3 ms·
"People expect to find their acquaintances to talk to in a messaging application." That hasn't been the case in my use of Skype, for instance. I'm not sure if
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"People expect to find their acquaintances to talk to in a messaging application."
That hasn't been the case in my use of Skype, for instance. I'm not sure if it's changed, but when I used it it had no real name requirement, and the people I communicated with over it had to tell me their Skype usenames out-of-band, like through email or by phone. There was no directory that would have been useful to us, as we didn't use our real names (or phone numbers).
So your assertion that people on messaging applications expect to find their acquaintances (through it) is simply false in the case of Skype, which is one of the most popular messaging applications in existence.
Discord is another extremely popular messaging application that didn't require me to give my name or phone number.
"Signal refuses to keep that database, because it is practically as valuable to adversaries as message plaintext."
And a database of phone numbers is not?
"the "other way" PGP came up with is (wait for it) a global directory of key metadata."
If you're talking about pgp/gpg keyservers, those aren't necessary for communication via pgp/gpg, as keys can be exchanged and verified by other means. Furthermore, the entities (plural) most people communicate through using pgp/gpg (ie. mail servers) don't control the keyservers, so they're not centralized like Signal is. This is a distributed system.
"What you cannot reasonably do is suggest that there was no tradeoff, or that their use of phone numbers is somehow obviously flawed and privacy-hostile."
I can't believe that you can't see that requiring people to hand over their phone numbers is a violation of privacy, or that it could in fact be objectionable to people who care about their privacy. It's even more mind boggling that you'd argue that handing over one's phone number offers more privacy than not doing so.
This is akin to Facebook's real name policy, and arguably even worse, as so much tracking is tied to one's phone.
- shawndrost 7y ago> That hasn't been the case in my use of Skype, for instance. You have misread his point. He's not saying that users expect to see their contacts on their "first load". He's saying they expect to see their contacts after adding them. Skype does fulfill that expectation, by keeping metadata about your contact list on their servers. Signal fulfills that expectation without keeping the metadata, by deferring to your phone's (local) contact system.