4 ms·
How about if the offer was $1000 plus $10 per Mb/s and the maximum is 10Mbps ? You would switch because you've imagined this service is magically cheaper and b
by tialaramex 7y ago
How about if the offer was $1000 plus $10 per Mb/s and the maximum is 10Mbps ?
You would switch because you've imagined this service is magically cheaper and better, but now I say it'll be expensive and worse are you still enthusiastic?
Providing network service is a utility, and so yes razor thin margins are typical and that's too bad. It does make very high capital investment (such as launching huge numbers of satellites every few years) difficult to stomach though.
These projects (whatever Musk says about them when hyping his company) deliver expensive network access to places where it's otherwise not practical to offer service at all. They aren't going head-to-head with Comcast, or even with AOL, they're competing with "Physically take a day's / week's work to the A site where they have network access".
- ghaff 7y ago>These projects (whatever Musk says about them when hyping his company) deliver expensive network access to places where it's otherwise not practical to offer service at all. They aren't going head-to-head with Comcast, or even with AOL, they're competing with "Physically take a day's / week's work to the A site where they have network access". Yeah, there are a lot of places in the US--some of which aren't even really all that rural--that just don't have good Internet options. Today, satellite basically falls into the slightly better than nothing category but it's neither price-competitive nor good if you have essentially any other option. While I know people in tech who make do with only a satellite connection, I'm sure many reading this wouldn't consider that viable and it will be increasingly less so over time. 5G will presumably help in some cases as it rolls out but it certainly won't reach everywhere. And, presumably, over time places that don't have a certain level of Internet access will be increasingly unsuitable at least for long-term residence.
- ericd 7y agoI’d be careful about comparing current satellite internet with what Starlink is promising. The latency and total throughout differences are huge.
- ghaff 7y agoThat's why I specifically referred to current satellite. Of course, future satellite could be much better. (Although we'll have to see.)
- ericd 7y agoRight right, I was guessing you were familiar, I was just pointing it out because I think a lot of people reading think about it in the context of HughesNet et al, and I think that leads them to write it off prematurely. I read a nice overview of the constellations a while back, but I realize now that it's actually pretty outdated (2018, and it talks about optical crosslinks between SpaceX's satellites, which has been punted for now): http://www.mit.edu/~portillo/files/Comparison-LEO-IAC-2018-slides.pdf http://www.mit.edu/~portillo/files/Comparison-LEO-IAC-2018-s... So I don't know if my comment about throughput is accurate anymore.
- BenjiWiebe 7y ago5G? Around here in central Kansas 4G is spotty, and there's plenty of places that your phone will lose all data connection, and occasionally even lose the connection entirely. Also a max of 10Mbps would sure beat a max of 6Mbps from CenturyLink. Though at $1000 that would probably be too much...