3 ms·
Signal and Moxie specifically have outlined their reasons in detail and, by all indications, in good faith. You might not agree with these reasons or think they
by pvg 7y ago
Signal and Moxie specifically have outlined their reasons in detail and, by all indications, in good faith. You might not agree with these reasons or think they are outright mistaken but constantly insinuating that they are acting nefariously is something you should stop doing, at least on HN.
- ddevault 7y agoI have written at length to enumerate the many indications that Signal and Moxie's engagement on the subject has not been in good faith. Exactly what does it take for you to give up the presumption of good faith? How long will you allow yourself to be gaslit by their self-serving lies?
- beervirus 7y agoLink?
- ddevault 7y agohttps://drewdevault.com/2018/08/08/Signal.html https://drewdevault.com/2018/08/08/Signal.html
- tptacek 7y agoI think a reasonable reading of your argument is: "I told Moxie that Signal should be federated and that the Signal application should be deployed officially on the F-Droid app store. He disagreed. Here is why that makes him a bad person..." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723973
- ddevault 7y agoAny onlookers are encouraged to read my actual ~2,000 word article and forward tptacek's ~30 word bad faith reduction of it to /dev/null.
- tptacek 7y agoI stand by my analysis, which is derived from a re-reading of your pointless 2018 post and the ensuing HN thread, and welcome any substantive rebuttal you'd like to generate. By the way: you get a million extra points for ghost editing your Matrix recommendation out of your post after being called out on the fact that it didn't even do E2E by default. It's still right there on Archive.org. If you flip through the Archive snapshots, you even had a changelog on this post at one point!
- ddevault 7y ago>By the way: you get a million extra points for ghost editing your Matrix recommendation out of your post after being called out on the fact that it didn't even do E2E by default. It's still right there on Archive.org. I issued a correction and I'm still the bad guy? You simply can't even pretend to engage me in good faith today, can you?
- kick 7y agoTo be fair, normally when corrections are issued on posts, the corrections are noted. You've even done this before: https://drewdevault.com/2018/02/05/Introduction-to-POSIX-shell.html#fnref:2 https://drewdevault.com/2018/02/05/Introduction-to-POSIX-she... I don't think you're the bad guy here, but the criticism was that you ghost-edited, not that you issued a correction. Of course, your blog is publicly version-controlled, so it probably wasn't intentional on your part.
- tptacek 7y agoUntil November of 2019 your post recommended Matrix (and, a few weeks after you originally posted it, Tox, which recommendation was accompanied by a changelog entry noting the inclusion of Tox). When you decided to stop recommending Matrix, you simply removed the recommendation and the changelog from the post. It's a blog post, not a work of journalism, but I don't think you get to use the words "issued a correction" here.
- 7y ago