4 ms·
> I began doing gig work while deathly ill and homeless. > 60 percent of people are at least moderately handicapped. Most downplay it and don't want to wear th
by lm28469 7y ago
> I began doing gig work while deathly ill and homeless.
> 60 percent of people are at least moderately handicapped. Most downplay it and don't want to wear the label "handicapped" or "disabled." Such people benefit enormously from having more control over their lives
I don't know you nor your story and this isn't a comment about you personally, but writing that kind of sentences with a straight face to defend the gig economy is such a weird thing. You shouldn't have to work while "deathly ill", you shouldn't need the gig economy to survive while handicapped.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- true_religion 7y agoI agree with you, but the thing is we don’t have to destroy the gig economy to get free medical care for all, or housing for the unemployed and handicapped.
- lm28469 7y agoThe problem is that gig economy in Europe actually slowly erodes our rights. People working for uber, deliveroo, &c. don't have the same rights as people working for let's say mcdonalds or starbucks. It's becoming the new normal, no pension, no unemployment benefits, no job security, ...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI really hate dealing with comments like this. I've already written and deleted one upset reply. With 60 percent of the population impaired to some degree, it doesn't work for the world to say "Only the hail and hardy people should work." I didn't qualify for disability. I still don't. I had a corporate job. I quit it so I could prioritize my health. Like many people, my job was harming my health. In contrast, gig work allowed me to get healthier. This world does not usually reward you for having a good sob story. That's not how that works. Saying impaired people shouldn't have to work and from there arranging a world where they aren't allowed to work is a nightmare scenario where any defect cuts you out of the system entirely. When I was a homemaker, I couldn't get good drugs to treat my condition. I was bedridden and being treated like a hypochondriac who got off on cadging antibiotics for funsies. Then I got a proper diagnosis. The following year, with appropriate accommodation for my condition, I attended an eight week GIS Summer School. Halfway through, the air turned yellow, probably from sulfur from a factory, and I began reacting anaphylacticly anytime I set foot outside. I had borrowed $19k to attend. Failure was not an option. A doctor put me on eight prescription drugs so I could finish the program. Twenty-two months of drug withdrawal followed. And it saved my life. All those drugs were a turning point in my condition. People don't really try to help sad sacks live. They don't really try to heal the sick or have compassion for the poor. But they will dope you to the gills because you have a job to do. Working -- on my terms -- saved my life. Maybe that's not a good thing. It's a shitty life in a shitty world full of shitty people and I routinely wish I had died instead. But working was the only viable option I had for so very many reasons. Telling me I shouldn't work is like telling me to go die in a fire for having been born with the wrong genes.
- lm28469 7y agoAgain I'm not talking about you in particular and I'm sorry if I upset you, I'm glad it helped you but I'm convinced that in the grand scheme of things it isn't a net positive for the world.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI see potential for the gig economy to be the next industrial revolution. We once fought for forty hour work weeks. Perhaps we could fight for remote work to be unchained from a physical location and fight for the right to work as little as twenty hours per week. I've said that for years. I don't harp on it, but I do feel a personal need to give another take on it. If they start outlawing gig work, as California more or less has done, this negatively impacts me. Thankfully, I had already left California before that happened. But I've heard from someone still in California how much it has put them to n a world of hurt.
- livueta 7y ago> Saying impaired people shouldn't have to work and from there arranging a world where they aren't allowed to work is a nightmare scenario where any defect cuts you out of the system entirely. This really struck me. There's an interesting stain of American progressivism that sees a bad situation and, in earnestly attempting to address it, makes the problem worse. See the death of SROs and various forms of actually affordable housing: a veneer of compassion justified restrictive zoning ("nobody deserves to live in conditions like that!"), but without a suitable replacement occupants often just ended up on the street. Same effect with asylums: horrible abuses spurred public interest in dismantling them, but absent a replacement you just end up dumping the patients on the street without their meds. Sex work? Nobody should have to sell their body to survive! Therefore, let's persecute Backpage and force sex workers back out on the street where they can't meaningfully vet clients! Oh... There's a pattern here. This history makes me apprehensive that well-intentioned (or not, just wearing the mask) attempts to reform gig work will end up being a huge fuck you to the people actually impacted by them. That's not to say the gig economy doesn't enable abuses - it absolutely does, but any action should at minimum involve a lot of genuine consultation with those affected and, preferably, address root causes rather than symptoms, e.g. a workable solution to lack of job-provided healthcare probably shouldn't involve reenforcing our already-fucked system of employer-provided healthcare serfdom.