6 ms·
I'm not sure that I want the government in a position to be a single point of control for which websites I can or cannot access.
by sneak 7y ago
I'm not sure that I want the government in a position to be a single point of control for which websites I can or cannot access.
- freehunter 7y agoAbsolutely nothing about public internet in any way implies anything even remotely related to your strawman argument.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> nothing about public internet in any way implies anything even remotely related to your strawman argument Why not? If the government has a monopoly on internet access, it becomes easier for voters to call for certain sites being blocked or certain sorts of traffic be monitored and/or intercepted.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- freehunter 7y agoIf we're playing that game, there's a million things they could do as well, but it doesn't make any of them likely. Hell, they could do what you're talking about right now, other countries do that even though their Internet access isn't controlled by the government. The porn ban in the UK is a great example of privately-controlled ISPs being forced to block certain sites. I'll repeat, there is absolutely nothing about publicly funded Internet service that in any way even remotely connects "internet access as a public utility" to "government starts blocking certain sites". They could do it right now if they wanted to.
- uk_programmer 7y agoThe porn ban didn't happen. Even with the "don't go to the pirate bay or we send you a nasty letter" legislation, they stop bothering doing that because nobody paid any attention and threw the letter in the bin.
- coldpie 7y agoThis is a blatant violation of the 1st amendment. You are at more risk of this from private entities, who are not bound by the 1st amendment.
- sneak 7y agoPerhaps. Competition is a realtime mechanism for stopping this sort of fuckery on a provider level presently. I can switch ISPs immediately (provided that there is more than one around). Remediations for 1A violations are anything but realtime. You could suffer rights abuses for a very long time with no immediate or cost-effective recourse. Also, such a circumstance in which your 1A rights are violated by your government ISP, which may be eventually protected by courts, remains inherently dangerous for example during declared periods of emergency where the usual rights and remedies are "temporarily" (weeks or months) suspended. Imagine the situation were this the case right now, and your government ISP disconnects you today (let's say on some bogus "local" authority). How long do you think it would be before the thing winds its way through the courts and your port finally gets ordered to be turned back on? A month? Three months? Six? How much money has it cost you in legal fees? How many dollars did you lose from not being able to work in that time due to being entirely offline? I don't trust any one player being the "only game in town" no matter who they are or what remedies I have against them. Making it state-run means that not only are they the only game in town (like Comcast is now in a lot of places), but that it's impossible to change that situation. It makes it permanent. We need more competition, not less. More opportunity for more people to create businesses and jobs, not less. I think the people of Flint should be able to chime in on this thread.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- enraged_camel 7y ago>> I can switch ISPs immediately (provided that there is more than one around). You may want to look at what percentage of America has this kind of choice (and whether it is a choice between viable and high quality alternatives, as opposed to ones that are equally shitty).
- ksk 7y agoA private company has to comply with all governmental laws and regulations. If the government wants something banned, they can just create a law that lets them do that. They've already demonstrated that they can easily do that with the patriot act.
- LatteLazy 7y agoThe only thing stopping them now is the first amendment. That doesn't change depending on ownership. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for a wider deeper interpretation of 1A. But it's not relevant to this matter really...