3 ms·
> As scientists, the base of our work is to read papers and search for bibliography. A huge part is distinguishing good articles from bad articles. Do you thin
by gus_massa 7y ago
> As scientists, the base of our work is to read papers and search for bibliography.
A huge part is distinguishing good articles from bad articles. Do you think all peer review articles are correct? In which field do you work?
Let's analyze the first article you linked. It's the previous article about this topic of Raoult, not an independent research. Did you notice that he control group is not randomized, and most of it was in others hospitals, so it's not clear that they have the same treatment and same prognosis.
Also they are not counting the 6 patients that they lost in the treatment group (1 just leave, 1 had too much nausea, 3 where transfer to ICU, 1 died).
It is more strange that they didn't lost any patient in the control group. (Someone gave an answer to this in a previous thread. Can you spot it in the paper? Do you think after this that calling the other bunch of people a "control group" is accurate?)