4 ms·
What a strange, skewed survey. It seems to pre-suppose a single reason you'd participate in Open Source, then asks a bunch of questions so that you can answer
by jasonkester 16y ago
What a strange, skewed survey. It seems to pre-suppose a single reason you'd participate in Open Source, then asks a bunch of questions so that you can answer "yes, that's right".
None of those questions have an answer I can check that applies to me.
As an example, take the Internationalization library for ASP.NET that I released as Open Source last year. Sure, it's nice to give back to the community and all that, but there's a business reason there as well. It's hosted on one of my product domains, so having developers link to the project has measurable SEO benefits. Weighing that benefit against the negligible competitive advantage of keeping it in-house was the main part of the decision, along with the fact that it was comparably easy to break out as a reusable piece.
"Goodwill" might have weighed slightly, but "Esteem", "Self-Actualization" and all the other tick marks from that survey were never part of the equation.
This isn't limited to small projects, either. Pick any big-name OS project, and chances are you'll find a big corporation or two behind it, promoting (and funding) it to further their own business need.
- redslazer 16y agothanks for the input, basically i only wanted to ask 4 questions Do you participate? Do you get compensated? Tick all that apply 1 Tick all the apply 2 Which would have told me what in essence, i need. People who participate in Open source (for no financial compensation) have fulfilled the needs associated with the bottom 4 levels of Maslow's Pyramid of needs Again thanks for the input, i should have made the survey more open ended and just narrowed down the parts where i needed specific answers