4 ms·
Why are they calling it a 'phone'? It's a conventional voice radio isn't it? You can't dial anyone. Nobody calls modern military radios 'phones'.
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Why are they calling it a 'phone'? It's a conventional voice radio isn't it? You can't dial anyone. Nobody calls modern military radios 'phones'.
- simonsarris 7y agoall media sites just really like taking neologisms for a walk back in time for some reason. "the computer that the ancient greeks made" "the ancient egyptian automobile" "the subway of pipes underneath rome" etc
- _wldu 7y agoA lot of phone/fone nets have been operating since the 1920s and 30s. Here's one: http://www.vfn3947.net/ http://www.vfn3947.net/
- mulmen 7y agoTelephone literally means “far voice” in Greek. A device does not require a dial pad to be a phone. The article establishes earlier radio communication as using basically Morse code (telegraphy). This is a “phone” because it uses voice (telephony) instead of some other signaling. It’s not a common use of the word phone today but it is a reasonable interpretation based on the technology of the time and how it was used.
- soneca 7y agoI don't think the Greek roots of the word matter to our understanding of the modern word. It does look more like radio and that the words "wireless phone" are there only for clicks.
- perl4ever 7y agoWasn't the telephone switchboard invented a little after the telephone itself? Not to mention, dialing came even later, right?
- dmos62 7y agoIf someone asks you for your phone, you won't ponder if they mean your "far voice". However, if we start discussing what is a phone and isn't (does it have to dial?), then suddently etymology is very relevant. I personally love etymology, because it let's you cut through the not-always-useful baggage accumulated around words.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Telephone literally means “far voice” in Greek. That's not how words work. Dinosaur literally means terrible lizard, but they aren't lizards nor necessarily terrible. > It’s not a common use of the word phone today Lol so why use it in an article today?
- anticensor 7y agoDinosaurs are huge terrible lizards, though.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThis is not a true statement. Dinosaurs and lizards diverged at the lepidosaurs. A dinosaur is not a lizard. They share a common ancestor.
- jhbadger 7y agoThey aren't technically lizards, but closer to birds according to current knowledge (pedants will even say that cladistically, birds are dinosaurs) . But I love etymology despite the fact that neologisms often don't mean literally what the roots say.
- Talanes 7y agoBut they are terrible at being lizards.
- tialaramex 7y agoIt's true that Etymology (the source of the word) is neither Definition (a documented meaning of the word) nor Usage (how most people use a word). Your example of dinosaur is fair for showing this, nobody from the outset conceived of the Dinosaur as really just being a "terrible lizard" (this makes me imagine a very lazy gecko, can't be bothered to actually do much "You are a terrible lizard"). BUT telephones really are about voice communications at a distance and not about the particular mechanics that were popularized with the public telephone network. Telephone "numbers", dialling, all that stuff was added later and isn't part of the telephone concept. So although the Latin etymology isn't why these were telephones, they were anyway.
- Someone 7y agoI wouldn't call this a phone, either, but the distinction is murky. You couldn't dial anyone with early phones, either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_dial#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_dial#History: "The first commercial installation of a telephone dial accompanied the first commercial installation of a 99-line automatic telephone exchange in La Porte, Indiana, in 1892" Phone exchanges were you told an operator who you wanted to talk to are older. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_exchange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_exchange: "The first experimental telephone exchange was based on the ideas of Puskás, and it was built by the Bell Telephone Company in Boston in 1877. The world's first state-administered telephone exchange opened on November 12, 1877" Phone lines that were 1:1 were even older, but not by much (Bell's patent is from 1876)
- kube-system 7y ago'phone' actually is commonly used in technical circles to refer to voice radio communications, in contrast to other modes of radio communication. Example: http://www.arrl.org/files/file/Regulatory/Band%20Chart/Band%20Chart%20-%2011X17%20Color.pdf http://www.arrl.org/files/file/Regulatory/Band%20Chart/Band%...
- close04 7y agoThat's a description of the radio bands. The device itself is never referred to as "a phone". No authority that I know of calls a 2-way voice radio "a phone" unless it's an actual phone (modern definition applies). The article used it to get more clicks but (I assume) an amateur radio operator insisting on wrong terminology is surprising.
- Johnythree 7y agoNot just Bands, but also Modes: Early military radios had a switch labeled "CW" and "Phone". In radio parlance, "CW" was Telegraphy and "Phone" was Telephony, so in this context the term "Phone" derived from the term "Radio Telephony".
- close04 7y agoAre any authority, manufacturer, or expert user officially calling the radios on any plane, ship, etc. a "phone"? Does the FAA, Motorola, any CB operator, police or emergency services ever call their radios "phones"? "Phoning" is used for a lot of conceptually similar or analogous actions without implying the use of an actual phone. Like when a device or software "phones home" without being a phone. The device and the concept of the action are independent. We've called devices "telephones" for more than 200 years now and the earliest ones were just megaphones. Very loose decades or centuries old references to a "phone" aren't relevant for an article written today. My point is according to any reasonably modern definition of the words, what's presented in the article is a radio and not a phone, and the usage of "wireless phone" in the title is just an attention grab. Perhaps "biplanes had those days' equivalent of wireless phones in the cockpit" would have been more appropriate... and less clicky.
- donaltroddyn 7y agoUntil relatively recently, military signallers who carried radios were called Radio Telephone Operators - manuals are still full of references to radio telephones.
- djrogers 7y agoEarly 'car phones' were simply multi-channel 2 way radios with a switchboard at the other end. You'd pick up the receiver, flip to a channel with no voice traffic, announce your personal code (DR83229 for example), and ask the operator to patch you through to a phone number.
- jacobush 7y agoI think boats can still do this with UHF
- Johnythree 7y agoYou probably mean VHF, eg the marine VHF band.
- greglindahl 7y agoThere are things called "radio telephones". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiotelephone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiotelephone
- elliekelly 7y agoBy contrast the device I call “my phone” is almost never used for dialing & speaking to someone else.