5 ms·
The reports of “business as usual in Sweden” are exaggerated. The end results are pretty similar across Scandinavia despite approaches being officially differen
by alkonaut 7y ago
The reports of “business as usual in Sweden” are exaggerated. The end results are pretty similar across Scandinavia despite approaches being officially different. Streets are mostly empty. People do walk outside as there is no lockdown or shelter-in-place, but restaurants are mostly empty or closed, ski resorts are closing, travel is “not recommended” even domestically and so on. The restrictions are based on recommendations and personal responsibility. Trust in authorities is high.
You’ll always be able to find people that won’t follow recommendations (So taking clickbait pictures of people drinking isn’t difficult).
I think the gradual approach might mean we are always “one step behind” since the idea is to introduce measures as they are needed, which you notice two to three weeks after you need them. That’s my fear, at least.
On the other hand I think we’ll se authorities facing the opposite problem in Italy and elsewhere when lockdown needs to continue for longer than people accept (already reports of this). In the end I think we’ll see that differences will be small between countries despite varying policy, and that policy will converge to the successful ones.
I hope authorities will be quick to introduce further restrictions if and when they are needed. More importantly I hope people are doing this before authorities require it, if reports of healthcare overload appear.
Looking at the curves now, I’m pretty satisfied, but again if they start to point north further restrictions need to be introduced two weeks back in time, which is difficult even for our trusted authorities.
- dijit 7y agoI guess this hugely depends on where you live. I live in central Malmö and restaurants don’t seem any less empty in the evenings. Large groups of people hang around in the parks in the middle of the day and small groups (5-10 people) saunter passed each other on the high street as usual. Not much has changed at all, maybe a few less people out at lunch, but it’s definitely alarming to me.
- alkonaut 7y agoI live in Stockholm but I don’t visit the city in evenings now since I live outside the city and obviously reasons to visit the city (concerts, matches, restaurants) are out of the question now. I think one key element of the Swedish approach is this: don’t make restrictions that aren’t proven very effective, because people will adhere less to those that are really effective. As if there is a budget of restriction (same with duration, I guess). Banning meetings of 5 people outside in a park (who take reasonable precautions and keep distance) might have marginal effect compared to some much more important measure, so don’t ban small park gatherings - instead try to get more adherence to the things that are important. This is my interpretation of the reasoning. If it’s based on self enforcing rather than policing it needs to encourage adherence to the important parts. I don’t worth much about small groups walking outside or meeting in parks. What does bother me is packed public transport at rush hour. That just isn’t good and we should try to fix it. Same with some gyms still being open. Thought people would realize that they shouldn’t go so they’d close by themselves, but no.
- mclightning 7y agoexactly. Living also in Malmö, people are out and about if there is sun in the sky, Möllan, Lilla torg were both full on past 2 saturdays.
- lnsru 7y agoSounds like a recipe to duplicate German virus spread curve.
- chinesempire 7y ago> Looking at the curves now, I’m pretty satisfied even though the numbers are very different absolutely (for many obvious reasons), the curve doesn't look very satisfying to me comprared to others left Italy, right Sweden https://imgur.com/a/FcGPMNq https://imgur.com/a/FcGPMNq Also: population density is much different https://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/downloads/maps/gpw-v3/gpw-v3-population-density/itadens.jpg https://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/downloads/maps/gpw-v3/gpw-... https://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/downloads/maps/gpw-v3/gpw-v3-population-density/swedens.jpg https://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/downloads/maps/gpw-v3/gpw-...
- alkonaut 7y agoI worry mostly about healthcare system overload so the curve I follow with most interest is the ICU admittance. https://portal.icuregswe.org/siri/report/vtfstart-corona https://portal.icuregswe.org/siri/report/vtfstart-corona Death curve is of course interesting too but harder to interpret at the low numbers we still have and says more about spread in certain age groups than the general population.
- chinesempire 7y agoAge groups is the most important factor IMHO In Italy we have less than 100 deaths in the range 1-49 and only 347 in the range 50-59 87% of deaths are in the range >=60
- yodsanklai 7y ago> The reports of “business as usual in Sweden” are exaggerated. The end results are pretty similar across Scandinavia despite approaches being officially different. In France, we have a stricter lockdown (e.g. we're not allowed to wander to more than 1km from our home - which is BS in my opinion). I'm wondering if the bulk of the measures is enough: closing school, restaurants, preventing gathering and so on... If this is the case, I don't expect different outcome in Sweden compared to other western countries.
- alkonaut 7y agoI think only time will tell, and it will be hard to tell even in hindsight. I think the most important ones are the ones you can't really enforce. Like "wash your hands". Most importantly "stay at home if you are sick even if just slightly". That one is hard to enforce but easy to encourage: ensure everyone has good paid sick leave from day one and has zero risk of losing their jobs even if they are sick a long time.
- renox 7y agoWhy do you think its BS? You know that the hospitals are saturated and that they have to choose who they give respirators and who they 'let die'..
- alkonaut 7y agoI assume he thinks it’s BS because there is no way someone driving away to a forest to take a walk is a higher risk of spread than someone walking within 1km from their home. So banning walks in nature can’t have much effect in itself. If there is a positive effect it’s due to something secondary, such as people that are allowed further than 1km might get on a bus, or might go to a different shop with too many people. But still: it’s a ban of going out in nature, at a time when basically everything else is banned but going out in nature is safe and healthy. It should be encouraged! ICUs being overfilled isn’t an argument for why millions of people can’t walk in the forest.
- nitrogen 7y ago
- jariel 7y agoThis is really interesting. It could be that Swedes are following the norms established everywhere else, even if 'lockdown' orders are not that hard. In Quebec, restaurants started to empty out long before they were ordered closed. I can absolutely see information workers working from home without the order. So it may be the the 'de-facto' situation in Sweden is quite similar to that of other places on soft lock down.
- alkonaut 7y ago> It could be that Swedes are following the norms established everywhere else, even if 'lockdown' orders are not that hard. Well, it could be but it's not that there is any numbers to back up anything yet. I do think that the difference in reality is smaller than the percieved difference in policy. Some headlines would have you believe that we are ignoring the pandemic and everyone just goes to work normally.
- checkyoursudo 7y agoI live in northern Sweden. This is some of my anecdotal sense. My children's school is still, technically, open. However, according to my neighbor who is a teacher there, there are only a small handful of children actually present any given day. On Friday, I think she said there were 2 children present. Edit: This is not to say that I have any idea about elsewhere. And, again, just one fairly not useful data point. Just an observation.
- reaperducer 7y agoIt could be that Swedes are following the norms established everywhere else, even if 'lockdown' orders are not that hard. Or it could be, as the article noted, that more than 50% of households are just one person.
- alkonaut 7y agoAnd no households consist of elderly living with younger relatives. That at least helps isolate the old from the rest.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- detaro 7y agoWhat I hear from friends in Gothenburg is that certainly a lot more people WFH, but also that restaurants etc are still quite busy.
- fxj 7y agoSweden has a doubling time of the cases of about 10 days which is about the same as in Italy, but still should raise some concerns. The swiss government just communicated that the strict measures can be lifted if the doubling time is more than 14 days. In Switzerland the doubling time is 8 days now. For comparison in China the doubling time is in the order of 2 years now and in the US it is 3 days now.
- alkonaut 7y agoPlease don't compare testing/case curves. That just a report of how many tests can be performed. That will never be an accurate representation of how many are actually ill. It's an absolutely useless number for comparing between countries too since testing strategies vary. Sweden only tests those admitted to hospital (starting some randomized testing now too). Other countries already have capacity to test broader, e.g. germany, so case numbers can give a better picture of actual infection numbers. Not so in Sweden. Look at deaths, icu admittance and hospitalisations. Not case numbers. We have a worrying trend in deaths doubling every 3 days or so, but at least it is a bit slower the last 2. ICU admittance trend is great suddenly, for some reason I don't understand (trending downwards last several days).
- rasz 7y agoThere is this one trick to controlling number of cases some of the countries are using, making whole calculation meaningless.