3 ms·
Had a similar thing happen to a company I was involved with a long while ago. (The VC involved was far from the valley.) In fact, the partner even resigned fro
by gojomo 16y ago
Had a similar thing happen to a company I was involved with a long while ago. (The VC involved was far from the valley.)
In fact, the partner even resigned from our board during acquisition negotiations, because the squeeze he was attempting, enriching his firm at the expense of other shareholders, wouldn't mesh well with the fiduciary responsibilities of a board member.
Some people think using every lever at their disposal to eke out a few extra percent at the last minute proves their business mettle. I suppose they expect – or prefer to guarantee – that this be their last transaction with the others affected.
We wound up acquiescing to his demands to avoid ruining the acquisition. And most of us resolved to never do business with him or his firm again.
If another acquisition materializes, you may just have to acquiesce and/or play chicken/hardball with this VC – all the while hiding any internal dissent from the acquirer, so that ultimately it's up to you and your investors whether you walk away from a deal.
If he's a bit player at a larger VC firm, you might privately share your concerns with other more senior partners there – which almost always would be a relationship-destroying maneuver, but if the relationship is already kaput, why not?
Hardball might involve having your own lawyer find the maximum you can do under the investment agreement without the VC's agreement – asset sales, de facto liquidation, etc. – or find grounds to (credibly threaten to) sue the VC for breaches of various duties.
- throwaway5317 16y agoIt was very valuable to hear of a similar situation. I'm happy to hear that you were able to rescue the deal, albeit paying a heavy price.
- gojomo 16y agoI believe the net price wasn't that heavy, but it stung, because it broke the all-in-it-together logic that otherwise had ruled. It was already a good result for the investor – the last-minute extras demanded weren't a part of any prior negotiated preference, they were just new things extracted in return for not vetoing a deal everyone else wanted.
- chipmunkninja 16y agoThe biggest lesson I've learned from various startups is that "all-in-it-together" is an awful lot like asking "How are you?" (The correct answer is "Fine!", even if your arm just got torn off, your cat died, and your spouse left you for a monkey): It's conversation, and nothing more. In the end, everybody is unpredictable. If you don't protect your rights from the start, you'll have problems. Even (especially?) if you're BFFs, everything should be spelled out in advance, including metrics for conceptual terms such as "success", etc.