15 ms·
Unemployment benefits have been significantly expanded under the Coronavirus aid bill. The benefit amounts will sound small if you're living in an expensive cit
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
Unemployment benefits have been significantly expanded under the Coronavirus aid bill. The benefit amounts will sound small if you're living in an expensive city like SF or Seattle, but $600/week from the federal government and a similar amount from state unemployment insurance means that unemployment benefits can pay up to an equivalent of $50-60K/year right now. That goes a long way in most parts of the country, especially when you're stuck at home. Of course companies are going to opt to shift people to unemployment benefits while they're forced into downtime.
In some situations, people can actually earn more from unemployment benefits by being laid off due to some hasty oversights in the aid package (Reference: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/how-unemployed-workers-could-get-more-than-100percent-of-their-paycheck.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/how-unemployed-workers-could... ). This doesn't account for lost benefits or the risk involved in losing a job, but it could disincentivize people returning to work if it means their income will go down.
Of the many people I know who have been “laid off”, all of them have been told they’ll be first in line to be re-hired the moment quarantine ends.
If a business can’t make money, it makes more sense for them to let employees collect unemployment during the downtime than to overextend the business’s balance sheet. During normal times, this is a common tactic for seasonal businesses. I have friends in seasonal tourism industries who received training on applying for unemployment benefits during their annual off-season layoffs each year. They even have an explicit system for tracking seniority in the re-hires.
Of course, the longer this quarantine lasts, the more likely their businesses are to disappear before they can re-open. Unfortunately we won’t know this number for many months. For now, the initial unemployment claims number can't discriminate between jobs that have been temporarily paused and jobs that have been eliminated.
- aluminussoma 7y agoWhat will the employees, in the US at least, do for health insurance? A pandemic is when you need it. These employees will be strained to pay for COBRA. I fear that we will see revolutions in countries where this is not contained, from either a health or economic perspective. An old saying is that you should buy stocks when there is blood in the streets. I hope that doesn't become literal.
- skellera 7y agoI don’t wish a bad outcome but if it happens, hopefully people realize we need a different system for healthcare.
- ihm 7y agoAlready most Americans support Medicare for all – it’s our bought elected officials who don’t.
- faet 7y agoeh. Most Americans support a public option. M4A is down to about 26% support as of yesterday. https://i.imgur.com/H9bAwV9.png https://i.imgur.com/H9bAwV9.png
- ianleeclark 7y agohttps://morningconsult.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/2003101_crosstabs_POLITICO_RVs_v1_AUTO.pdf https://morningconsult.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/200310... All registered voters supported M4A with ~55% (see POL19) according to a recent poll. I'm not really sure what to do with a twitter image, but I'd be interested in seeing their numbers.
- dwiel 7y agoWhat is the source of that imgur meme? Here is an article with a link to the pdf which claims 55% of voters are in support of M4A https://morningconsult.com/2020/04/01/medicare-for-all-coronavirus-pandemic/ https://morningconsult.com/2020/04/01/medicare-for-all-coron...
- Chathamization 7y ago55% in the latest Morning Consult poll[1]. And this is after a heavy push from the healthcare industry against it, as well as strong opposition from all of the Republican leadership and most of the Democratic leadership. Before the recent blitz against it, polling was 70%[2]. [1] https://morningconsult.com/2020/04/01/medicare-for-all-coronavirus-pandemic/ https://morningconsult.com/2020/04/01/medicare-for-all-coron... [2] https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/403248-poll-seventy-percent-of-americans-support-medicare-for-all https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/403248-poll-seventy-pe...
- boringg 7y agoAgreed though I think you hit the nail on the head...how much demand will there be after the pandemic passes(?). We were at the apex of a bull market, now we're heading towards a deep depression. A lot of those jobs won't exist sadly. This goes for current markets impacted but the ripple effects are pretty large.
- asdfman123 7y agoAnd lots of people don't realize how long this will last. They say we're going to reopen in a month, but right now the curve doesn't seem to be bending significantly. We're not going to reopen when there's way more cases, and that's where we're heading. Also, when we reopen, it will be short term and still pretty locked down. It's absolutely not the end, but a slight reprieve.
- _curious_ 7y agoPlan and prepare for a year and if things clear up sooner, great!
- boringg 7y agoGood points. I would agree that when we do open up (which we will have to) it will be to a very different landscape of people who are much more cautious and have much less disposable income to spend. Without a vaccine, I would be think that infections around the world will keep bouncing around and reinfect countries without significantly coordinated efforts between countries to manage outbreaks or there would be long term shutdowns of trade, people flow amongst countries.
- asdfman123 7y agoThose of us who manage to keep our income will have a lot of disposable income, since we're basically removed transit, eating out, entertainment or vacations from our budgets. But there will definitely be fewer places to spend it.
- treyfitty 7y agoWhile the benefits amount to something small for cities... they've largely been the ones hit the hardest. NYC residents are more or less being ignored in these stimulus packages.
- xwdv 7y agoNYC residents don’t need help, if you can make it there, you can make it anywhere, and if you can’t make it, leave and free up some real estate for those who can.
- ianleeclark 7y agoWhat a cruel thing to say.
- xwdv 7y agoI think it’s fair, given the way people in NYC have treated the underclass for a long time.
- blueline 7y agothe median household income in NYC is $57000. there is a huge amount of people in NYC who make up what you're calling the "underclass".
- ianleeclark 7y agoThis is such an impressively grotesque admission, but it leads me to one question: why do people willing to throw away retail workers, home health care workers, cashiers, and janitors (you know, the most commonly held jobs in NYC) to the plague, care about 9/11? Shouldn't you and others like yourself have cheered it on? They are "people in NYC," after all.
- monktastic1 7y agoWhat? The income distribution of NYC roughly matches that of the USA as a whole. Do you wish ill on the entire USA because a small percentage of Americans have acted unfairly?
- KarlKemp 7y agoThe risk is that the economy might behave like any complex machine, or the electric grid: once it’s turned off, it might take a really complicated sequence of steps to turn it back on again. And unlike machines, nobody knows that sequence for the economy.
- cm2187 7y agoThat's assuming that 1) the said business will still be around after the lockdown (after 2-6 months without revenues), and 2) consumers will not have changed behavior, and I am concerned that people who spent several months watching the economy collapse, and wondering how long before they get laid off, will not start consuming like if there was no tomorrow when the lockdown ends.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoI'd be more worried about lots of low cost consumption. If all these business collapse then land, good, and other things may be super cheap -- we're seeing $10/barrel, even negative, oil -- so you could consume as much as you need, even consume aggressively, but the supply is out of control and won't bridge the gap caused by 6 months of capital starvation.
- apacheCamel 7y agoIt seems like the benefits are there for unemployment (except for the whole healthcare debate) but at the same time, our unemployment systems have never experienced such a stress test. My father and a few close friends have all applied but are still waiting to hear anything back from the offices. I hope the process goes quickly for them and anybody else who is going through this right now.
- veggieburglar 7y agoYeah, I was laid off 3/20 (California) and applied immediately. Got a confirmation number but still haven’t heard anything else. The site was already bugging out and I made it in before the majority of people.
- mrfusion 7y agoI don’t understand the 600$/week? Does everyone get that? Will it be back paid if my state doesn’t process me for weeks? Does my state have to apply for this?
- themagician 7y agoIn many places being unemployed pays more than being employed. Not sure why the downvotes. It’s literally true for the first time ever. The way the new benefits work out your unemployment check STARTS at the equivalent of $15/hr x 40hr/week = $600/wk. In California, for example, you can get up to $1,050/wk instead of the old maximum of $450/wk.
- arbitrage 7y agoGo ahead and name them, please?
- themagician 7y agoMost places. California, New York, anywhere with a decent unemployment insurance program. If you made $15 an hour in California you were making $600/wk. On unemployment you now make $877/wk. That’s a 46% increase. It’s huge.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> In many places being unemployed pays more than being employed. You're being downvoted because you overgeneralized ("many places"), but this is actually true in some scenarios. See "Unemployed workers could get more than 100% of their paycheck under the coronavirus bill" https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/how-unemployed-workers-could-get-more-than-100percent-of-their-paycheck.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/how-unemployed-workers-could... It's a perverse incentive to getting people back to work, so I expect this loophole will be closed soon.
- themagician 7y agoIt’s true in a LOT of scenarios. It’s true for anyone making under $15/hr anywhere, and in some states the break even is $20/hr or more.
- _curious_ 7y ago"I expect this loophole will be closed soon" What makes you think that?
- nck4222 7y agoThis "economy is paused" idea is getting more and more unjustifiable by the day, weeks, and months. We're not going to emerge from this and just hit the unpause button. Yes some industries will bounce back quickly, but 9 million people over two weeks losing their jobs is an absolutely massive number, and we haven't hit peak yet. There's no way they'll just be simply rehired when this is "done".
- walkingolof 7y agoWhat do you base that on?
- pjc50 7y agoDead people can't go back to work.
- malandrew 7y agoBut there will be a lot more job openings for those that can.
- tathougies 7y agoYeah, honestly, people always forget to note that the black plague resulted in significantly higher wages for peasants and artisans.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIf the economy bounced back to what it was on Feb 28th, what is your acceptable number of dead? Would you trade 9 million unemployed for 9 million dead? Do you think that wouldn't have an effect on the market as well? We're in it now, and no amount of wanting to hit the abort button will change anything. It's a fantasy to assume people will just go back to work, the economy will get better, and everything will return to normal, aside from a hot new opportunity for mass body disposal services.
- nck4222 7y ago
- globular-toast 7y ago$600/week after tax is surely a massive amount and enough to give a family a very comfortable lifestyle. I always thought it was cheaper to live in the US than in the UK. That amount here would give you a luxurious lifestyle. What am I missing?
- toasterlovin 7y agoIs $600/week enough to live comfortably in London? It’s not enough to live comfortably in most large cities in the US. Our mortgage payment is $2200/month. And we live in the most affordable large city on the West Coast (Portland, Oregon). LA, SF, and Seattle would all be much more.
- swimfar 7y agoIf by we, you mean two people, then it's $1200/week for the both of you. So that leaves you $2600/month after housing (maybe not including taxes, utilities, repairs). That doesn't seem too bad. Also, you're talking about a mortgage for a property worth over $400k. It's unreasonable to expect that unemployment would be enough to pay everyone's mortgage, regardless of how much it is.
- ModernMech 7y agoNot everyone's spouse would automatically qualify for unemployment. For example, if I make enough to cover the $2600/month rent on my own and my wife is a full-time caregiver for our aging parents, if I lose my job we would only collect one unemployment check.
- toasterlovin 7y agoYeah, if I were planning for that level of income, then we could probably comfortable cover our bills. My wife would have to already have a job. And we'd have a pretty sizable commute to get to work. So, bills would get covered, but life would be a lot less comfortable (though comfortable when compared to not being able to afford the basics). But Portland is pretty affordable. $400k doesn't get you much in California (there are foreclosures in South Central listed for that much on Zillow right now).
- _curious_ 7y ago"unemployment benefits can pay up to an equivalent of $50-60K/year right now." Wow. It's bizarre one can neither create nor add value yet proceed to receive thousands of dollars for an extended period of time (often multiples more than they will ever "pay in" to the system). I know too many people already milking it before the pandemic (including family & friends). I accept that it is their personal choice and I don't get emotionally wound up in it or treat them different, though I do feel sorry for them. Learned helplessness combined with ego/entitlement must be a painful state of cognitive dissonance in which to live. Hard to imagine what this looks like afterwards; it seems like each unemployment instance or broader "depression" further demotivates many Americans while dis-incentivizing the immutable values of knowledge acquisition/application, hard work, sacrifice, risk taking, etc. There is no such thing as free money. Those who think and act as as if are merely being stripped of their human spirit in exchange. Change my view. Edit to add: ya'll can downvote but can't share your own views or debate otherwise?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tathougies 7y agohacker news is a hivemind. I don't agree with everything you say (one can argue there is economic value in staying home during an outbreak of a highly transmissible virus) but I do think you are right in a lot of ways (it's a perverse incentive, and unproductivity should not be subsidized in general).
- elliekelly 7y agoStaying home is productive though. It slows the spread of the virus and adds value (in terms of capacity) to our hospitals and healthcare system. You can think of unemployment benefits as the government purchasing that time from employees and instructing them to use it in the most valuable way to us as a society: do nothing. The person's time is valuable (and so they should be compensated) but the most valuable use of their time in the short-term is to not use it at all. Tech does this all the time. We just call it "rest and vest".
- tbyehl 7y ago> $600/week from the federal government and a similar amount from state unemployment insurance benefits can pay up to an equivalent of $50-60K/year right now LOL. My state maxes at $330/wk and that's taxable income. IDK if the Fed is taxing their payout, pulling other shenanigans (remember Bush II's stimulus checks were a "tax prebate"), or how long they'll pay. $3,720/m is about 60% of my net income, after taxes and benefits. It'll pay my mortgage, utilities, and keep me out of jail for driving without car insurance. That's about it. In a "WAY lower COL area than SF/Seattle." Thankfully not unemployed. Yet.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> It'll pay my mortgage, utilities, and keep me out of jail for driving without car insurance. That's about it. That's the point. It's not intended to replace your job. It's there to keep you afloat until you find your next job.
- bluedino 7y agoHis state pays $330/week, which is $1320/month The other figure was $600/week, which is $2400/month. Neither of which would meet his needs.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> His state pays $330/week, which is $1320/month > The other figure was $600/week, which is $2400/month. The values are cumulative, not mutually exclusive. You don't have to choose one or the other. You get both.
- nck4222 7y agoIsn't the point to be able to sustain someone until they can get another job? What's the point of giving someone enough money to pay their mortgage but not enough to eat, or enough to feed kids? There's more expenses to living than mortgage and utilities. Food, health care, home repairs, funerals, car repairs, etc.