4 ms·
> Governments are so utterly broken and inefficient that they can’t do it. Exactly. Which means we should not be depending on governments to do it. This is exa
by pdonis 7y ago
> Governments are so utterly broken and inefficient that they can’t do it.
Exactly. Which means we should not be depending on governments to do it. This is exactly the sort of thing that private startup companies should be doing, without trying to involve the government's bloated and inefficient bureaucracy.
> even if they produced a design now we have supply chain problems globally
For this particular crisis, yes. But not for the next one, if we start now.
- fyfy18 7y agoWait... isn't that exactly what the article says they tried to do?
- pdonis 7y agoThe government tried, but then canceled the contract at the request of the big company that had bought out the small company they originally had the contract with.
- neffy 7y agoExactly. The issue in some sense isn't government, it's the corruption of government by corporations that have been allowed to become to big and to powerful, to the extent that the US Government itself has been deliberately defunded. (Sure, I know Government spending grows every year, but so does the money supply and corporate profits. Control for monetary expansion, and the US Government's portion of the economy has been steadily shrinking.)
- pdonis 7y ago> The issue in some sense isn't government, it's the corruption of government Ok, so how do we keep the government from being corrupted? Nobody has yet solved that problem, and people have been trying for centuries. > Control for monetary expansion, and the US Government's portion of the economy has been steadily shrinking. The money supply is not the same as the economy. Government spending as a percentage of GDP, which is the closest estimate we have to "the size of the economy", has been growing, not shrinking.
- m0xte 7y agoWell the first thing you do is ban professional politicians and lobbying.
- amanaplanacanal 7y agoThe trick is doing that while still having some semblance of free speech, and allowing constituents to talk to their representatives about what problems they are seeing.
- pdonis 7y agoAs I commented upthread, your solution is to just change the entire system of government. Sure, that should be simple. Not.
- m0xte 7y agoBig problems require drastic changes.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Control for monetary expansion, and the US Government's portion of the economy has been steadily shrinking. What? No it hasn't. It has kept pace with GDP since the end of WWII (prior to WWII it was much smaller), and the rate of GDP growth is higher than the rate of inflation. The size of government in the US has been growing continuously in real terms since before Eisenhower.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoWhy should hospital X buy 100 ventilators...just in case, unless the gov made them do it?
- pdonis 7y ago> Why should hospital X buy 100 ventilators...just in case Well, of course. That's what we're talking about, right? Somebody has to do the long-term planning for emergencies like this one. I understand that most of us thought it was the government's job to do this long-term planning so individual facilities wouldn't have to, but this article shows that the government failed at that job. Unless we have some reason to think the government wouldn't fail next time, it seems like the only alternative is for private entities to do it.
- neffy 7y agoBut private entities can't do it, because the market forces them not to - those that the spend the money will be out-competed in the short term by those that don't.
- pdonis 7y ago> private entities can't do it, because the market forces them not to Private entities don't have to be subject to the market. Someone like Bill Gates or Elon Musk could set up a privately owned company, not publicly traded, that would not be subject to investors' demands for consistent quarterly growth. Matter of fact, maybe that's what Bill Gates should switch his attention to from malaria. The fact is, a private individual, or a small group of them, can have a longer time horizon than the government does, and a longer time horizon is exactly what is needed for something like this.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoThe government failed here but they are the only ones that can really prepare. A pandemic is as much as a threat as USSR, Bin Laden was, or China is, so just as they have these billion dollar planes they should prepare for Covid like situations.
- blunte 7y agoIt was already a small private company doing the contract. Another bigger company (that was publicly traded and therefore operating with shareholder profit as the primary if only concern) came along and bought the smaller private company. This happens to start-ups all the time. What does this have to do with "government's bloated and inefficient bureaucracy"? The only government failure I see in this story is that they allowed the sale of the small company to the big one, or that they allowed the big company to get out of the contract.
- worik 7y agoI completely disagree. If the government had done it in house they could have succeeded. The problem here was the profit motive. Cheep ventilators endanger profits. It is a side effect of free markets (I like free markets) that big firms get bigger, get more market power, kill off competition then price gouge. Health is a bad bad place to have free markets as the incentives are almost all wrong (exceptions: E.g. running clinics as a service for state run health systems turns out to work well here in Aotearoa - but even that is under pressure from consolidation) Nationalise the whole ball of wax. Use waiting lists not wealth to ration access. FFS the richest country in the world is heading to a health catastrophe. What a bunch of idiots!
- pdonis 7y ago> If the government had done it in house they could have succeeded. Ok, so how do we get the government to do it in house, and stick to it long enough so that the stockpile is there when the next disease crisis happens, which might not be for another 10 years? That's five Congressional elections and at least two changes of Presidential administration.
- worik 7y agoGovernment is not congress, or a president. It is civil servants beavering away.
- pdonis 7y ago> Government is not congress, or a president. It is civil servants beavering away. The civil servants work on what Congress and the President set as priorities. They cannot execute plans that span multiple Congresses and Presidential administrations unless every single Congress and Administration over that time period agrees to support the plan.
- worik 7y agoThey flew to the moon. They built a horrifying arsenal. I really do not see why they cannot build a health system. They have done so here.
- smacktoward 7y agoThere is no profit to be made in building up huge stockpiles of ventilators that will only be used in the event of a freak disaster. Government has to pay for such things, because no economically rational private investor would.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> For this particular crisis, yes. Really not even for this particular crisis. We can build more of something on a short timescale, it just costs more then. You have to build facilities you know are only going to run for six months and then be decommissioned, so you have to amortize their construction cost over half a year instead of 30 years. You have to build them on the double, which means paying a lot of overtime and buying land and raw materials without taking a lot of time to negotiate on price or worry about efficiency. But we could do it. And then the ventilators would cost ten times more than they ordinarily do and idiots would accuse anybody trying to do this of price gouging. But it could be done. (Unless the idiots pass a law against charging more than the regular price during an emergency.)