5 ms·
.. or dividends as the article says. Devil is in the details. Maybe French government has good conditions for the aid, but the article is not giving details.
by nabla9 7y ago
.. or dividends as the article says.
Devil is in the details. Maybe French government has good conditions for the aid, but the article is not giving details.
Aid should be exchangeable debt for public companies. No dividends and buybacks. No executive bonuses or options until the debt is paid full. After (5-7) years the remaining debt is exchanged into company stocks in a rate that leaves the government in the neutral position or with small profit. I think it would be OK to give compensation package to executives if it's tied to the profit that the government makes from the aid.
The aid should be available to everyone with same conditions. Not doing so punishes companies with good finances.
Having right incentives as a whole is the issue, not some implementation details.
- batmenace 7y agoMonstly agree - but dividends that go to every owner aren't unfair per se, a cap on dividends would be very good, though. As for options, depending on the company they can be a hiring incentive, and not being able to grant any may restrict the company going forward - has to be evaluated carefully.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>but dividends that go to every owner aren't unfair per se If these companies are in such dire straits they need the infusion of cash provided by a government bailout, where did the money to pay dividends come from? Shouldn't they use that money to pay employees and fund their operations?
- tomatotomato37 7y agoI've heard arguments for dividends/buybacks in the scenario where the government does a terrible job of picking companies that actually need a bailout and ends up throwing money at a healthy company, in which case the only way for that money to reach decent investment opportunities is for the company to pass on the money to its own investors in the form of buybacks and what not. I don't really agree with the concept since bailouts are supposed to be for keeping big domestic employers alive and not some 10 person juicero startup an ocean away but the money does eventually end up funding someone's job so it's not completely useless.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThis is just making a stronger argument for not bailing out corporations at all and giving out more of the money by sending checks to individuals. If companies need money they can sell shares, and then people have more money to buy the shares with. If that's what they want. If everybody has the money and nobody thinks a particular company is worth saving, why are we saving it?
- sokoloff 7y agoPresumably companies with strong finances and other options for financing would not want to take on shareholder-unfriendly terms like a multi-year ban on paying dividends or doing buybacks.
- koolba 7y ago> I think it would be OK to give compensation package to executives if it's tied to the profit that the government makes from the aid. That still has the perverse incentive of gambling with other people’s money.
- BubbaHool 7y agothis. I am often left surprised by how many people are always and only read the headlines. Even those who do read the headlines and the article, don't really question it.
- snarf21 7y agoAs others have said, make it convertible debt. It converts to voting shares. I actually like these conditions. If you need the money, you shouldn't be paying dividends or doing buybacks anyway. This real issue is that we need to ban C-suite and BOD compensation from using anything stock related. Then this perverse incentive for buybacks and quarterly numbers fades and people start focusing on building healthy companies.
- joosters 7y agoCompanies (and their directors) care about the share price because their owners care about the share price, since they are the shareholders. If the directors and bosses stopped caring about the share price, the shareholders would be more likely to kick them out and recruit some more co-operative people. If you want companies to care less about share prices, you'll have to structure companies differently.
- dumbfoundded 7y agoOf course, companies will always care about the stock price. And that's a good thing. There should be strong limits on the way to increase that price. Increasing the value of the company? Awesome, go ahead. That's what the bailout is supposed to be for. Buying back stock? No. No value is created.
- MiroF 7y agoSure, but changing C-suite compensation from being stock-based won't change the dynamic around buybacks because the buybacks are pushed by the owners not just the management.
- abakker 7y agoThis whole issue is overblown. Employees, retirees, and generic Wall Street investors have a preference for buybacks because it leaves equity holders with the ability to put their capital to good use. I don’t want GE to invest in vanity projects if they don’t have good ideas. Buy back shares, return capital to shareholders, and let shareholders invest in something else. There two sides to a buyback transaction, and saying it creates no value is BS. Someone is SELLING. If the issue is just using debt to buy equity, then there is some discussion to be had, but even then, the result looks more like a need for a stress test/capital buffer rather than a ban. Alternately, just modify the tax treatment of buybacks to look exactly the same as dividends.
- tenpies 7y agoAll I can think of is that it sucks to be a pensioner or pension fund manager. Going to be really interesting to see the second quarter consequences of the "buy backs and dividends are evil" movement.