8 ms·
Amazon warehouse workers are walking out and Whole Foods workers are striking
- djohnston 7y agoThe crisis has provided a lot of leverage for these workers, but large-scale unemployment has also made replacing them easier than ever before. Will be interesting to see what happens here.
- oarsinsync 7y agoLets hope "the right thing" and the companies start treating their employers better. Otherwise, the onus is on the rest of us to remember how these companies value human life.
- djohnston 7y agomy gut tells me that, given the public support for essential workers rn, and the meager demands, amazon will accept the terms
- Kaiyou 7y agoNo one cares that their products are made possible by literal slave labor. Most people care so little, they aren't even aware which of their belongings are made possible through slave labor. You really think anyone is really concerned with how companies treat human life? Concerned enough to sacrifice their own benefits instead of just parting with pretty words? I don't think so.
- op03 7y agoPeople care. It's just that things break down in hyperefficient settings (factories, warehouses etc) when unpredictable events hit them. These environments aren't great at adapting quickly to things they haven't faced before. Before anyone with decision making power or imagination, can be pulled in to deal with some issue, (that no one has training or experience to handle on the front lines), it's already all over social media and the news. That's just how things work currently. Give it a few days before reacting to whatevers on the net or on the news.
- bluntfang 7y ago> People care. They really don't. If people cared, Nike wouldn't use child slave labor.
- oarsinsync 7y agoSome people can afford to care and don't. Most people just can't afford to demonstrate they care. If you're part of an exploited underclass, feeding your family has to be more important.
- Kaiyou 7y agoThat's just an excuse to shift responsibility. In a kill or be killed situation, you could always choose to be killed instead of killing, you'd just have to sacrifice your life. It's just that people don't actually care enough to give up their life or any of their benefits. It always comes down to the fact that people will not give up their own benefits for someone else. If you want people to do something you have to appeal to their self-interest, not their morality.
- matz1 7y agoMaybe but most people don't, I certainly don't. I care cheaper price and fast shipping.
- rumanator 7y agoThe reputation hit that Amazon is setting itself to take due to the ongoing treatment of some of its staff might do more harm to it than just keeping the company's staff happy.
- gutnor 7y agoThere is a "Fight club" feel to this crisis. All the "key worker", necessary job that need to be done regardless the catastrophe society is facing are literally the least desirable job on the market and often the least paid too. Hopefully there is going to be wake up call in society. Surely a large scale demonstration like this would convince people that your "free market capitalistic assigned worth, i.e. your salary" is not a sufficient measure of your value in society and external adjustment (eg: government regulation or welfare or ...) is actually quite reasonable.
- Kaiyou 7y agoWhy would it be reasonable? If you're not willing to perform a job at the current pay grade, just quit your job. Either you get replaced immediately or you've got yourself a chip in your salary negotiation.
- rumanator 7y ago> Why would it be reasonable? If you're not willing to perform a job at the current pay grade, just quit your job. That is not an option for those living paycheck to paycheck, or not in the prime of their life. Human beings are not a resource, and managers need to understand that there is a social cost they pay and thus need to comply with a social contract.
- Kaiyou 7y agoIf you are living paycheck to paycheck and don't have enough funds to survive a year without positive cash flow, you yourself are to blame for your misfortune. If you got the money to buy a phone, you got enough income to save up and not saving up was a personal decision. You reap what you sow.
- danharaj 7y agoWe live in a society poindexter.
- strict9 7y agoRight now public sentiment is highly favorable to the people left enabling online shopping, groceries, and prescriptions. Workers are easily replaceable at the moment, but companies should tread carefully in treating workers as expendable. In a time of crisis legislation, investigations, and executive orders have a way of happening a little faster than normal.
- habosa 7y agoTells you a lot about why "the market" won't always give you the outcome you're looking for. People value delivery more than ever right now. It's literally saving lives. However that value does not result in the people taking risk to provide the delivery getting any more money. As others have mentioned these workers have so little leverage right now because of the massive unemployment. So even if Amazon was to charge customers more, they could totally just pocket the money and the warehouse/delivery/grocery people would have no position. It's so completely unfair. Everyone risking their lives to feed us right now should probably be making 2-3x normal pay (and we should be paying a lot more for their services).
- monkeynotes 7y agoAsking people to pay a lot more when many of the people who will be paying that premium are now unemployed is gonna hurt those who are most in need.
- kiliantics 7y agoWhich is why the government should step in and impose rent freezes and increase unemployment pay, as they've done in other countries.
- de_watcher 7y ago2-3x normal pay? I once thought that militaries must be paying fortunes for what those people do...
- Mediterraneo10 7y ago> I once thought that militaries must be paying fortunes for what those people do... The vast majority of people in modern militaries will never see combat. They are all somewhere relatively safe and merely supporting that small minority of troops who will see combat. Consequently, it is no surprise that pay is fairly low. But in the private security world – people guarding Western and Chinese interests in unstable developing countries – those people are likely to get involved in some shooting, and so their salaries and benefits for loved ones are very high.
- DrWumbo 7y agoThis is a company that pays almost no Federal taxes, whose employees are forced to seek aid from the Federal govt. The least they could do is offer paid sick leave for those affected. Hardcore capitalism is doing as much harm to the US during this crisis as the virus itself.
- barry-cotter 7y ago> This is a company that pays almost no Federal taxes Indeed, if you reinvest almost all your profits in the business instead of taking them as earnings you pay very little in taxes. Taxing investment would be a very stupid thing to do since it would discourage what makes society richer in the long run.
- matt_the_bass 7y agoIf the issue was that simple ans black&white then bezos would not have his fortune. Amazon has gamed the system.
- barry-cotter 7y agoPlease explain how Amazon has gamed the system, or how Bezos being rich is incompatible with Amazon paying little in tax because it reinvests almost all profits.
- veggieburglar 7y agoAmazon was one of the original “disrupters”, taking out regular retail by not charging sales tax for the first decade of its existence. One might argue this gave them an unfair advantage over conventional retail, allowing them to gain a foothold faster than they might have otherwise. Anecdotally, I absolutely and conscientiously used Amazon as a way to avoid paying sales tax when I was younger and less financially stable.
- gimmeThaBeet 7y agoI would argue the income tax issue is that simple. The bet Amazon made was that profits didn't define the valuation of the business. The part that wasn't black & white was that folks were split on whether he was a genius or a scam artist running a book retailer with a 400+ p/e ratio. Gaming the system is what I'd call their sales tax treatment. They didn't collect it everywhere until they got so large that they're warehouses and datacenters were everywhere. And depending on jurisdiction I think its the 3rd party sellers' responsibility where possible.
- throwawaysea 7y agoAmazon has already increased both normal and overtime pay for these workers, and instituted lots of reasonable changes in their stores and fulfillment centers. See https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/amazons-actions-to-help-employees-communities-and-customers-affected-by-covid-19 https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/amazons-actions-to... These strikes just seems opportunist. For those saying “workers should get PPEs” - how? There’s a shortage and medical workers are a higher priority since they’re more likely to be infected. And clearly, online shopping is popular these days and important to keep operating while there are shelter in place orders. Grocery stores are also important to keep operating. These workers are free to forego their jobs and go home. Amazon should just replace them and move on. There will be many others who are willing to work.
- ForHackernews 7y agoGood for them. I guess I won't hold my breath for AWS SREs to go on strike in solidarity, but if there were ever a time it would be now. Edit: No strike threat, but there's a petition here https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/amazon-must-protect-workers-and-community-from-covid-19 https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/amazon-must-protect-work... Better than nothing!
- kiliantics 7y agoThis is why we need a tech workers union
- throwawaysea 7y agoSo those whose views are different from union leadership can nevertheless be compelled to lend weight to those views? No thanks.
- kiliantics 7y agoIt's called solidarity. You acknowledge that more vulnerable people can benefit from your support, such as the fulfillment centre workers being supported by the SREs in this case. But if you only care about yourself and never worry that you might need support from others some day, then yes, I suppose it's not really for you.
- npo9 7y agoWhat are the chances that these strikes can lead to a union? I imagine a grocery store workers union could do a lot for the health of its workers now.