4 ms·
Could someone explain the sudden anger at share buybacks to me? Media seems to portray it as some sort of evil trick, but I don't see it. It's not that differe
by Havoc 7y ago
Could someone explain the sudden anger at share buybacks to me?
Media seems to portray it as some sort of evil trick, but I don't see it. It's not that different from distributing divs
- rorykoehler 7y agoIt's basically rent seeking behavior if you taking public money and then using it to enrich yourself with no benefit to the public. That money could be 1) saved for a rainy day (like now) so they won't have to ask the public for money or 2) reinvested in the company to generate more value. As it is it just sucks value from the economy while also artificially increasing the stock price.
- smaryjerry 7y agoIt does the opposite. Buybacks send that money directly back into the economy to the shareholders that sold.
- madhadron 7y agoInto the economy, perhaps, but not generally into circulation. Most shares are held by institutional funds or the wealthy, which is about the least useful place to put money for stimulus.
- zentiggr 7y agoAnything that increases share values or enriches shareholders is going straight into the hands of the 1%, or the funds that hold huge percentages of the market. It's not going out to be respent.
- greenshackle2 7y agoYou didn’t explain how this is different from dividends.
- rorykoehler 7y agoDividends don't increase wealth concentration.
- adwww 7y agoIt's symbolic of short-termism. Instead of saving cash for emergencies or investing in new equipment, research or product lines, the cash is just 'wasted' on manipulating a share price in order to boost quarterly targets. A lot of the time, management is then rewarded for the increased share price, which doesn't necessarily reflect the performance of the business in terms of their ouput, number of widgets sold or whatever.
- umanwizard 7y agoYou didn’t explain how this is different from dividends.
- gpderetta 7y agoDividends do not increase the share price (the reverse in fact).
- em500 7y agoThere are some tax and option-price related differences between dividends and buybacks in normal times, but for most of the current discussions those differences are irrelevant. I agree that some of these recent stories about evil buybacks feels like fabricated outrage. For requesting state aid, buybacks are largely the same as dividends: if you need public support, you should definitely not do buybacks after that, just as you should pay dividends. Whether you believe they shouldn't have done buybacks in the past, ever, should not be much different than whether they should have paid out dividends in the past. Higher level, it's about what kind of equity buffers companies should retain in normal times.
- fmajid 7y agoThey also make executives' stock options more valuable, and in most cases the grants don't have clauses to reprice their options to account for that. In other words, a form of embezzlement.