3 ms·
I want to like this show, but it far too often devolves into the hosts giggling uncontrollably like a couple of schoolgirls. It lacks the professionalism and r
by pengaru 7y ago
I want to like this show, but it far too often devolves into the hosts giggling uncontrollably like a couple of schoolgirls.
It lacks the professionalism and respect for the listener's time and attention I've come to expect after listening to shows like This American Life for years.
- yitchelle 7y agoI quite like their on-air banter, and have only found it on a couple of their shows such as "Yes Yes No", or "Super Tech Support". Their other shows seems to be quite professional.
- Judgmentality 7y agoI feel like the show would be boring without their casual laughter. It gives the show personality and keeps it from being stale. To each his own.
- pengaru 7y agoI'm not complaining about the general light-heartedness and casual laughter. There are full on prolonged laughing fits about stuff the audience isn't even aware of. Like we're eavesdropping on kids experiencing a sugar high and giggling over an inside joke. That becomes obnoxious real quick.
- deanCommie 7y agoI've never been confused by what the hosts are laughing about listening to this show. Maybe you have trouble with non-visual social cues?
- jordanpg 7y agoIn the spectrum of podcasts wherein the hosts insist on doing this kind of thing, Reply All keeps it to a tasteful minimum. But I agree in general; podcast hosts need to learn that their inside jokes are not really funny or fun to a broader audience.
- deanCommie 7y agoWhat a ridiculous criticism. Their inside jokes aren't inside between the two of them, they are inside WITH THE AUDIENCE. Yes, that may make a new listener listening to an episode for the first time get less out of it than a long time listener. But to the long time listeners, it is an absolutely delight, and it is exactly inside jokes and callbacks that breed loyal long term fanbases.
- swivelmaster 7y agoDepends on the episode. The investigative episodes have little to none of this.