4 ms·
"biodegradable" plastics are chains of polymerized lactic acid. Proper disposal requires heat and time, but the chains do break down in nature, and lactic acid
by colechristensen 7y ago
"biodegradable" plastics are chains of polymerized lactic acid. Proper disposal requires heat and time, but the chains do break down in nature, and lactic acid is everywhere, unlike many other "plastic" materials which are much more exotic. (talking about polylactic acid PLA)
It is also true that many plastics are active biologically, mimic hormones, etc. etc. BUT to temper this fear you have to realize that nearly everything is. Many foods, "essential oils", and natural plant and animal exposures have the same sort of hormone mimicry or other biological drug-like interactions which are poorly understood at best.
The point I am trying to get across is that your body is not an impenetrable fortress that new and evil synthetic compounds are attacking. Instead, biological interactions with small effects are everywhere, and while concern about some of them isn't unwarranted, it should be tempered by the idea that these influences abound.
- lukifer 7y agoCool, thanks for those details. I'm certainly not succumbing to any sort of naturalistic fallacy, or any illusion that plastic is in an intrinsically unique category compared to other products. I'm more operating from a general Precautionary Principle, where I want the burden of proof to be on demonstrating long-term ecological and health safety, especially for substances that come into contact with food and water.
- colechristensen 7y agoAbsolutely reasonable. 21st century medicine (and many other fields), in my prediction, will be the century of small effects. The broad strokes are out of the way, mostly, and it's now time for the less glamorous and more numerous small details and ever more complex interactions.
- zxcmx 7y agoIt's difficult because ontologically you can never actually prove something is "safe". It's proving a negative (never any harmful effects). Some harms are subtle or situation dependent, and small effects will only show up under widespread or frequent use. Perhaps deliberately slowed or phased rollout could help. It would also make materials science and the chemical industries "feel" a lot more like medicine. Companies would have to spend billions on studies to get new chemical formulations or materials to market which could have similar effects on innovation (and monopoly) to those we see in the drug market. Not necessarily bad depending on what you value but the effects would be very far reaching.
- lukifer 7y agoGranted. I mean, strictly speaking, we can't prove that the gravitational constant won't change tomorrow. :) But I would like a substantial enough body of evidence from competent and disinterested assessment(s) so that our societies can take the right long-terms risks on new materials (where "new" = less than 100 years). Obviously easier said than done; I like the idea of putting it in the same category as medical treatments (though let's be frank, even that process is hardly flawless).
- jchanimal 7y agoWe only discovered recently that baby powder causes cancer, and it’s not “new”.
- colechristensen 7y agoShrug. You can define "safe" as an absolute and then argue absolute is impossible, yes. It's a bit of a straw man argument though. Or you can drop the binary label and start developing statistics about known effects and outcome ranges. These things can be done; further understanding of bio-chemical systems and simulation makes discovery by widespread experiment less and less extant. The issue isn't that looking for and finding effects positive or negative is hard, the issue is that few are trying and few are interested in the effort. (i.e. most people either have the conservative, 'everything is safe' attitude or the luddite 'everything is bad for you' attitude, and neither involve much discovery)
- tolmasky 7y agoYou can’t drop the binary label if your intent is to do something with the information. Ultimately there will be a “safety” threshold at which these materials would be allowed or not. If the only statement is “we should generally be studying everything more, in an undirected manner with no stated purpose aside from the inherent value of simply knowing more about everything and letting each individual draw their own conclusions”, then yeah sure, but there’s nothing stopping this from happening now, aside from the fact that such a mission statement doesn’t provide particularly strong incentives.
- harimau777 7y agoWouldn't a limited version the naturalistic fallacy be somewhat appropriate here? Until we have better science on the subject[1], it seems reasonable to me to assume that our bodies have had time to evolve and adapt to naturally occurring substances in a way that they haven't to man made chemicals. Of course I'm sure this doesn't apply perfectly, but it seems like a reasonable heuristic. [1] An additional problem is that, even when there is "science", I am often not equipped to determine if it was a sham funded by industry, whether a given chemical is just some functionally identical variant of a potentially unsafe substance, etc.
- lukifer 7y agoLate reply, but yeah, this is roughly my view. I think the Naturalistic Fallacy label should be applied to absolutism: the old/"natural" thing must be good, the new/"unnatural" thing must be bad, both of which are clearly false. But I think there's an argument for taking the history of selection pressures (or lack thereof) into account when making risk assessments. This could also be compared to Chesterton's Fence [0], or even the Lindy Effect [1]. > I am often not equipped to determine if it was a sham funded by industry Yeah, this is a problem. :( While I trust that there are good actors in most subfields of scientific inquiry, many domains (health in particular) are exorbitantly expensive to empirically research, inevitably leading to perverse incentives, or at least the absence of incentives to do thorough and holistic research. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoI wonder how much time they require in a natural environment. I left a small chunk of PLA outside for weeks and saw literally no signs of biodegrading. It might be better than regular plastic but its no banana peal.
- colechristensen 7y agoNo, PLA won't just rot. In industrial composting environments it will be completely gone. In cool dry environments it will last for a long long time. They use PLA in dissolvable stitches (one of a few options) and those thin fibers are dissolved within a few days to a few months. It depends much on environment.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]