4 ms·
Chinese speaking people are stubborn(from my point of view) about reading Hanzi/Kanji in their sounds, so landmarks in Chinese pronunciation aren't really loanw
by numpad0 7y ago
Chinese speaking people are stubborn(from my point of view) about reading Hanzi/Kanji in their sounds, so landmarks in Chinese pronunciation aren't really loanwords. It's like someone sees "хорошо" and pronounce it "soppovo" because that has to be correct to them, but that's their thing(both ways) and it's not practical for single person to keep up with every pronunciations of Hanzi derivatives anyways so people just read the way they perceive.
Which, I think, also means a Japanese word in a Chinese dictionary is not an implication of acceptance as a loanword since that process is very deterministic.
- kazinator 7y ago> aren't really loanwords Place names aren't loanwords, which is why I called them "exonyms": foreign names for places that differ from their local names. E.g. Japan is an exonym for Nihon.
- dheera 7y agoPlot twist: Actually, the word "Japan" is thought to come originally from an earlier Wu dialect of Chinese pronounciation of "日本". In modern Shanghainese, it's roughly "Zeppen".
- spacehunt 7y agoIf you consider that there's really no such thing as "Chinese pronunciation" -- Chinese is a writing system for a group of spoken languages such as Mandarin, Shanghainese, Cantonese -- then it makes sense that people are used to read the characters in the spoken language they are most familiar with. In fact Chinese speakers do this even for Japanese and Korean names that aren't originally written in Kanji/Hanja. Japanese speakers used to do this to Chinese exonyms also, but generally don't anymore; nowadays they tend to take the characters (sometimes with the writing slightly changed) and annotate the reading (furikana) with the native pronunciation using Katakana.