6 ms·
Cash Is King: Flows, Balances, and Buffer Days
- jtdev 7y agoSeems like maybe there are systemic issues with the economy...maybe concentrating wealth in the hands of so few doesn’t make for a robust economy that can handle some punches.
- bravo22 7y agoUnless they're stuffing their wealth in mattresses that wealth is spread everywhere in economy. Also a lot of that wealth is based on market value of assets which ebb and flow and inflate and crash. It is not based on sucking cash out of the economy. Put another way, the economy is fucked but a small % are able to inflate the market value of their assets.
- GuiA 7y agoThis isn’t “some punches”, this is one of the biggest pandemics in living memory and will be an event whose consequences will be felt for the years and decades to come. I’m not disagreeing with wealth concentration being problematic, to be clear.
- lainga 7y agoHow does wealth concentration tie into the report's findings? What I saw was that most of the small businesses in the JPM report are operating on margins of a few dollars a day. That might be the consequence of competition, driving down prices; or, maybe broadly high confidence in market stability -- whether reasonable or not -- lowering the level of caution small business owners thought they needed to take. But I'm not sure how it relates to wealth concentration.
- Mathnerd314 7y agoAs I see, it means small businesses are getting squeezed too, just like poorer individuals who also have small cash buffers. It's possible to interpret this as economic efficiency, but it is efficient in the same way communism is efficient, i.e. efficient at misallocating resources. Tight budgets are like tight rubber bands and if there's enough stress something will break. I think that's enough terrible analogies, you get the point.
- clairity 7y agoyes, slack in the economy (in forms like cash reserves and inventory) provides robustness and resiliency, but our financial sector has mined it for the benefit of the wealthy and to the detriment of the rest of us. it's yet another reason to revise policy to move us (back?) toward a better balance. for instance, we need to allow all kinds of businesses to (live and) die, and also provide a robust safety net so people can try ideas big and small without being left destitute upon failure. then they can pick themselves up and try again. capital then flows to find the best ideas because we're allowed to try more of them. instead we get stupid capital gains & inheritance tax rates that mainly benefit the already wealthy and blunt capital's edge.
- ttul 7y agoLet me illustrate with an example. A colleague operates a company doing about $10M in annual revenue. Due to stay at home orders, his business has completely failed. A very wealthy minority shareholder who lent the company some funding last year is now going to do a debtor-in-possession financing and will end up owning the whole thing. The founder, who is not wealthy, will lose everything. The rich man will gain everything. Once the pandemic is over, the company will return to normal. The rich just got richer, folks.
- cm2187 7y agoI think it rather says that the more you leverage, the more risk you take, the less you can survive hard times. Same story with the Private Equity Funds industry.
- lainga 7y agoThat raises a good question: what proportion of small businesses (SBA definition or JPM's sample definition) have shareholders? Vs. being sole proprietorships or partnerships?
- vsareto 7y ago>Once the pandemic is over, the company will return to normal. I wouldn't say that. Your employees who did the work and had tribal knowledge are now gone. If they didn't document something, it may not be found for a good while. Point is, it might take a lot of work to get it back going. Or it's as easy as putting some equipment on firesale and shredding everything else.
- perl4ever 7y agoI see this as an inevitable consequence of the fact that most small business owners assign a large value to the intangible of "being your own boss" not to mention the potential for wealth, and this drives everyone to have no margin for downturns. I mean, think about restaurants. Who starts a restaurant because they think it's the easiest way to make a dollar? The very fact that many people want to do something for reasons other than sheer profit means that profit will be driven below normal which will cause pain over time. What can the rich do to prevent this? Unless they got together and eliminated the ability of the non-rich to seek wealth. Sometimes, that's the conclusion elites reach about things; they do it to some extent. Like the way in the US you have to be a "qualified investor" with a certain amount of assets to invest in unregulated securities.
- danans 7y agoThis is a real time experiment in progress. People across the globe are watching how the distribution of wealth in each country relates to the economic effects of this. There are a lot of confounding variables, some more related to wealth distribution (i.e. universal healthcare vs not), and some less related (timeliness of local authorities and government reaction). At the individual household level in the US at least, household savings are very low among large segments of the population (because of high wealth disparity), so there is very little to fall back on for most people. Depending on the length and severity of the pandemic, the 2T relief/stimulus bill may not be enough. Overall, this is a huge test for how whether the amount (or lack) of slack in important areas of the system - primarily income and health care, but others too - can cope with this shock.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoTLDR More than 50 percent of US small businesses only have roughly a month of cash reserves on hand (based on JPMC’s data from small biz accounts).
- zapttt 7y agowonder what most "US small biz funds" (required on most 401k programs ) are doing these days
- lonelappde 7y agoDo you mean "small business" or "small cap"? "Small cap" publicly traded companies are bigger than "small businesses"
- zapttt 7y agoi mean exactly "us small business" which is a title almost all companies ofering 401k managed accounts have.
- wslh 7y agoThat is a great insight. It is incredible how fragile the economic system is. This is one of the weak points if the economic system that can destroy decades of work.
- SilasX 7y agoSo we're going to have a spate of bankruptcies in a week or so for those businesses that didn't get aid in the bailout bill?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThe official bankruptcy filing may take time, but many will cease operations immediately once cash reserves are exhausted. If liabilities aren’t significant, there might not even be a bankruptcy filing; they’ll just never hire workers back and the owners will file their last tax returns for the business next year. The effects will take time to be felt; with the US stimulus bill (“CARES Act”) providing 10 months of unemployment, workers will be cushioned for now, but might not be able to find jobs when that relief expires.
- symplee 7y agoIs there an equivalent "short term disability" insurance for companies? Where if some unforeseen event happens, they can still make 60-80 percent of their revenue for 6-12 weeks?
- dillonmckay 7y agoit is called ‘cash balance’.
- Klinky 7y agoThere was a discussion on SBA Disaster Loans a few days ago, not exactly insurance though. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22703758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22703758
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt’s society getting together and deciding to either forego debt/rents, or print money and hand it out.
- themagician 7y agoYou can get insurance on your receivables, which is the real immediate risk. Lost revenue is one thing, but right now a lot of companies are refusing to pay or changing payment terms and many will go bankrupt. If you are owed $500k in the next 90 days from a company that’s going to default on its debt obligations there’s a good chance your receivables will fall apart long before revenue itself is actually a problem.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lukas099 7y ago> The median small business has average daily cash outflows of $374 and average daily cash inflows of $381 Someone help me understand. Does this mean that small businesses make $7/day or $2555/year on average?
- dmurray 7y agoThe median, not the average. But it does seem to be saying 50% of small businesses make less than $7/day. Maybe this is after paying the owner a salary?
- xapata 7y agoOutflows include owner distributions, which may be in addition to salary.
- eanzenberg 7y agoIncluded are payroll, so yes, the majority of outflow is employing people.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- goatherders 7y agoThat median is also about 140k revenue based on the inflow, so take it for what it is
- stevedewald 7y agoYes, after paying salaries, owner distributions, etc. There isn’t much incentive for small businesses in the US to keep excess cash in the company.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 7y agoWhich is one result of near-zero interest rates.
- zitterbewegung 7y agoHaving a text version of the graphs in this site is really helpful. I wish more sites would do this .
- unreal37 7y agoThe thing to note is, if cash inflows stop, some cash outflows also stop. Like if you're a store and you're not selling any products right now, you're also not buying any inventory. If you're a restaurant that's closed, you're not buying any food. Revenue has to include cost of goods sold right, unless specifically excluded?
- jeromegv 7y agoSome yes. But when rent is one of your biggest one, the impact of stopping is quite high as you can't even cover this one.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoRent/mortgage/insurances/property tax are the big ones.
- eruci 7y agoI've gotten several inquiries (more than in the past 10 years) on LinkedIN recently from 'investors' offering financing for companies 'in trouble'. I run a very small company that is completely bootstrapped and I have never used any outside funding for anything I've done. Yet, they found me. The sharks are circling, they smell blood.
- avalys 7y agoEvery small business owner in the US should check out the details of the CARES Act (the coronavirus rescue package, just signed into law). Essentially, the US government will cover your payroll, rent, and a few other things for the next 2 months, up to $10M. This is implemented as a “loan”, so that it can be rapidly issued from existing commercial banks - but the principal will be forgiven once you provide documentation that it was spent on covered expenses. You don’t have to pay it back. It’s not perfect, but it might be just enough to bridge the gap for many businesses until things start returning to normal. Hopefully, Congress will extend it if necessary.
- ac29 7y agoDo you have a link for this? The stuff on sba.gov doesn't mention the forgiveness portions of these loans anywhere I can find, so the only info I've seen is summaries provided by news media. There are various covid-19 related programs on sba.gov, but none of them seem to exactly match how the news has described them, and I think one could easily apply for the wrong type of loan assuming it would be forgiven and end up on the hook for the full amount.
- avalys 7y agoHere is a link to a description from my CPA (I know their site looks like shit, but they are legit). https://wcginc.com/blog/paycheck-protection-program/ https://wcginc.com/blog/paycheck-protection-program/ It is called the “Paycheck Protection Program.”
- themagician 7y agoIt can be used for rent but doesn’t actually cover rent. The loan amount is 2.5x average monthly payroll.
- tmpynews 7y agoI have never really thought about daily cash flows before, but it looks like for SMBs the cash inflow and outflow is the same on a daily basis. How do the owners make money?
- bagels 7y agoThe average small business doesn't, it fails after a few years, even in the best of times. https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/advocacy/Frequently-Asked-Questions-Small-Business-2018.pdf https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/advocacy/Frequently-...
- rsynnott 7y agoThey pay themselves a salary.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymanbot 7y agoin JP Morgans case, bailout/Tax Payers cash is king.
- xchaotic 7y agoAssuming one made the right choices and is 100% cash, what now? Do you buy the dub on equities? In my view cash is also getting diluted by gov action, which can be nicely summed up by the meme money printer go brrrrr
- kortilla 7y ago> In my view Don’t use your view. The massive economic contraction is a deflationary pressure. Keep an eye on commodity prices before worrying about inflation.
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoYou need only look at foreign currencies and the price of precious metals. The dollar is weakening. That means inflation or even hyperinflation if the dollar price index slips below 90.
- wolco 7y agoDollar is weakening? Against what currency, I've been watching a jump to US currency.
- whatsmyusername 7y agoTo anyone believing the hogwash about, “loans getting forgiven in 10 months if you follow the rules,” go look what happened with student loan forgiveness for public service. Trusting anything the US government says about money that could cross a political cycle is just stupid.
- wallacoloo 7y ago> We constructed a sample of 597,000 businesses who hold Chase Business Banking deposit accounts and meet our criteria for small, core metropolitan operating businesses. I read the overview — not the full 44pg pdf. But if small businesses manage their finances at all similarly to the way I as an individual do, I wouldn’t expect a single bank deposit account to hold the full story of all the liquidity a business can tap into in time of need. For example, how many of theses businesses keep enough $ in the bank account to cover monthly expenses, and then keep some in a higher grossing money market account with a different institution which they can tap into in times of unexpected/less frequent demand, or as they save up a deposit on a nicer office, or as a way to optimize their take-home pay for tax purposes? I don’t know the answers, but from the overview it seems like Chase doesn’t either.