4 ms·
This article is an eye opening read. They didn’t choose paper because they were old fashioned but because their students all lived in an area without internet o
by gumby 7y ago
This article is an eye opening read. They didn’t choose paper because they were old fashioned but because their students all lived in an area without internet or any retail infrastructure. They also distributed corona virus info because the parents were (naturally) in the same boat.
I might have expected such a thing deep in the Australian bush or in rural parts of west Africa but not close to major urbanization’s like Chicago or St Louis.
- sslayer 7y agoI am Jacks Bias.
- non-entity 7y ago> I might have expected such a thing deep in the Australian bush or in rural parts of west Africa but not close to major urbanization’s like Chicago or St Louis. tbf the lines between rural, suburban, and urban in the US can be easily blurred. I've lived in places that were relatively urbanized to middle of nowhere in half an hour of driving
- Spooky23 7y agoI lived in a town about 13 miles from Albany, NY as the crow flies. We had a party line until 1990, and our CO was so antiquated that dial-up would connect at between 9600-19200. Now my parents have a local company cable connection funded by Obama's broadband expansion. They were using Verizon, but Verizon basically no longer maintains copper unless there's a certain number of customers on a road.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoDoes bring up the question if it makes sense to practice convnetional social distancing for a place where everyone is already lives so physcially apart that it's a pain in the ass to provide them with modern infrastructure; you'd think the curve would already be flat enough for them that whatever urban hospital services the area could handle it. To put the density in perspective the entire population of 500 sq mi Coles County is 2k less than the population of all 2 sq mi of Uptown Chicago
- spaced-out 7y agoHow much does population density matter if kids are still spending 8+ hours in the same room at school, and parents are touching the same surfaces at work?
- tomatotomato37 7y agoThe jobs that a low population density supports generally don't have a lot of workers touching the same thing; only so many people are going to be using a tractor or mining excavator in the span of a month. That only leaves schools as a large potential infection vector, which considering the average age & thus risk group of parents with kids still in primary school will leave the situation a lot more manageable
- spaced-out 7y ago>The jobs that a low population density supports generally don't have a lot of workers touching the same thing They have a separate bathroom for every employee? People on worksites never share tools?
- lioeters 7y agoI don't live in a rural area, but have friends who do. They all seem to have informal social networks spread through the area, family, relatives, friends - with whom they regularly meet and exchange information or goods. Any business transaction or social activity at local events, churches, banks, schools, grocery stores - are all potential infection vectors. Combine that with much lower and slower access to healthcare - meaning, a low threshold for overwhelming the system - makes rural areas as risky as urban centers. Well, less risky due to population density, but enough to warrant a social distancing policy (in my non-expert opinion).
- pwg 7y agoThis is actually normal. The US is huge, and outside of the major urban centers and their extended suburbs, it becomes very rural, very fast. And by "very rural" I mean most of the amenities that urban city/suburb dwellers simply take for granted do not exist (or are a half-hour or better car ride away).
- gumby 7y agoFWIW I have a home in the rural Sierras (closest hospital is two hours away; industries are agriculture, tourism and meth) but Internet service is faster and more reliable than at my other home in Palo Alto. California at least seems to be able to get services (health care, roads, communications, power, and often water) into most of its obscure corners. Places like Montana or New Mexico may be really sparsely settled, but central Illinois seems less excusable. According to this map the described situation doesn’t exist; not sure if that’s an artifact of county boundaries or if it’s due to carriers lying to the FCC: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/map-digital-divide-leaves-millions-isolated-during-coronavirus-panic.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/27/map-digital-divide-leaves-mi...
- cbhl 7y agoIt might be that the cellular internet with data caps/metering counts as high speed internet by the FCC definition? My cellular phone is capped at ~10 GB of data; over the last month my household (with five people in it) has used ~460 GB over its landline connection.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- imglorp 7y agoIf the government is going to throw $2 trillion at the problem, this seems like a reasonably inexpensive improvement with large impact. A CCC style nerd corps could set up a number of rural, micro ISPs. You could start with with fiber in the nearest town, go p2p microwave to each uISP, and then cantennas and mesh networking tech for last mile runs. This is all ancient off the shelf stuff. A nonprofit could organize the design and deployment, seek grants from feds and fangs, seek spare equipment from idling manufacturers.
- gumby 7y agoI love this plan. Unfortunately it helps the poor so has no chance of being funded.
- kick 7y agoIllinois & Missouri are states that look decent on paper, but both are doing poorly if you look at what's actually going on. The FCC's Broadband Map lies for half of the former and most of the latter.