4 ms·
Ah, ok. As a technical note, I wouldn't call those words "syntactically plural". They are syntactically plural in that they can be the subject of verbs inflect
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
Ah, ok.
As a technical note, I wouldn't call those words "syntactically plural". They are syntactically plural in that they can be the subject of verbs inflected for a plural subject, but that's not the best criterion. There are a few relevant questions:
1. Does it have the form of a plural noun?
2. Does it take plural verb agreement?
3. Does it take singular verb agreement?
Phrases such as "the poor" are hard to call "syntactically plural" because they fail criterion 1. They pass criteria 2 ("yes") and 3 ("no"), but nouns that are syntactically singular can also pass criterion 2.
Scissors (syntactically plural, semantically singular):
1. Yes. Scissors appears to be a plural noun in terms of raw morphology.
2. Yes. Scissors has obligatory plural verb agreement.
3. No. Despite the semantics, scissors has obligatory plural verb agreement.
Family (syntactically singular, semantically plural):
1. No.
2. Yes. My family are all painters.
3. Yes. My family is coming to visit me this summer.
With only the verb agreements supporting the classification of "the poor" as plural, you get into an unresolvable argument over whether singular verb agreement doesn't happen because it's impossible (syntactically plural) or because "the poor" are always being considered plurally (syntactically singular).
If you want to consider "the poor" as a mass noun, you also run into the problem that there are no syntactically plural mass nouns. Mass nouns are always syntactically singular. (Well, this depends on how you want to classify scissors and pants, I guess.)
- dragonwriter 7y agoEnglish has no “form of a plural noun”; it has a regular pattern of how, for countable nouns, singular and plural forms relate to each other (and even for such pairs, there are a number of irregular patterns with multiple examples, and a number of pairs with sui generis relations. “Family” is a singular collective noun; singular collective nouns are a special case and can take plural or singular verbs. “Poor" is a plural mass (not collective) noun, it takes exclusively plural verbs > If you want to consider "the poor" as a mass noun, you also run into the problem that there are no syntactically plural mass nouns There's a whole broad class of them that are structurally just like "poor" as I mentioned and gave examples of in the grandparent post. Sure, if you ignore that broad and very frequently used class of mass nouns, there aren't any other plural mass nouns. But... > Mass nouns are always syntactically singular. (Well, this depends on how you want to classify scissors and pants, I guess.) Scissors and pants are normal countable (and so, not mass) plural nouns that just happen to not have a singular form because the quantum unit is conventionally taken to be a pair. This isn't really in question anywhere.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Scissors and pants are normal countable (and so, not mass) plural nouns that just happen to not have a singular form because the quantum unit is conventionally taken to be a pair. This isn't really in question anywhere. I don't have a strong position on this, but they aren't normal countable plural nouns. "Two pants" is ungrammatical; it must be "two pairs of pants". (Expanding a bit: it's easy to say that "one pants" is impossible because pants is plural. But pants require counting in pairs regardless of how many you're talking about; it's not just a restriction on grammatical number. Whether you think "four pants" should correspond to "four pairs of pants" or "two pairs of pants", it isn't possible to say "four pants", and this is not normal behavior for a count noun.)