3 ms·
m68k isn't just one person's hobby however - there's a sizeable retrocomputing community around it. > and then either the whole project is getting held up by t
by zozbot234 7y ago
m68k isn't just one person's hobby however - there's a sizeable retrocomputing community around it.
> and then either the whole project is getting held up by that backend, or it just gets removed.
LLVM has a notion of "experimental" backends that's precisely meant to avoid this. Unfortunately it's a bit misused at present, with backends that have little reason to be "experimental" being marked as such for historical reasons, while stuff like m68k (and perhaps this new PPC-based stuff) that could use it gets left out altogether. This should be fixed.
- skissane 7y ago> m68k isn't just one person's hobby however - there's a sizeable retrocomputing community around it. But how many people in that community have the skills to maintain the LLVM backend? I agree it would be great if m68k made it in LLVM, I'm just trying to explain why the LLVM developers seem so hesitant about it. A thought: if there is really enough interest in LLVM for m68k, those interested could set up a not-for-profit membership association with annual dues, and then the association could use those dues to hire a developer to work full-time (or even just part-time) on LLVM+m68k. I think if an arrangement like that existed, the LLVM development team would be far more likely to say "Yes". If 1000 people were all willing to pay $100/year to support this, that would make available $100,000 per annum to fund development.