5 ms·
No, I am the same as you — lead free is different, but not worse. Just like you I started using pretty much both from the start. I think the perception of lead
by atoav 7y ago
No, I am the same as you — lead free is different, but not worse. Just like you I started using pretty much both from the start. I think the perception of lead free solder as beeing worse or harder to solder is mostly due to braking with one's habits. A bit like a subtle version of driving your car in the UK as a continental European: all the signs seem to be at the wrong side.
Lead free behaves differently for sure (although how exactly also depends on the mixture, iron power, temperature), but as you I actually find it better and not worse.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI used both leaded[1] and lead free. Only thing with lead free is needing a little more heat and making sure everything is clean. Anything tinned or with a flash of silver/gold solders just fine. And I think I've seen tin whiskers once in 20 years. I'm dubious it's a problem for 99% of commercial applications. Unlike mil spec the temperature extremes are less, IC's are encapsulated[2]. And I suspect lead free alloys aren't as problematic as pure tin. Either way industrial production, processing and eventual disposal of lead is bad news. [1] Nicest solder I've used is lead/tin/antimony. Stuff was the shit. [2] Early papers I read were all about pure tin solder causing problems inside hermetically sealed packages.