3 ms·

A lot of stuff gets lost to time. My friends Dad had a huge record collection of Jazz. When CDs came out he started replacing them. He still had hundreds of

A lot of stuff gets lost to time. My friends Dad had a huge record collection of Jazz. When CDs came out he started replacing them. He still had hundreds of records, and lamented "a lot of these aren't going to be re-issued". I'm assuming that there is a lot of music out there lost to time.

ndespres 7y ago
Certainly there is. In 2008 there was a fire that destroyed many of the master tapes for old recordings, this will no doubt prevent new releases or remasters of many old albums. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/magazine/universal-fire-master-recordings.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/magazine/universal-fire-m...
- acomjean 7y ago
  Interesting. what should be saved. Whats weird though is that all that music was sitting in a private archive. What are the chances someone would go through them.. The public can't discover them. So there they sit. Part 6. A skeptic might argue that this is as it should be. In the 140-odd years since Thomas Edison invented the phonograph, countless recordings have been made under the auspices of record companies. To conserve anything close to all those recordings has proved impossible; it may not even be desirable. The caretaking of canonical material, the Bings and Billies and Nirvanas, must naturally take priority. To ask that the same level of attention be lavished on all music, including stuff that holds interest only for obscurantists, is to demand a preservation standard that prevails in no other area of culture. If the sole vestiges of thousands of old recordings are a few stray 45s lining the shelves of collectors — perhaps that’s not a cultural tragedy, perhaps that’s a commercial-art ecosystem functioning properly. Perhaps. But history holds a counterargument. Many recordings were ignored for decades, only to be rediscovered and enshrined as Imperishable Art. The Velvet Underground were a commercial bust in the late 1960s and early ’70s but have proved to be one of the most influential groups in history. Then there’s Nick Drake, the English singer-songwriter who recorded three LPs of dreamy jazz-inflected folk between 1969 and 1972, before his death at age 26. During Drake’s lifetime, his albums sold modestly. A cult fan base developed following the release of a box set; in 1999, Drake’s song “Pink Moon” appeared in a Volkswagen commercial, and sales went through the roof. All three of Drake’s LPs were included in Rolling Stone magazine’s 2005 tally of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.
mayneack 7y ago
For a long time I used what.cd to find digital copies of most of my Dad's record collection of 60s-80s folk music. A few of them we even managed to ship to users to create high quality rips of. Sadly it got shut down and the replacements haven't caught up yet. https://heavy.com/tech/2016/11/what-cd-shut-down-music-torrenting-site-oinks-why-who-when-private-tracker/ https://heavy.com/tech/2016/11/what-cd-shut-down-music-torre...

ndespres 7y ago

Certainly there is. In 2008 there was a fire that destroyed many of the master tapes for old recordings, this will no doubt prevent new releases or remasters of many old albums. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/magazine/universal-fire-master-recordings.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/magazine/universal-fire-m...

acomjean 7y ago
Interesting. what should be saved. Whats weird though is that all that music was sitting in a private archive. What are the chances someone would go through them.. The public can't discover them. So there they sit. Part 6. A skeptic might argue that this is as it should be. In the 140-odd years since Thomas Edison invented the phonograph, countless recordings have been made under the auspices of record companies. To conserve anything close to all those recordings has proved impossible; it may not even be desirable. The caretaking of canonical material, the Bings and Billies and Nirvanas, must naturally take priority. To ask that the same level of attention be lavished on all music, including stuff that holds interest only for obscurantists, is to demand a preservation standard that prevails in no other area of culture. If the sole vestiges of thousands of old recordings are a few stray 45s lining the shelves of collectors — perhaps that’s not a cultural tragedy, perhaps that’s a commercial-art ecosystem functioning properly. Perhaps. But history holds a counterargument. Many recordings were ignored for decades, only to be rediscovered and enshrined as Imperishable Art. The Velvet Underground were a commercial bust in the late 1960s and early ’70s but have proved to be one of the most influential groups in history. Then there’s Nick Drake, the English singer-songwriter who recorded three LPs of dreamy jazz-inflected folk between 1969 and 1972, before his death at age 26. During Drake’s lifetime, his albums sold modestly. A cult fan base developed following the release of a box set; in 1999, Drake’s song “Pink Moon” appeared in a Volkswagen commercial, and sales went through the roof. All three of Drake’s LPs were included in Rolling Stone magazine’s 2005 tally of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.

mayneack 7y ago

For a long time I used what.cd to find digital copies of most of my Dad's record collection of 60s-80s folk music. A few of them we even managed to ship to users to create high quality rips of. Sadly it got shut down and the replacements haven't caught up yet. https://heavy.com/tech/2016/11/what-cd-shut-down-music-torrenting-site-oinks-why-who-when-private-tracker/ https://heavy.com/tech/2016/11/what-cd-shut-down-music-torre...