5 ms·
> The iconic shape for a nuclear power plant cooling tower also incorporates curvature in both directions. This shape, called a hyperboloid, minimizes the amoun
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> The iconic shape for a nuclear power plant cooling tower also incorporates curvature in both directions. This shape, called a hyperboloid, minimizes the amount of material required to build it.
What? This is completely meaningless. A hyperboloid shape minimizes the amount of material required to match what constraints? If the goal is to minimize the amount of material while reaching a certain height, you just want a pole. If the goal is to minimize material, full stop, just don't build the tower in the first place. What's the goal supposed to be?
- Hokusai 7y ago> This shape, called a hyperboloid, minimizes the amount of material required to build it I guess that to build it "for its required purpose" is implicit in the sentence. I agree, that the author could have gone into more detail of what are the requirements of cooling towers but that may be out of the scope of the article.
- labawi 7y agoThey presumably have a set of complex constraints on cooling towers. A hyperboloid fullfills them with less material than a cylinder.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoCongratulations, you've repeated my question exactly while saying absolutely nothing else. I strongly suspect that they're talking about an actual mathematical minimization result, such as how a sphere minimizes surface area for constant volume, and the journalist just didn't bother to understand what the claim was before repeating half of it.
- labawi 7y agoA two page interlude on cooling tower constraints including functional cooling capabilities, height vs. width tradeoffs, manufacturability, earthquake, sabotage, plane-crash resistance etc. would not improve the article.
- bluntfang 7y agoTake a deep breath. You're getting upset over something that's very evidently implied in the article, which is about pizza. It's not a technical paper, it's a fun exercise using math and simplified real world models.
- mannykannot 7y agoThe goal is to dissipate the waste heat from the condenser cooling water, or at least that part of it which is to be reused. The relevant parameters are the rate of flow, inflow temperature, and acceptable outfow temperature. As the performance of a cooling tower depends on the ambient air temperature and humidity, knowledge of the local climate is needed. It is claimed here [1] that the hyperboloid shape is not just for structural efficiency, but also for aerodynamic reasons, efficiently generating an updraft from a relatavely small temperature difference. They are not just for nuclear plants, but for any large steam generating facility lacking a large source of cooling water in its local environment. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperboloid_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperboloid_structure
- leni536 7y agoI thought they used hyperboloid because it can be built from straight beams (besides probably hundreds of other, more complex constraints). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperboloid#/media/File:Cylinder_-_hyperboloid_-_cone.gif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperboloid#/media/File:Cylind...
- lonelappde 7y agoSure, but cylinder (degenerate hyperboloid) can too.
- jameshart 7y agoIt’s not quite precisely phrased, but this is just a simple literal mathematical minimum - like that a sphere is the surface which uses the least material to enclose a given volume. A cooling tower needs to be a chimney - a closed off area at ground level, open at a higher altitude. Given those constraints alone, the cooling tower form is literally the one that minimizes the amount of material required. A circle uses less material to enclose the same area of the ground than any other shape; the cooling tower’s curved form uses less material than any other shape to create any area of opening at any height above the ground. It might seem intuitive that a cylinder would be more efficient - if you imagine building one vertical slice of the tower wall, going in a straight line up seems like it would require less bricks than curving inwards then back out. But if you build one layer at a time, it’s clear that if you can build smaller and smaller circles before getting wider again nearer the top you will use less bricks than if you just keep building every layer with a circle of the full diameter. If you balance both of these ‘stretching’ directions - minimize the size of each circle but also minimize the path from each point at the base to a point at the top - you get a cooling-tower type surface. Actually this mathematical ‘minimal surface’ between two rings - as in the way to create two walls that are circular at the base and the top using the minimum amount of material - is not a hyperboloid, but a catenoid (the curve is a catenary not a paraboloid). The surface does exhibit mixed curvature though, so it is ‘hyperbolic’ if not ‘hyperboloid’. The easiest way to see the catenoid as a minimal surface is with a soap film - it is the shape that forms when a soap bubble is stretched between two rings. Surface tension forces soap films to minimize area. In practice cooling towers have other constraints than minimizing material cost - structural, wind load, material strength, ease of construction, etc, so they might actually be a different shape than a pure catenoid. But it is true that the closer to a catenoid they are, the less material they will use - and that is one good reason why they are not cylinders or truncated cones or pyramids or barrel shapes, and as a result they do have negative Gaussian curvature.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]