2 ms·
I disagree - school is an excellent place to learn skills, especially if you do sciencey stuff. It teaches you how to question things fairly and appropriately,
by vacri 16y ago
I disagree - school is an excellent place to learn skills, especially if you do sciencey stuff. It teaches you how to question things fairly and appropriately, and how to do and dissect research.
When I left tertiary education we were all sitting around doing the trendy thing and bemoaning how university had been worthless; we couldn't remember any facts. Then it dawned on us that we got insights into industry, learned how to communicate professionally, learned how to find the truth or the most truthful path, how to research, how to critique work, learned how to better collaborate with others, gained a small measure of self-direction (tertiary is the first level of education where it's up to you to show up), tastes of politicking and how to survive it, professional ethics, so on and so forth. Occupational skills were learned in addition to all of those. Part of the above meshes with culture, but they're all tangible if non-obvious skills. If you want someone to do a root-cause analysis, you're not going to turn to the dropout unless he's talented and a passionate self-driven learner. Most folks are not this.
As always GIGO, but you learn a hell of a lot of skills in tertiary education, they're just not all in 14-point font on your syllabus.
- TheSOB88 16y agoI dunno, man, that'd sure be nice if school taught you how to think, how to question. Maybe your friends do that. But schooling in general seems to be "them's the facts, get used to it". Industrial-strength indoctrination.
- ChuckMcM 16y agoSome colleges teach you to think, some don't. A 'classic' liberal arts education starts with debate, discussion, and rigor. An engineering school starts with terminology, overviews (survey classes), and specialization options. Learning to think takes both an institution willing to teach it and a student willing to learn it. However, it seems that a number of people, possibly more than half, under-estimate the value of learning how to motivate yourself to finish things in the presence of losing interest in doing so. Lots of people "get" the joke that the last 10% of a project takes 90% of the effort but they don't get the fact that folks who never learned how to motivate themselves through the finish (of which having a college degree is a reasonable signal) will 'drop out' at the 90% point at best, and become dead weight at worst. Combine that with the unemployment statistics of folks with versus those without college degrees and statistically it seems you want to be in the 'with' group. The bottom line is that college is the first place you get to show the world your work ethic and your 'mettle.' That's because for many its the first place where not-going is considered a legitimate option. You can be very successful without finishing college, see Bill Gates or Steve Jobs as examples, just like you can get into the National Football League or Major League Baseball by going to open tryouts. If your personality is suited to that, its going to be a great option for you. But success on those roads isn't the "more common" outcome.
- nostrademons 16y agoUniversity is a whole lot different from K-12 schooling, and which university makes a difference as well. I felt I learned a lot about respect for data, the scientific method, how to formulate and test hypotheses, etc. in my physics classes at Amherst. I learned mostly facts at UMass. I'm not sure I learned anything about what science really was through my K-12 studies. One of my main beefs with K-12 science education is that it mistakes the results of science for science itself. So kids are taught evolution, they're taught plate tectonics, they're taught Newton's Laws, but they're rarely taught how these were discovered, or the rigorous data-driven experimentation process that's refined them. The scientific method is covered as 6 bullet points that get glossed over in a week, and never returned to. In many cases, if a student actually does science - they question the recieved wisdom of their teacher, and go off and do the experiments themselves, and report back objectively on the results - they'll be labeled a disruptive student and sent to the principal's. Hell, if the science involves chemistry, they'll probably be reported to the FBI and arrested for making bombs.
- vacri 16y agoSorry, by 'school' I was meaning tertiary only. High school didn't add much in the way of critical thinking, I agree.