9 ms·
E-VENT: Emergency ventilator design toolbox
- Jim- 7y agoI wonder if it will actually get built and used due to the critical nature of the Medical Field, even amidst this emergency. The good thing; at least you'll have a working Ventilator. On the other, your life depends on this frankenstein'd together machine made with hospital spare parts.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIt's not as bad as you think. The ventilator is only one part of the solution. There are also sensors for heart rate and oxygen consumption, maybe even CO2 (though that's expensive) and Human beings involved in monitoring everything. First, most of these patients are probably not completely breathing-depressed to the point they don't breathe on their own at all. That extends the time necessary to fix anything. If indeed one of these ventilators malfunctions, it is probably visible at once. In case of loss-of-function an operator can immediately grab the bag and resume ventilation. In other failures he can disconnect the device and reconnect a non-mechanized manual bag in seconds. This can even be done by volunteers with minimal training, in such emergency situations.
- coliveira 7y agoKudos to the MIT group, but I think the problem of ventilator shortages has nothing todo with technology (this is old, well understood tech), but the lack of leadership in mobilizing industrial production to supply this lifesaving equipment. Since the early days of this crisis this country should had mandated companies to produce record levels of ventilators, masks, vests, and other equipment that are now needed to save lives. On the contrary, the federal government is up to this point dilly-dallying about how to procure and produce ventilators, without a clear solution in sight.
- mdorazio 7y agoHow exactly do you mandate companies produce something which they don't even have the parts to make? The problem is not manufacturing capacity or will, it's that supply chains for medical devices are global and those supply chains have been broken. Increasing production of something like ventilators purely domestically requires increasing (or building from scratch) production of the components, which requires new or re-tooling, sourcing of raw materials, etc. Yes, the current federal mismanagement of the whole crisis is awful, but even if everyone had acted quickly, there would still be shortages. Covid spreads faster than device production.
- coliveira 7y agoI can guarantee you that this country has the industrial capacity to produce any kind of parts, especially for a well known technology like ventilators. The fact is that they are not doing it because nobody alerted and told them to do so three months ago.
- freeopinion 7y agoI'm not convinced that it would have been reasonable to do so three months ago. Three months ago there were rumors that there was something brewing in some part of China most people had never heard of. I point this out to suggest that your expectation might be a little unfair. If such an order had gone out one month ago it would have been controversial. But if you want to say that the administration is a month behind in their reactions it would be more fair. You seem to have observed that a giant beauracracy is reacting weeks behind a crisis and this seems to upset you.
- coliveira 7y ago> Three months ago there were rumors that there was something brewing in some part of China I disagree. Anyone paying attention knew, in the first weeks of January, that something very dangerous was happening. Moreover, we cannot equate the US government to a common person. They have the most expensive intelligence apparatus in the world. And we have an expensive government exactly to protect the population against real threats like this.
- riedel 7y agoThere are multiple university projects out there: https://www.coresponse.rwth-aachen.de/cms/~gqged/Coresponse/?mobile=1&lidx=1 https://www.coresponse.rwth-aachen.de/cms/~gqged/Coresponse/... Currently also at least the 3d prototyping facilities of automotive manufactures are being used for such purposes. However, I really want to see those devices saving lives instead of generating news reports. We already have shortages of intensive care in the grand est and in Italy. I don't think people there have the time to read tech reports and try out all the design.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoAs far as I understood it, the commercially available ventilators are too complicated to ramp up production quickly. Patents and regulation also complicate things. This device doesn't have that problem. I can recognize most components as either off-the shelf or easily manufactured.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>As far as I understood it, the commercially available ventilators are too complicated to ramp up production quickly. Very true, but USA, China, EU, Russia, India etc have their militaries ready to go with Plan A, B and C, they don't order bullets once invaded. We all knew that pandemics are part of life, so we should have had warehouses full of this stuff. USA is spending about $700 BILLION a year in military matters and untold trillions in Afghanistan and Iraq. So, at least USA does not need an open source one, we can afford to pay whatever price they sell it for. They neglected this and of course now it's too late. 100K ventilators at, say,$25K each = $2,500,000,000 unless I made a mistake. What's $2.5 Billion to USA?
- bayesian_horse 7y ago$2.5 Billion is a lot to the US, especially if it's taxpayer money for a public health issue. But actually pretty much all countries have stumbled into the same problem. A respiratory pandemic of this magnitude wasn't anticipated by anyone, for reasons that should be investigated further. Now it's very easy to say there should have been a bigger stockpile, but a lot of the voters, especially in the GOP are quite sensitive to government spending, especially for healthcare. And it's important to remember that there are probably other things countries need stockpiles of, with a similar anticipated risk. For example dialysis machines for a kidney disease pandemic. These things add up quickly, and all you can do is make an educated guess of how far to anticipate any such threat.
- foobarian 7y ago> A respiratory pandemic of this magnitude wasn't anticipated by anyone, for reasons that should be investigated further. Right, we had close calls in the near past, but why did they not spread like this one?
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> I think the problem of ventilator shortages has nothing todo with technology isn't the problem economy of scale? at peak, the US needs 25k-30k ventilators for a few days, and then 90 days later we don't need anywhere near that number. where do we store them? how do we justify the expense? etc. especially if 70-80% of people who still get a ventilator die [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22730622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22730622
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> where do we store them? how do we justify the expense? You either store a large surplus of them in warehouses, or ensure you can rapidly manufacture them even if the world around you goes to hell. That should be the responsibility of governments, and it's one of the main reasons to even have one - a government doesn't have to justify everything in terms of costs, it can evaluate some non-profit metrics like, I don't know, saving lives in case of emergency. Alas, something happened after the Cold War, all western nations went collectively insane, and got rid of most emergency surpluses and any kind of buffer in the system.
- justin66 7y ago> at peak, the US needs 25k-30k ventilators for a few days, and then 90 days later we don't need anywhere near that number. Those numbers are way off. NYC alone needs 30k machines.
- tlrobinson 7y agoI can't find it at the moment, but I recall seeing a report from China that 80% of COVID-19 patients placed on ventilators still ended up dying. I assume that's not the case in the US? (does anyone have stats on this yet?) I also recall seeing (again, can't find it right now) a scientist concerned about the potential for widespread usage of ventilators to rapidly increase the prevalence antibiotic resistant bacteria. My point is, having as many ventilators as we need is good, but it's even better to not need the ventilators in the first place. I hope we don't fixate on ventilators too much at the expense of mitigation and other treatments.
- Green_man 7y agoA doctor on the twiv podcast in America said that about 50% of his patients died after getting put on ventilators. https://podcasts.google.com/?feed=aHR0cDovL3R3aXYubWljcm9iZXdvcmxkLmxpYnN5bnByby5jb20vdHdpdg&episode=NDMwNzJlMTEtNjZjMy00Njk0LTlmMjctZDVmMmE5YWFkMmI5 https://podcasts.google.com/?feed=aHR0cDovL3R3aXYubWljcm9iZX... It's about 15-25 minutes in if you want to hear the full quote.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoThat figure is meaningless because he can't account for the people who are still on a ventilator on the moment and will eventually die.
- Green_man 7y agoyeah, I wish i had a study or something, but I happened to be listening to the podcast right when I saw the parent question. the guy was an immunologist iirc, so he has some statistical background. He probably was counting patients who either died or got off the ventilator, but I don't know for sure.
- aidos 7y agoPresumably you can compare people who die vs those recover and no longer need the ventilator. The number that recover after being on a ventilator (for say, 2 weeks, or something) would seem to provide more information (though I suspect it may be a little harrowing to hear the number).
- Palomides 7y agonone of the hospitals in my area are accepting amateur-manufactured equipment or PPE, so I wonder a lot about these efforts. I have a 3D printer, so I think I'm waiting until they get desperate.
- wegs 7y agoIn my area, they're burning through PPE like there's no tomorrow, and complaining about shortages. When the crisis really hits, that's when they'll need to go for amateur-made, reusing, and working naked. The lack of foresight in this whole situation has been astounding.
- reaperducer 7y agoThere were pictures out of New York over the weekend of hospital workers using trash bags as gowns. The only people who dislike "amateur" equipment are the paper-pushers who are safe at home behind their keyboards and screens.
- snapetom 7y agoYeah, I agree. At best, I think it's people trying to help, but I doubt they'll get anywhere. I worked on an ML project for a hospital as late as last year. The FDA was clear - we could develop it in house and use it as a clinician tool, but productizing it outside the hospital it was nearly forbidden. One generic model for all patients and that model had to have FDA approval. Any changes at all required FDA approval. This was what our legal team and a partner vendor interpreted. "The FDA doesn't want someone in a basement with no medical knowledge marketing a medical device," said one person. These amateur ventilators seem like the kind of stuff the FDA wants to prevent.
- jacobsenscott 7y agoKaiser is accepting donations of homemade masks https://lookinside.kaiserpermanente.org/donate-ppe/ https://lookinside.kaiserpermanente.org/donate-ppe/
- geomark 7y agoIn my area (not in the US) we are making homemade face shields. Simple hand made construction, no 3D printer required. Hospitals are happy to get them because they go through them like crazy.
- nimbius 7y agonot seeing any value from MIT here other than an opportunity for them to ink a quick patent. Heres something more feasible if you're looking to endorse or support an effort: https://opensourceventilator.ie/ https://opensourceventilator.ie/
- ecopoesis 7y agoStudents built this in 2010.
- dang 7y agoThere are a number of projects among recent ventilator threads, if anyone wants to compare: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=Ventilator%20comments%3E3&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- app4soft 7y agoPLEASE, Let's collect all Open-Source Ventilator projects in single article on Wikipeda![0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_ventilator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_ventilator
- mcguire 7y agoAnd include data on which ones have been tested for safety.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoWhat could do wrong if you use one that is not tested for safety?
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoLung perforation. Inadequate ventilation. Aerosolization/Contamination. Suffocation. Death. You know, bad stuff.
- chromaton 7y agoThe real fallback for lack of ventilator machines is the use of the bag valve mask. This is a manually operated device, no motors or electronics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bag_valve_mask https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bag_valve_mask I have to assume this is more reliable than whatever somebody hacked together in their garage. Your average builder may be able to make something that works OK in testing, but having it work 24/7 by people unfamiliar with its quirks is a different matter entirely. The official word out of New York is that they are going to use bag valve masks when they run out of ventilators and train people how to squeeze the bag.
- rabboRubble 7y agoMy understanding is that squeezing the bag would have a high risk of covid infection. The only way this solution would help the curve is if covid survivors were doing the squeeze.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoThe proposed system uses exactly such a thing. But a mask doesn't work because you want to put pressure into the lungs, not inflate the cheeks. Masks only work temporarily to assist a patient that is still breathing relatively well on his own. And there is nothing technically preventing the use of those bags right now. But you'd have to have one person standing beside each bed, 24 hours a day. Which means a hell of a lot of foot traffic, and those will get infected with a high probability. They also need to be trained to a minimal standard. It's not practical.
- AstralStorm 7y agoMasks do and can increase pressure in lungs, the reason intubation is used is to provide fluid drainage, prevent choking. So that the critical patient does not drown. Other than that, they're equivalent. Cheeks can puff out only so far.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoI have never used masks that way and I would worry about the fit. But it may be possible, temporarily, especially when you hold it down. Procedurally most physicians seem to reach for the intubator as soon as there is any trouble breathing, even though that takes longer than putting on a mask.
- saadalem 7y agoThere is a ventilator concept(with pressure booster double acting) that's fully mechanical and very simple that can be plugged into an air supply or water supply to power the ventilator. It sould easily be made and used anywhere in the world at home, ICUs and ambulances. The ventilator could operate without any power source at all. It can be powered by water (even by any tape) You can easily add adjusting stroke length & volume of breath, cadence, ratio of inhale/exhale, connecting many ventilators to one system etc.. Let me know and feel free to develop the idea further !
- raphman 7y agoA condensed recent Twitter rant of mine regarding this influx of DIY ventilators based on bag-valve masks (BVMs): There are quite a few BVM-based ventilators being designed right now. However, there are a lot of caveats I have become aware of. In short: ventilators for use in intensive care need to be safe and adjustable. Oh, and it is not clear whether ventilators actually change the outcome. Lungs of COVID-19 patients are often damaged, and ventilation causes additional damage. As the patients' alveoli no longer capture enough O2, you need to increase air pressure to force more O2 into them. More pressure = more damage to alveoli, so you need to be very careful. So you need to be able to adjust the pressure curve very finely. None of the BVM solutions I have seen so far has such a feature. COVID-19 already causes severe lung damage in some people - you don't want to damage them even more due to wrong ventilation. Unlike emergency care (where BVMs are usually used), intensive care of COVID19 patients needs to play the long game. AFAIK, patients need constant care, supervision and medication over a period of 10+ days. Any damage you cause to the lungs early on will make it harder later on. But won't it be better to keep people alive with a simple ventilator even if they will suffer lung damage? Maybe not. I am aware of the gut-wrenching situation doctors face in Italy and elsewhere - deciding whom to connect to the few available ventilators. It seems (I'm not really sure about it yet) that ventilators just delay inevitable death by a few days in most cases. A study from Wuhan notes: “32 patients required invasive mechanical ventilation, of whom 31 (97%) died.” [1] "Not everyone is a good fit for ICU. Even outside of COVID, if you are of a certain frailty and you have certain underlying conditions, your chances of making it off a ventilator when you are deathly sick is close to 0%." [2] So the question is indeed whether one should really extend a patient's suffering for a few days or whether one should instead focus on making their last few days as comfortable as possible, and give them the chance to stay conscious and say goodbye to family. Even if there is a subset of patients who might benefit from a BVM-based ventilator (and I am not sure about this), I would be very hesitant to rely on them. If a motor burns out, a tube gets loose, or a microcontroller goes crazy, the patient might choke, panic, even die. None of the DIY ventilators has gone through rigorous testing yet. None of the ones I have seen has backup mechanisms (spare motor, continuous surveillance of all parameters, fail-safe power supplies, etc.) I would not want to inflict them on dying patients - or caregivers. This leads me to the most important point: the most severe bottleneck are qualified professionals. Should we really hand these people some DIY Arduino-based ventilators that might fail any moment, that lack important features, and that need additional training? A ventilator that malfunctions at the wrong time (or does not reliably function at all) will take away time and attention from exactly those people whom we really don't want to get distracted or burnt out. There is a UK government guidance which gives a good overview of essential requirements for ventilators [3]. It states: "A ventilator with lower specifications than this is likely to provide no clinical benefit and might lead to increased harm, which would be unacceptable for clinicians and would, therefore, not gain regulatory approval." Disclaimer: I'm no expert on medical tech or intensive care. I have just followed a few of those projects over the past weeks and read reports of experts. It could be that I am wrong and those projects will save many lives. There could also be use cases where DIY ventilators may help (e.g. in home care). But overall, I am rather skeptical and would rather suggest focusing on stuff that might be more useful. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140673620305663?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S014067362... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fnl0n6/im_a_critical_care_doctor_working_in_a_uk_high/fla5579/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fnl0n6/im_a_cr... [3] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-ventilator-supply-specification/rapidly-manufactured-ventilator-system-specification https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/coronavirus-covid...
- pugworthy 7y agoRight now I'm doing a lot of research into GxP for a life sciences project I'm working on. Quoting something I found online... "GxP is an acronym that refers to the regulations and guidelines applicable to life sciences organizations that make food and medical products such as drugs, medical devices, and medical software applications. The overall intent of GxP requirements is to ensure that food and medical products are safe for consumers and to ensure the integrity of data used to make product-related safety decisions." I would guess that the GxP mindset is lacking in a lot of these projects, and in truth it would be a burden to progress to be full in on it. But that said, I do hope people who are doing these things are at least aware of the importance of data integrity and a very good log of their work. Don't just record what works, but also record what doesn't work. If a motor, or an Arduino, or any other part fails on you or you find that using a cheap one leads to issues, this is REALLY important to record and note for the record. This is especially true for anyone attempting to duplicate your work. That said, it's worth noting that the site specifically states that... "We are working to submit a specific variant of the MIT E-Vent design to the United States FDA for review under the Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) authority." and "The Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has declared liability immunity for medical countermeasures against COVID-19."
- fasteddie31003 7y agoVentilators are at the bottom of the COVID-19 infection funnel. The cost-benefit is not as good as mechanisms higher up the funnel. I'd advocate narrowing the infection funnel at the top by adopting a universal mask protocol. https://www.maskssavelives.org/ https://www.maskssavelives.org/
- onetimemanytime 7y agoUSA can chew gum and walk at the same time.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoPlease look up medically recommended air clearance methods. These have a long history of being used by people with serious lung issues to help keep them alive. One news video indicated that Italian doctors are using them before people are so bad as to need a ventilator, but they don't seem to be getting anywhere near as much press as the "ooh, shiny" solution of mechanical ventilators. Edited for clarity.
- brigandish 7y agoCan you provide a link? I did a search for "medically recommended air clearance methods" and nothing stood out.
- DoreenMichele 7y agohttps://www.cff.org/Life-With-CF/Treatments-and-Therapies/Airway-Clearance/ https://www.cff.org/Life-With-CF/Treatments-and-Therapies/Ai...
- brigandish 7y agoThanks. I'm not a doctor so I could be wrong (and happy to be corrected) but from my understanding the problem with those techniques in this situation is that they are for clearing mucus from the lungs (in the bronchi and broncioles) not from alveoli, because mucus isn't the type of fluid in the alveoli. Hence, they'd have little effect. This video[1] goes into what happens when you have ARDS caused COVID and how it will be treated. It shows why machines like CPAP aren't appropriate too. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=okg7uq_HrhQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=okg7uq_HrhQ How Coronavirus Kills: Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS) & COVID-19 Treatment
- DoreenMichele 7y agoA. One news video indicated Italian doctors are using airway clearance in less severe cases. Not all cases end up needing ventilators. B. I know ways to also treat inflammation. I've left remarks about that various places, but a few people were following me around and harassing me on the excuse that I'm not a doctor, I'm just someone who lives with serious lung issues. C. I originally brought this up because people were asking "What can be done at home?" They are de facto rationing health care because there aren't enough medical supplies to go around. So I talked about what I know about managing serious lung issues to say "If medical care is unavailable and you find yourself in serious respiratory distress, there are things you can do on your own." Because no one else was really offering up solutions. D. I also spoke up to express my concerns that we are posting all these articles about homemade ventilators because ventilators are invasive and promote serious secondary infections that are more likely to be antibiotic resistant. I wish we were emphasizing other measures. I have a form of cystic fibrosis. I deal daily with serious lung issues. This includes inflammation which is supposed to be chronic and progressive. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/ppul.24129 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/ppul.24129 I have, anecdotally, found that it is possible to reverse the inflammation. If you really want to see my previous remarks, there is a link in my profile. I'm disinclined to link it here because of people following me around and harassing me. I am not interested in having this turn into endless drama. Rest assured, lung clearance is known to help improve lung function, even when there is chronic and irreversible lung inflammation. If you have no other options because the medical system is overwhelmed, it's worth knowing about. Please note that I am absolutely not suggesting this as an alternative to seeking medical treatment if it is available. I'm only suggesting it as an option in cases where you simply cannot get medical care due to overwhelming demand and find yourself in respiratory distress.
- zenit-mf-1 7y agoOne idea that is keep coming to my mind. Why ventilator are built to be used by individual at once? Sorry, I am not subject matter expert, but was wondering is there is way to design ventilator that can serve X patients?