3 ms·
I don't believe that claiming a group on average exhibits more of a characteristic is a generalization. And I don't think nationalism is when someone talks abou
by sudosysgen 7y ago
I don't believe that claiming a group on average exhibits more of a characteristic is a generalization. And I don't think nationalism is when someone talks about average characteristics of the population of a nation.
EDIT: I forgot to add, I don't really think that a community with 50% of it's citizens being in one country is highly international.
- dang 7y agoIt is, relative to the assumptions people usually make about the HN community. The other common wrong assumption is that HN is concentrated in or somehow represents Silicon Valley. In fact less than 10% of the community is in SV and the majority of the userbase, if anything, identifies against it. Incidentally, many of the HN members in the US come from other countries, so 50% is a lower bound. By the way, I think you may be using more precise definitions of some of these words than I am. That's because I'm commenting about this strictly from a moderation point of view. If you post pejoratives about "average characteristics of the population of a nation", we're going to get a flamewar whether you intended it or not. And it's going to be about national characteristics, hence the phrase "nationalistic flamewar". The thing we care about is convincing users not to post to HN in ways that are guaranteed to lead to shitty, nasty discussion. You're no doubt right that some of these topics can be discussed in ways that are not ideologically nationalistic, just like a high-energy physics lab can work with high temperatures without burning down the building, but this is the internet and those distinctions don't apply.