3 ms·
> The very fact people still burn coal in cities in the 21st century is mind-boggling. There are a lot of interesting things you could say about this. A coal
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> The very fact people still burn coal in cities in the 21st century is mind-boggling.
There are a lot of interesting things you could say about this.
A coal plant needs workers and it also needs good transportation links. (To bring the coal in.) It needs to support the workers. It needs to be hooked up to an electrical grid. So it's sort of a natural nexus for the development of a city. People who can live in some other city might prefer that, but there will be plenty of people for whom the Coal City is a natural choice. If cities naturally grow around coal plants, then it doesn't make sense to be surprised that there are cities with coal plants in them.
Taking the original comment in a totally different direction, this is an angle I don't think is discussed enough in relation to electric cars. We may not need to burn coal inside cities, but we burn oil all the time, so we can move around. This produces the same undesirable smog that coal does. There's a big fight over whether electric cars release more or less smog well-to-wheels than gasoline cars do. But I almost never see anyone asking whether, even if electric cars release more smog, it might not be better to have the smog all produced centrally at a power plant somewhere than widely distributed in the middle of concentrated residential areas.
- maxerickson 7y agoThey are talking about home heating with coal. You can site a power plant regionally, it doesn't have to be particularly adjacent to residences.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThere is no discussion if electric cars release “more smog than gasoline cars” just due to the fact that “smog” isn’t any specific substance. It’s a phenomenon that depends just as much on the wind direction as on air quality. In less literal terms, there might be a debate about relative amounts of CO2. But that is mostly a debate that happens online instigated by ideological opponents of electrification. Electric cars use less energy even including production and even if the energy mix consists mostly of fossile fuels. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_aspects_of_the_electric_car https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_aspects_of_the_e.... The advantages are even starker for other emissions such NOX or particulates: even without renewables and nuclear energy in the mix, electric cars need less energy because the efficiency of one large power plant is higher than thousands of engines. And that energy is generated with fewer emissions because, again, centralized generation allows more investment into clean technology.