2 ms·
You can't prioritize some content without deprioritizing other content, which effectively amounts to censorship. Algorithmic "timelines" (which aren't timeline
by sneak 7y ago
You can't prioritize some content without deprioritizing other content, which effectively amounts to censorship. Algorithmic "timelines" (which aren't timelines at all) are one of the biggest mass scams ever perpetrated. It allows giant companies to sit and mediate personal friendships, and extract rent for anyone who wants more reach (even within their existing, opt-in audience).
I think daily about ways to get people to stop donating content to these censorship and surveillance platforms. Most people don't run businesses, so they never realize the rent-seeking nature of these jerks.
- onion2k 7y agoYou can't prioritize some content without deprioritizing other content, which effectively amounts to censorship. This would imply HN "censors" the front page. Of course that's nonsense. Sometimes sorting by an algorithm is just sorting. In the case of HN it's up votes, and in the case of Google it's a basket of hundreds of criteria (including up votes if you think of clicks on results as voting). Google probably does have some "censorship" rules like filtering out illegal content, but I'd be surprised if they're not impartial about everything else.
- leeoniya 7y agoHN's front page is heavily moderated/curated; it is far from being purely vote-based.
- sneak 7y ago> This would imply HN "censors" the front page. That’s precisely what they do. Everyone’s allowed to censor what they wish on their own webpage. I, for example, censor from my own webpage (which otherwise contains a lot of information about me) anything someone could use to physically harm me. The issue comes up when the censorship is used, for example, in DMs or timeline posts between friends (as it is on Facebook and Instagram and Discord), versus one’s own content on a webpage. There’s a difference between moderation and rent-seeking.
- notacoward 7y ago> I'd be surprised if they're not impartial about everything else. Assuming impartiality seems awfully optimistic, given both human nature and the fact that Google admits that it is committed to maximizing profit.