9 ms·
Eminently sensible call by Honda. Knobs, dials and switches work well and do not demand that a driver takes their eyes off the road. I suppose that voice contro
by samizdis 7y ago
Eminently sensible call by Honda. Knobs, dials and switches work well and do not demand that a driver takes their eyes off the road. I suppose that voice controls would be a reasonably safe tech option, but probably not cost-effective.
- throwanem 7y agoMy car has onboard voice controls, but, unlike Siri via the car's audio system, they suck. Recognition is slow and unreliable enough that I never bother, and if I did, the cognitive overhead would be unacceptably high anyway. They'd have done better not to bother implementing them at all and instead just offload that work to the driver's paired smartphone, which for a sedan that listed $32k new, it's very reasonable to assume will be present.
- at-fates-hands 7y agoIt's interesting, when I had my Windows phone and linked it with my 2014 Ford Fiesta which had Microsoft Sync, it was incredibly fast, responsive and a joy to use. Once you got the format of your queries down, it was super easy to use. They had a button on the wiper knob. Press it, wait for the beep and your're off and running. It synced up instantly. As soon as your phone was connected via bluetooth, you were good to go. I had a text conversation with my GF back and forth for almost two hours, just by using the speech to text recognition capability of the Sync in my Fiesa, it was really amazing to me how well it worked. My 2016 Toyota Corolla has something similar and pairs with my iphone and its a total nightmare. it takes literally ten minutes for it to sync up. That's after the phone has already been connected via Bluetooth. The command queries don't often work, you have to repeat them several times, and then after three of four times of saying the same thing over and over, you finally just give up. I'm not sure if its just with the iphone, but it really does suck.
- throwanem 7y agoIt might just be the car. Unless I invoke the onboard voice recognition, my Altima essentially behaves as a Bluetooth headset powered by internal combustion, and Siri is as usable that way as via the phone's own speakers and mic. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if that were heavily dependent on the quality of the car's audio system, though; I went for the best available trim package, figuring that if I had to go back to owning a car again then it might as well at least be as comfortable as I could manage, and I might not have so good an experience here if I had economized a bit more.
- Dahoon 7y ago>My car has onboard voice controls, but, unlike Siri via the car's audio system, they suck Using Siri is more dangerous than driving and texting: "Undistracted drivers typically showed a one-second reaction time. Those who used the voice-controlled Apple CarPlay saw a 36% increase in their reaction time, which rose to 57% when they used the touch interface." https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/03/20/new-study-shows-using-apple-carplay-impairs-drivers-reaction-times-more-than-alcohol https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/03/20/new-study-shows-u... Touchscreens should be banned in cars. I bought my car without any for that reason.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwanem 7y agoI'd be interested to see how having a conversation with a passenger lines up.
- perl4ever 7y agoYeah, well, people are selective in their concerns. How much does it affect reaction time to have passengers in the car who you may talk to, or may be doing all sorts of things that distract you?
- saagarjha 7y agoAren't passengers much better to have in your car, because they can "copilot" for you?
- mod 7y agoNo. Even if they were helping, they would have to communicate things to you in a way where you could interpret them and react more quickly than just doing it yourself. Passengers are largely not helping, and certainly are not good at communicating problems.
- perl4ever 7y agoIf you don't stop that right now, so help me, I'm going to turn this car around...
- mihaaly 7y agoVoice command is unreliable. Even human to human level, every safety critical application rely on voice commands has to implement very rigid and strong standards and rules on human speech.
- Robotbeat 7y agoIs taking your hands off the steering wheel much better? Ideally, all controls would be available on the steering wheel without removing either hand. Or, as you say, voice controls.
- nannal 7y agoWhen it comes to it, I don't think it's as bad. In a manual car one hand is often off the steering wheel and that's not detrimental.
- dijit 7y agoThis is a great example of when "perfect is the enemy of good". Humans have pretty good spatial reasoning (proprioception); the notion that touch controls should replace tactile well-spaced controls is dependent on the fact that both senses (sight, spatial awareness) are uncontested. I would argue the point that sight is already in-use and must not be interfered with, if there's an alternative that does not use the same resources. I think of it like hardware acceleration and parrelelisation; the brain has a hardware accelerator for sight, but only one, and has a bunch of cores ready for other tasks, and those other tasks can happen in parallel.
- fastball 7y agoOr you could go for Tesla's strategy, which is try to get self-driving ASAP so you don't have the problem anymore.
- axaxs 7y agoTaking your hand off the steering wheel isn't so bad. It's loss of attention, even for 1 second, that's extremely dangerous. Touch screens make you look away from the road. Knobs and buttons do not. However, jamming them all into the steering wheel may then cause the same problem, as if there's too many things in the same area you'd have to look down to find what you're looking for.
- donaltroddyn 7y agoI'm not at all convinced that voice recognition are better or safer than well designed physical controls.
- nannal 7y agoI'm hoping they take up some kind of googles or periscope like interface.
- ihuman 7y agoHonda cars already have built-in voice controls, plus Siri (and I'm assuming OK Google) if your phone is plugged in.
- mushufasa 7y agohondas have had voice controls for ~20 years. they're in e.g. the 2004 acura tl. simple voice controls are cost effective and already implemented.
- randcraw 7y agoYes but they're uselessly complex. I've owned a top-of-the-line Ridgeline with voice control for over a year and I still don't remember any of the sequences of specific commands it recognizes. Any car needs to be connected to a central server where the processing occurs. Useful levels of voice recognition just aren't going to happen inside the car.
- setr 7y agoThe problem there is that they try to parse voice as natural language -- if they instead made a simple programming language with a consistent format.. you'd be able to process the voice locally (speech-to-text has been mostly effective since like the 95s) and actually make it memorizable and semi-explorable. And if you added a semicolon-keyword like "over" for radio, you'd avoid the issue where it waits a minute to see if you finished, making usage agonizingly slow. But we somehow still haven't reached the point where people/corps finally realize that we simply can't parse natural language effectively
- jsight 7y agoIf they are as good as the ones in my Nissan, they are effectively worthless.
- beamatronic 7y agoMy 2007 Honda already has voice controls. Never use them.
- black6 7y agoI'm still waiting for the convenient floor-mounted headlamp dimmer switch to come back.
- huffmsa 7y agoNow would be a good time, there are very few of us who use the engine disconnect pedal these days.
- eyegor 7y agoWhat is an "engine disconnect pedal"? You rewire the ignition or something?
- mywittyname 7y agoOP is being a smartass. He means a clutch pedal.
- frosted-flakes 7y agoThe clutch pedal disconnects the engine from the transmission.
- icefo 7y agoComplicated way to say clutch
- vidanay 7y agoI don't know of any teenagers who re-wired that switch to cut off the license plate lights....no, none.
- Zenst 7y agoExactly - touchscreen offer no unique tactile feedback you can associate with an individual action. Also when the screen is multi use depending upon options then you really handicap the muscle memory and with that, cause distractions. However, I do feel HUD display tech is one area in which could do with some love as would compliment and be less distracting over a screen located away from the drivers view of vision.
- chc 7y agoI like physical controls better, but I don't think that's a totally realistic contrast. Neither touchscreens nor knobs necessarily demand you look. I've known lots of people who looked while using physical buttons, and I can do my common touchscreen tasks in my car (e.g. switch to Bluetooth, hit play or pause) without looking. I suspect most people will look in both cases.
- lazyjones 7y agoVoice control sucks IMO, even though a lot of people now grow up with Alexa and similar and adapt to the technology. Why does it suck, just like some "smart" buttons? Because it's not obvious what it can do. You have to learn the vocabulary it understands and its other limitations (tone etc.). For example, I tried to get my Tesla to text one of my contacts recently and failed. I didn't know whether it just didn't understand me or was unable to. Good UI are obvious and don't require you to memorize secret capabilities.
- 121789 7y agonot obvious to you. I suspect younger generations won't have much of an issue with this, similar to how millenials learned how to utilize google search easily while it confounded their parents
- nullc 7y agoHave you watched a younger person search? Most of them don't have any clue what they're doing either. Presumably it's just more socially acceptable for older people to admit their ignorance. :)
- BostonFern 7y agoI'm a technologically-inclined 25-year-old, and I've been using voice commands since 2010, but I still think the criticism fully applies.
- ben-schaaf 7y agoVoice control is like trying to use a command line interface that comes without any documentation or completions.
- systemtest 7y agoIn a car it's even worse because you have to tell everyone in the car (or on the phone) to stop talking, give your command, wait for the confirmation and then everyone can continue talking.
- masklinn 7y ago> I suppose that voice controls would be a reasonably safe tech option, but probably not cost-effective. They all suck and they’re literally not workable for rentals. Nobody will waste an hour configuring a rental car’s VA on departure.
- LeoPanthera 7y agoI always hunt down and hit the “factory reset” menu option on every car I rent, though. If you don’t, you never know what weird settings the previous users have changed. I also un-pair all the hundreds of paired bluetooth phones, if the reset hasn’t already done that. I often rent cars where the address book is full of names and numbers from previously paired phones.
- brozaman 7y agoThe previous BMW one is pretty good and requires 0 configuration, at least in Spanish. I haven't tried the new one and my accent is very clear though. It has few functions like call X or go to Y but in my experience, it doesn't do that many things but makes them very well.
- Wistar 7y agoThis past January, I rented an Audi Q7. It was brand new and had the Audi Virtual Cockpit which took me a full two days to grasp to the point where I could use it safely and required me to pull over several times to figure something out. Worse, the rental agency had removed the owner's manuals so I was without reference. One of the goofiest things was that the navigation moving map would mysteriously stop moving--allowing the car (me) to drive off the edge of the map--and didn't allow me to move the map, to re-center by touch, while the car was in motion, instead presenting an alert saying that the action was unavailable while the car was moving. As I was driving in an unfamiliar city, this issue forced me to stop several times so that I could see the map surrounding the car, it was simply horrible. To complicate things, the rental agency had bound the two key fobs together with steel cable. This caused the car to arbitrarily recall the user settings from one key or the other--presumably whichever key it happened to recognize first. This had the effect of making the system behave even more randomly as it unevenly switched back and forth between the two user profiles each time I started the car. Every time I'd think I had tamed the user preferences, the "other" set would get loaded, changing the preferences. I solved this by removing the key battery from one of the keys but even with just a single profile, it was a remarkably trying experience and one that seemed to have been engineered for frivolous, show-offy, reasons rather than solid, task-solving reasons. Mercedes-Benz has, in recent years, also made their UX very flashy and fiddly even though they are not using a touch screen. Just tuning a radio station is a multi-step process requiring the traversal of several menus but lacking the feedback in the sub-menus that is needed to let the user know they have actually made a selection. The user must come back all the way to the top of the menu structure to see if the selection they made two or three steps earlier has had any effect. Just give me a dedicated knob.
- yitchelle 7y agoThis is one direction that I never wanted a car dashboard to go towards. The amount of information packed into a dashboard is overwhelming. Most of them is not relevant to the daily commute. Who wants to know you water temperature measured to a 0.5degC accuracy?
- t0mas88 7y agoThat keys-with-steel-cable thing car rental companies do is terrible. And there is absolutely no point in doing so. Either give me two separate keys so two drivers can use them, or just give me one key.
- gnicholas 7y agoVoice control still isn't there yet. Siri frequently thinks I'm talking to her when I say "hey [kid's name]" — despite the fact that my kid's name shares zero letters with "Siri", either in English or in IPA. This is pretty surprising/disappointing, considering that the /s/ sound is pretty distinct, and considering that I did the "hey Siri" training when I got my phone.
- xeromal 7y agoIt's started working pretty well on my Tesla. I can tell it to set the thermostat, turn on specific heated seats, play music, call or text someone, etc. It's not perfect but it gets better every update and we get an update at least once a month if not more.
- tropdrop 7y agoThinking of voice-activation in a car in lieu of analog manual controls misses the point - perhaps you weren't advocating for it as a replacement, but the article above seems to. There are multiple points of failures for a voice-control only interface for a high-speed moving vehicle: 1. Problems with NLP, and needing to adjust oneself to the proprietary format of this particular car's voice recognition grammar/syntax/parsing/etc. (discussed elsewhere in this thread) 2. Loud location (driving by a jackhammer) 3. Female voices [1] 4. AAVE voices [2] 5. Immigrant voices [1] Some argument can be made that 3-5 could be improved on with larger training sets. Given that we're still working off of much of the same recording equipment that we developed in the early 20th century, this is only true up to a point in regards to #3, since it's difficult to calibrate higher pitched "noise" out and keep higher pitched voices in when they're at a similar range. Even assuming all the above problems are solved, there are still the cases of someone losing their voice temporarily due to illness, or someone speech-disabled but otherwise able-bodied, and the cases of a computer malfunction in the car itself that causes voice recognition to break. I was in such an incident myself quite recently, where a rented Mini Cooper's onboard computer made it appear that the engine was overheating (red hot engine symbol) and that I must cease driving immediately lest the car explodes. After the car was off, the computer malfunctioned so severely that attempting to turn the car on only resulted in a light-up display of every error message the car had. All that to say - voice controls are not a suitable replacement for standard knobs and dials, and the latter should always be available as a reliable back-up method for operating a car. [1] - https://hbr.org/2019/05/voice-recognition-still-has-significant-race-and-gender-biases https://hbr.org/2019/05/voice-recognition-still-has-signific... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African-American_Vernacular_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African-American_Vernacular_En...
- leokennis 7y agoI drive a 2010 Honda Jazz (Honda Fit in the US I believe) and I love it. Not only does it indeed have buttons, but good buttons as well. Clicky where needed, rubbery where appropriate, with the righ amount of resistance etc. Just like the iPhone always has the nicest buttons of any phone. It's a little thing that makes using it a pleasure.
- foxyv 7y agoI love the big knobs and switches on my 2013 Honda Fit. They are big and chunky so it's easy to tell the difference between the vent and the temperature on the AC. Everything about it is simple and ergonomic. Although I kind of wish I went with the manual instead of the automatic sometimes. https://cars.usnews.com/cars-trucks/honda/fit/2013/photos-interior https://cars.usnews.com/cars-trucks/honda/fit/2013/photos-in...
- cjrp 7y agoOur 2008 Honda Civic (EU-spec) was similarly well-designed. Controls you were likely to use while driving (temperature/windscreen-clearing, radio, hazard lights, etc.) were raised up closer to your eye-line[1]. It was a really ergonomic "cockpit" [1] https://www.autocar.co.uk/sites/autocar.co.uk/files/styles/gallery_slide/public/1621111519575581600x1060.jpg?itok=98GkS5IY https://www.autocar.co.uk/sites/autocar.co.uk/files/styles/g...
- fluidcruft 7y agoVoice controls are a living hell with kids in the car.
- smsm42 7y agoVoice controls are nice. Except when you get a sore throat. I'm not talking about disabled people, people with funny accents (everybody speaks English of course and if they don't, they at least speak one of the five other languages we proudly support) and people with non-standard timbre of voice, also.