3 ms·
I had portable income and the freedom to go where I wanted more or less at will. My case doesn't prove that millions of people aren't being given a raw deal. I
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I had portable income and the freedom to go where I wanted more or less at will.
My case doesn't prove that millions of people aren't being given a raw deal. It just indicates that gig work doesn't have to be a raw deal and it is possible to design systems that work well.
I've tried to promote that idea in the past. It didn't really catch on. Most people basically agree with you and feel that I'm some bizarro statistical outlier and not really an example of how to do this well and what we should be aiming for.
As long as the people creating startups generally agree with you, we will continue to see more gig work that craps all over the workers. I don't think it has to be that way. I don't think it should be that way. I see enormous potential for gig work to make the world a better place.
But the world is probably not going to stop being a shitty place full of shitty people just because I'm capable of envisioning something better sprouting from the muck. Most likely, such visions will continue to be crushed under the boot of those in power and continue to go nowhere fast.
Same as it ever was.
Edit2: Also I do not mean to say that the gig-econ does not offer economical sustenance or reinsertion for workers that cannot endure more classical jobs but they're the great minority in these kind of jobs but that is just my own opinion and read on the market
I've seen data that suggests that up to 60 percent of people are at least moderately handicapped. Most downplay it and don't want to wear the label "handicapped" or "disabled."
Such people benefit enormously from having more control over their lives, such as when, where and how much they work. This is one of the things rich people tend to have more of than poor people and I think it has substantial impacts on health, productivity and quality of life.
But it's like 4:30 am where I am and I hope to sleep soon, so I don't care to drone on at great length about this topic, though I no doubt could.
- raws 7y agoThanks for the elaborated answer! I'd like to see the source for the estimated 60% if you can send it later. One thing is since companies like Uber are prime example of how gig-econ works and treats its workers, and that I do not agree with those standards and work ethics I would postulate the opposite. I do not condone the gig-econ style of jobs one bit. I would rather see more flexibility from the work place towards limited workers with proportional social benefits but the gig-econ from my understanding does not even offer that little. If the 60prct holds then you're not the statistical outlier but rather a proper representation of who the gigs are for and I think that would validate their existence but I still see them not necessarily as a raw deal but rather a cheapskate move. But yes some are raw af.
- DoreenMichele 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811988#19815635 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811988#19815635
- lm28469 7y ago> I began doing gig work while deathly ill and homeless. > 60 percent of people are at least moderately handicapped. Most downplay it and don't want to wear the label "handicapped" or "disabled." Such people benefit enormously from having more control over their lives I don't know you nor your story and this isn't a comment about you personally, but writing that kind of sentences with a straight face to defend the gig economy is such a weird thing. You shouldn't have to work while "deathly ill", you shouldn't need the gig economy to survive while handicapped.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- true_religion 7y agoI agree with you, but the thing is we don’t have to destroy the gig economy to get free medical care for all, or housing for the unemployed and handicapped.
- lm28469 7y agoThe problem is that gig economy in Europe actually slowly erodes our rights. People working for uber, deliveroo, &c. don't have the same rights as people working for let's say mcdonalds or starbucks. It's becoming the new normal, no pension, no unemployment benefits, no job security, ...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI really hate dealing with comments like this. I've already written and deleted one upset reply. With 60 percent of the population impaired to some degree, it doesn't work for the world to say "Only the hail and hardy people should work." I didn't qualify for disability. I still don't. I had a corporate job. I quit it so I could prioritize my health. Like many people, my job was harming my health. In contrast, gig work allowed me to get healthier. This world does not usually reward you for having a good sob story. That's not how that works. Saying impaired people shouldn't have to work and from there arranging a world where they aren't allowed to work is a nightmare scenario where any defect cuts you out of the system entirely. When I was a homemaker, I couldn't get good drugs to treat my condition. I was bedridden and being treated like a hypochondriac who got off on cadging antibiotics for funsies. Then I got a proper diagnosis. The following year, with appropriate accommodation for my condition, I attended an eight week GIS Summer School. Halfway through, the air turned yellow, probably from sulfur from a factory, and I began reacting anaphylacticly anytime I set foot outside. I had borrowed $19k to attend. Failure was not an option. A doctor put me on eight prescription drugs so I could finish the program. Twenty-two months of drug withdrawal followed. And it saved my life. All those drugs were a turning point in my condition. People don't really try to help sad sacks live. They don't really try to heal the sick or have compassion for the poor. But they will dope you to the gills because you have a job to do. Working -- on my terms -- saved my life. Maybe that's not a good thing. It's a shitty life in a shitty world full of shitty people and I routinely wish I had died instead. But working was the only viable option I had for so very many reasons. Telling me I shouldn't work is like telling me to go die in a fire for having been born with the wrong genes.