3 ms·
There is a faint whiff of hypocrisy in hiring foreign labour, it suggests to me that some sort of cash-in-hand deal is afoot that isn't in line with local labou
by roenxi 7y ago
There is a faint whiff of hypocrisy in hiring foreign labour, it suggests to me that some sort of cash-in-hand deal is afoot that isn't in line with local labour practices.
This is a serious and concerning situation. However, it also has a certain schadenfreude of wealthy Europeans waking up in horror at having to pay local wages in excess of local social safety nets in order to grow their own food.
- Zancarius 7y ago> it suggests to me that some sort of cash-in-hand deal is afoot that isn't in line with local labour practices. Absolutely. It's exploitative to be sure, at least here in the US. Farms don't want to pay more for labor, and in some cases (perhaps the plurality of them), the migrant laborers are paid under the table to avoid the tax burden on both ends. Of course, this means the company doesn't have to worry about payroll taxes, workman's comp, unemployment, etc., and the workers aren't going to register with the IRS to get a tax ID. Additionally, the laborers are paid so little it's difficult to think of this in any other way than as a form of slavery sanctioned by the state as it turns a blind eye to what amount to egregious violations of labor laws. Part of the blame I place on us as consumers. If we weren't so price sensitive to things like fresh produce, perhaps we could pay more such that things are done above board and we become less reliant on migrant labor. Either way, something has to change.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThere’s certainly exploitation happening, but it’s just as true that these were relatively good jobs for those that did them based on costs of living in their home countries. As such, this practice has been important to reduce differences between richer and poorer countries, not just in Europe but also between the US and Mexico, for example. That Schadenfreude seems to be prevalent among the far right here, who might just as soon become the object of it when differences start to widen again and thousands of people start seeking a better live by migrating outright.