19 ms·
It kills 1% if ICU care is available. It kills a lot more if the healthcare system is overwhelmed. Look at Spain or Italy. Case fatality rate is around 10%. Le
by adrianN 7y ago
It kills 1% if ICU care is available. It kills a lot more if the healthcare system is overwhelmed. Look at Spain or Italy. Case fatality rate is around 10%.
Letting it run its course it needs to infect 60-70% of the population before herd immunity kicks in. 1% of 60% of the population of the US is 2 million people. World-wide you're looking at 45 million people for a very optimistic scenario. The numbers could easily be 5 or 10 times larger. If we're lucky and the number of asymptomatic cases is very high, the numbers could also be lower. At this stage we really don't know, but I don't think it's ethical to take that risk.
- cm2187 7y agoThe case fatality rate is meaningless when testing isn't done extensively.
- adrianN 7y agoI know. But we don't know the true fatality rate yet and we won't know it before it's way too late to act. I don't think it's okay to literally risk millions of lives on the off chance that we missed 95% of the cases with our testing.
- agarden 7y agoThat is a reasonable line of thought, but incomplete. How many lives are we risking by tanking the global economy? That seems like it should be a more quantifiable risk. It becomes a trade-off between the amount of lives we can calculate will be lost via our pandemic-prevention measures (and to what degree of certainty) and the number that might be lost without them (and to what degree of certainty). The trade-off is between loss of lives one way versus loss of lives another way.
- MiroF 7y agoIt is quantifiable, however it appears that periods of economic decline are strongly associated with decreased mortality rates, at least according to the best evidence I can find from Nature.
- throwanem 7y agoOkay, but you have to look at both sides of it. How many people aren't dying in road traffic accidents that don't happen because of isolation? How many people aren't dying of diseases they won't develop because reduced economic output has also reduced the output of carcinogens and toxins produced by manufacturing that's not being done? And like that - those are just the first two examples off the top of my head; there are more. I don't see much mention of this among the "back to work at any cost" crowd, and I wonder why. It seems like a pretty obvious consideration.
- edmundsauto 7y agoExactly this! The WHO estimates that air pollution kills 7M people annually[0]. A really big range of estimates suggest 20-50% decrease in airborne pollutants since the start of the pandemic. Even a 10% decrease, sustained, could save 700k lives/year. Yes, bad economies harm people. But they also reduce harm. Pointing simply at directionality due to a bad economy is disingenuous. [0] https://www.who.int/health-topics/air-pollution#tab=tab_1 https://www.who.int/health-topics/air-pollution#tab=tab_1 [1] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200326-covid-19-the-impact-of-coronavirus-on-the-environment https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200326-covid-19-the-imp...
- buzzkillington 7y agoNow do a calculation that includes a world war with nuclear weapons, because that's what happens when you hit 30% unemployment.
- throwanem 7y agoHow on Earth do you figure that?
- buzzkillington 7y agoA natural outcome when you have 30% unemployment in the worlds largest economies. Who knows, maybe we will get lucky and it will only be civil wars in China and India with only hundreds of millions dead.
- _-___________-_ 7y agoThe comment you're replying to referred to "1% of the people who get it", which has basically nothing to do with CFR. Getting the virus is necessary but far from sufficient to become a case.
- enraged_camel 7y agoNot quite. 1% of people who get it don't survive when healthcare resources are not strained. But when ICUs fill up, that number starts to skyrocket, because people who need intensive care cannot get it.
- _-___________-_ 7y agoYou're really missing my point. CFR is not the percentage of "people who get it" that don't survive. It's the percentage of "people who get it, get tested, test positive and are thus confirmed as a case" that don't survive. The actual mortality rate, whether ICUs are working or not (they mostly are), isn't known.
- dante_dev 7y agoIn Italy you see 10% mortality because Italy tests only (really) sick people. It's really likely that millions of italians have covid. This is not really demonstrable at the moment, but still https://www.wantedinrome.com/news/coronavirus-report-six-million-infected-in-italy.html https://www.wantedinrome.com/news/coronavirus-report-six-mil... Italy is treating every single patient with high standard healthcare. They did not reach the "0 free ICUs" moment yet. What we can say as of today is that the high number of deaths do not depend on overwhelmed hospitals, but likely just because there are A LOT of covid patients. Also a greater average age and the fact that older people are much more integrated in the society played a role affecting mortality, but still those are only theories and we can't say how much they affected the total.
- fock 7y agosick of hearing this silliness: https://www.ecodibergamo.it/stories/bergamo-citta/coronavirus-the-real-death-tool-4500-victims-in-one-month-in-the-province-of_1347414_11/- https://www.ecodibergamo.it/stories/bergamo-citta/coronaviru... so yeah, they barely test half the dead people (which are still double the normal deaths...). And A LOT of covid patients means a lot of deaths as well, bc. at 1.3% (Diamond Princess, where people are still not through it/dying) to 5% letality, the thing IS BAD.
- StillBored 7y agoBut again, what was the age group on Diamond Princes? Because it matters, the death rate goes up with age. 5% says the average age was something like 50.
- MiroF 7y agoA cruise ship skews older and most people from Diamond Princess should be out of it by now.
- fock 7y agowith emphasis on "should". Most people started to argue with the low number of deaths, when there were 5. Now there are at least 10 and about 100 people unaccounted in statistics...
- stefano 7y agoNo one in Italy has ever been denied an ICU bed yet.
- adrianN 7y agoI'd like a source for that because it directly contradicts news reports I've seen.
- dante_dev 7y agoSource is Ministry of Health, data is collected by each Region. Specifically this is the free icu rate per region https://infogram.com/tasso-di-occupazione-posti-letto-1h7k23n1k8vg6xr https://infogram.com/tasso-di-occupazione-posti-letto-1h7k23... Unfortunately it's live without the per-day history, but you should consider that we're at the peak right now. Considering the many people downvoting I feel like US news suggest otherwise. Weird!
- MiroF 7y agoSpain and Italy have fatality rates of 10% because the infection exploded far before they could ramp up testing capacity, so they were only testing the people who were in serious medical distress. This is obvious if you compare the numbers between different countries versus their relative level of hospital capacity.
- jart 7y agoThat was a prediction CDC made in early Feb for broader China. More recent CDC reports for United States (https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6912e2-H.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6912e2-H.pdf) say mortality is somewhere between 1% (lower bound) and ~30% (depending on age) based on calculations they did w/ cases having "known outcomes". The CDC says they only have 44 such samples at this time, and that ICU status data is missing or unknown for the several thousand or so other cases. So we really just don't know the facts yet.