6 ms·
The Curve Is Not Flat Enough
- ehacke 7y agoFor decades large portions of the US population have prided themselves on ignoring whatever the government says. Until the bodies start piling up in their own town, people will not take it seriously, and possibly not even then.
- DeonPenny 7y agoFor decades? Thats the entire point of the US. Even the bodies won't change that
- eBombzor 7y agoThis comment seems to be unpopular but I have to admit, I really do think that a small portion of the US population treats this pandemic as an overblown distraction or treats it as fuel for some other conspiracy theory. I've experienced this first hand as someone I unfortunately live with was very vocal about how the coronavirus was created as a distraction by the media to avert our attentions to something about Iran and some other conspiracy crap. These people exist.
- exegete 7y agoDidn’t help when the President said it was a hoax by political opponents. There’s another segment that believes every word he speaks even though it changes constantly. Also doesn’t help that WHO & CDC said masks don’t help when they have been proven to reduce transmission. So misinformation came from the highest levels of government and experts. The media also didn’t take it seriously (not just Fox News). People formed incorrect opinions and as you said until they see it for themselves it’s not a big deal in their minds since everyone said that for weeks. Not sure if there is a technical term for this when one forms an opinion and won’t change it even when new evidence is introduced.
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> For decades large portions of the US population have prided themselves on ignoring whatever the government says. The fault lies where? The government/state that has lied about pretty much everything or the people who have been lied to? The amount of "believe government", "trust government", "obey government" throughout social media makes me wonder. Not to mention all the messaging about compliance. Even more astounding coming from someone who has "hack" in their username. Also, "ignoring the government" to some degree and "civil disobedience" is part of being american. It's what separates the US from Britain, EU, China, etc.
- credit_guy 7y agoJust to add to your point, the Surgeon General recently advised "don't wear masks". I personally disobey this every time I step out of my apartment. And I'm proud of that.
- throwaway3820 7y agoChina has quietly reopened its wet markets: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8163761/Chinese-markets-selling-bats.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8163761/Chinese-mar... How long until the next time we have to endure millions of deaths, trillions in lost economic activity, and months of quarantine? Meanwhile, we still have a domestic Fifth Column accusing anyone who calls the CCP's virus the "China Virus" of racism.
- DeonPenny 7y agoWHats this flattening point. I keep doing the graph but anyone know what they are using for ICUs that would even flatten the curve and the delta we are missing it by? Its just seems like so blanketed that it seems like its damn if we do damn if we don't
- eBombzor 7y agoDoesn't it vary highly on the location and its surrounding population density? That's probably why it's so vague. But why does it matter? Exponential growth can reach extremely high numbers in short iterations. Maybe a smaller hospital in Ney Jersey will be overwhelmed a few days before a larger hospital in New York would be.
- DeonPenny 7y agoBecause we can figure out the rate and inform people how much distancing they can do. I don't think this is tenable. IN SF, for example, April 7th is the date restaurants/bar are all openings again. This city is filled with smart people, but its very apparent if a max rate of daily interaction is shown people will start to ignore it. Honestly, they already are.
- exegete 7y agoLocal and state governments do simulations for the resources in their jurisdictions. I have seen some posted for NJ but can’t find them now and they would be out of date by now.
- nostromo 7y agoIt’s actually too flat in Seattle. We’ve flatlined at about 100 new cases a day. At that rate, we won’t get heard immunity for many decades. If we raise quarantine in May it’ll just start spreading again, and we’ll have kicked the can down the road. I think we should start considering letting young, healthy people return to public spaces, should they so desire.
- ttul 7y agoThat is insanity. Flat is absolutely the best we can do. Herd immunity is a fallacy when the result of loosening social distancing restrictions is to overwhelm the medical system and cause unnecessary death. Let young people congregate? A healthy fraction of those hospitalized with COVID-19 are young. They may survive better, but they take up a lot of ventilators in the process. Run out of ventilators and those young people will die in large numbers. No, the only reasonable endgame to COVID-19 is to flatten the curve and keep it flat until we have some treatment tools that work. Ultimately, a vaccine. But until then, drug therapies that have been proven out in reasonably sized trials.
- rimliu 7y agoCan you provide the numbers for those young people on ventilators?
- eBombzor 7y agohttps://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/news/coronavirus-making-young-adults-sick-and-spreading-through-them?utm_source=fiat-lux&utm_medium=internal-email&utm_campaign=article-general&utm_content=text https://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/news/coronavirus-maki... https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6912e2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6912e2.htm > Among the first 4,226 cases in the U.S., more than half of patients who were hospitalized were under the age of 65, and one in five were aged 20 to 44. No source on ventilators but "hospitalized" is close enough.
- DeonPenny 7y ago
- ckdarby 7y ago> Those who might end up in a hospital, which is to say all of us Unnecessary fear setting. Not even close to all of us will need to go to the hospital at all. Example, last time I looked at the stats, 20-40 had 0.2-0.4% chance of being critically ill from covid19.
- hurricanetc 7y agoI think the implication was that hospital staffs are overworked with Covid-19 but that normal every day emergency situations are still going to happen.
- paulryanrogers 7y ago> Example, last time I looked at the stats, 20-40 had 0.2-0.4% chance of being critically ill from covid19. Source? Because I think you'd need a lot more testing to say for sure, at least in the US
- DeonPenny 7y agoMore test would lower that number not increase it. They are testing people who go into the ICU testing at this point would be for people not in the ICU dropping that number like a rock
- ckdarby 7y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/coronavirus#case-fatality-rate-of-covid-19-by-age https://ourworldindata.org/coronavirus#case-fatality-rate-of...
- DeonPenny 7y agoI stopped reading stories cause of this. Your likelyhood of getting critically ill is very small. The issue was never that it was always that our capacity since everyone will probably get sick is very small, but we aren't acting as if this is what we are dealing with