malicious. I think they just built their software quickly and just made it work. Now that it's under a lot of scrutiny they're paying a bit of PR price. But they'd probably do it all over again since they are now seeing hundreds of millions of users.
- jospoortvliet 7y agoYou make it sound like a startup that build a piece of software quickly and forgot a few things. There are two issues with that argument. First, they put in EXTRA effort to break the security of their users. The feature of 'upon de-installation, install a daemon on the system that silently re-installs the app whenever a zoom link is clicked' is MORE work than not doing that, for example. Second, they are 8 years old, have 2500 employees and a revenue of over 600 million. I work at a 30 ppl startup and I would not at all be surprised of we invested more hours in security in 2019 than Zoom did...
- kstrauser 7y ago> another demands their security team be fired. This drives me nuts. Disclosure: I'm currently working in a security role. My company is great, and if someone on my team says "we shouldn't do this", the reaction is to meet and decide how to replace an idea with something that serves the business request and our (and our users') security needs. I love it. But I also know I'm being spoiled here. More common in my experience is: Software engineer: We need to do a thing. Security team: No! We can't do thing at all. It would ruin us. Engineer's manager: We've already started and our CEO promised it to a customer. Do your job and figure out how to secure it. Just saying, cut that group a little slack until we know that someone actually didn't do their jobs.
- lobotryas 7y agoTo be fair sometimes the security team is wrong or being over protective. There has to be a balance because it’s too easy to think of “what if” , Mission Impossible style, scenarios that have no hearing on the real world.
- Medicalidiot 7y agoThe more I'm online the less I feel like there's ever such a thing as over protective.
- kstrauser 7y agoThere's such a thing. You can get asymptotically close to "perfect security", but it really is a risk evaluation game. Is it worth it to spend $20,000 to run a pen test and make sure we're not grossly vulnerable to attack? Sure! Is it worth spending $50B to develop our own hardened OS, hosted inside our data bunker with airgapped servers running on custom CPUs? Probably not. The challenge becomes how to identify when you're as good as you reasonably can be given the threats you realistically face on a budget that doesn't resemble a small country's GDP.
- Medicalidiot 7y ago
- __s 7y agoI'm running Zoom in a virtual machine, & while I'll continue to do so, this news will pause me from recommending others (who are unwilling to sandbox applications) to not use Zoom Still, would like their WebRTC UI improved. The use case I'm in requires gallery view & the web ui lacks that, so I ended up having webrtc streaming me out while using Zoom in Windows Sandbox to view (Sandbox isn't able to use my webcam). "easy to use" wouldn't describe my experience
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- quezzle 7y ago>> One commenter here is asking for more, for punishment, another demands their security team be fired. Internet jerk trolls who feel they aren’t jerk trolls because they feel they occupy some moral high ground. “I’m not a jerk troll cause they’re bad bad!”
- dylan604 7y agoDid they remove the FB SDK completely, or just from the iOS app? The last post I saw from them was just the iOS app, and nearly bragged about it still being part of the webApp. FTA: "On March 27th, we took action to remove the Facebook SDK in our iOS client and have reconfigured it to prevent it from collecting unnecessary device information from our users."
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>This seems to be positive steps, folks. Genuinely not sure what more you could be asking for from a regular for-profit business I don't consider a public company worth umpteen billion dollars to be a regular for-profit business. They had the resources to address these issues before the public attacked them for it, and chose not to. With the same team in charge, why would I expect them to be proactive on similar issues in the future?
- outworlder 7y ago> One commenter here is asking for more, for punishment, another demands their security team be fired Sometimes engineers are clueless, but it is unlikely that all of them are clueless. It's unlikely, unless the company is small, that there's a single engineer that's responsible for something. However, a single person can be clueless and do incredible damage. Such persons are often called 'managers'.
- foobiekr 7y agoAny blog posts that claims enterprises did any kind of meaningful security evaluation is a joke. They say almost nothing about fixing their existing shenanigans nor their past failures in that posting.