6 ms·
This is really a very good point. The iPad still has a hard time looking for its killer app. And the pull to make the iPad more capable is, at its heart, “Why
by gumby 7y ago
This is really a very good point. The iPad still has a hard time looking for its killer app. And the pull to make the iPad more capable is, at its heart, “Why both an iPad and a laptop? My phone absorbed so many of the devices I used to carry; why can’t the iPad do the same?”
When it’s not trying to be all things to all people, Apple has a good story: there’s a single computing surface that spans the edge and the cloud, and whichever device you pick up should give you a window into it, though not always the same window.
So I can read web pages and send mail from my phone, but in many contexts my laptop is superior. The iPad is great somewhere in between but doesn’t leave the house. What the iPad did let me do was switch back to a smaller phone.
Another way to look at that last issue: the phone is hyper mobile. I can open an excel spreadsheet on it, in a pinch, and even edit it if it’s incredibly necessary. But never would I use it as my primary spreadsheet interface. And that’s OK. Likewise it’s a pain to pull out my laptop to look something up when I’m standing up someplace outside my office. That’s OK too.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoiPad has lots of good fits, appwise. Just that none of them are very big markets. They're ubiquitous anywhere a programmable display is needed. In tractor cabs; in recreational aircraft; in warehouses.
- alister 7y ago> They're ubiquitous anywhere [an embedded device] is needed. Just like the Mac Mini. I’ve heard people ask why Apple doesn’t kill off the Mac Mini since it’s not an extremely popular consumer device. But apparently it finds lots of embedded use. I’ve read for example that some casino floors have thousands of Mac Minis hidden behind cabinets controlling gaming machines.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI worked at a startup that made the bottom-tier unix box for ATT at one time. Trouble was, ATT stores just used it as a sacrificial offering, moving all their customers up to the next tier for a small increase in price. So we sold almost none. They got used in Texas in gas pumps. Our whole inventory, bought out for this embedded use. Never mind they had a screen and keyboard (kind of a terminal-like deal). They just mounted them sideways inside the pump!
- rubber_duck 7y agoiOS is very locked down and the hardware is not very modable - why would you chose iPad for custom controller use case ?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoFor interface to custom controllers, and back-end databases. Because they solve the software distribution problem; because they have a standard user interface; because they have rich tool support; because you can find developers by the dozens.
- rubber_duck 7y agoI don't really see this - in my experience Apple makes the distribution process more difficult (but I've never published an internal app through App Store) and iOS developers charge more than Android/JS frontend devs and are harder to find (at least in my local market)
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoVs custom embedded solution developers? Apple developers are orders of magnitude easier to find, in any universe.
- rubber_duck 7y agoWho is comparing this to custom embedded solutions ? Android and Windows tablets are dropin substitutes in this scenario that are cheaper and more flexible.
- zepto 7y agoIt has an excellent toolchain, the best hardware, the best security and has a much better assurance of support for years in a way that no small competitor can offer.
- gumby 7y agoI agree; the iPad would be a Fortune 500 business on its own. But the "killer app" is the product-making application that defines the product, pulling it into ubiquity (the original example was VisiCalc and the Apple II). The iPad has yet to find one that makes people say "oh, it's an X". Instead, as you say, it's spread around on a bunch of relatively small-volume apps.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dpeck 7y agoThe App Store + screen size is the killer app for iPad.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- welly 7y agoThe App Store in itself is by no means a killer app if all the apps available on the App Store are turds. I'm not saying they are - I'm an iPad Pro owner and user and there's a few apps I use on a regular basis - Shapr 3D most recently but there are certainly no apps that mean I absolutely need an iPad Pro for as there are equivalent apps, usually better, on desktop or smartphone. I'm not a gamer but have a few iPad games which are good but again, other platforms tend to have the same or similar games that are either better suited to that platform (console or PC) or are just better than the iPad equivalent. What the iPad only, sadly, does better than smartphones and better than laptops, is YouTube. And that is possibly it, at the moment. I hope things improve because my iPad Pro cost me a lot of money.
- wrycoder 7y agoI have an iPhone X, a 13” Air, and two iPads, one a mini. I find I do most of my casual browsing - news and HN - on the X. I switch to the Air for complex sites like Github, or when I want to save bookmarks. I find that I rarely reach for the iPad for anything, even reading technical Kindles, although it’s fine for that, once I get started. The iPhone is ever-present and fits comfortably in my hand. I generally sit with my feet up, and my Air is more comfortable resting in my lap than holding an iPad. And yet I keep eyeing the big iPad Pro and its pencil....