4 ms·
Some of the points here are good, but I think some of them are too simplistic. This article makes a huge assumption: that performance is the only factor you're
by kube-system 7y ago
Some of the points here are good, but I think some of them are too simplistic.
This article makes a huge assumption: that performance is the only factor you're hiring for, and therefore unstructured interviews are worthless. That would make sense if you're interviewing for a factory of emotionless robots. But humans are social beings, and human performance as a team is more complicated than a sum of individual productivity. You need to take into account the affect that the hire would have on the entire team. Just about everyone has an anecdote about a coworker sometime during their career that was super productive, but completely demoralizing to the team. This is a very valid reason to give unstructured interviews, and if you ask smart people who give them, this is what they're looking for.
I totally agree with the utility of work-sample tests. There is nothing better to see someone's performance than simply giving them a small but relevant chunk of work to do. It is very important to keep them short and flexible though.
If you make them too lengthy, you'll skew the results against people who have better things to do with their time. What kind of person works for free anyway? Certainly not the caliber of people I want to work with.
And if you make the test too specific to certain technologies, you skew the test against smart engineers who are less familiar with that tech. If you want a problem solver, give them a problem in plain words, and let their solution be open-ended.
I don't agree with making tests particularly hard, though. Make it nuanced, yes, but of normal difficulty for a given assignment. You need the appropriate people to do the job. If you only hire top-tier algorithmic experts for your basic CRUD app, then you're going to have a very expensive CRUD app with a bored and demoralized team. If someone does sloppy work, you can spot this on a normal exercise as much as you can on an unreasonably difficult one.
- itronitron 7y ago>> What kind of person works for free anyway? I would expect everyone at some point has done something (worked) for free, either on speculation, as a favor, or for bragging rights. Open source wouldn't be a thing otherwise.
- kube-system 7y agoMost work being done on significant open source projects is by people who are being paid for that work.
- geoffroberts 7y agoGreat points—I completely agree that the human element of hiring is of critical importance when it comes to building effective and high functioning teams. This article is intended to focus on the more technical/job focused component of hiring. That said, I agree with your comments here across the board.
- candybar 7y agoWith respect to your point about unstructured interviews - keep in mind that any statistical measure of performance isn't based on an objective measure of output - it's almost certainly based on performance ratings, which take into account "impact on the entire team." If anything, my experience is that charming, likable people that do well in unstructured interviews are also better at getting better performance ratings than they deserve. Also, I think you're implicitly assuming that structured interviews cannot measure soft skills as they relate to workplace behavior. I would argue the opposite - the only way to ensure high standards for these types of skills is to have a structured interview. Otherwise, you're not systematically trying to hire people whose workplace behavior enhances group productivity, you're just hoping that whatever random biases that interviewers bring to the table end up being a net positive. Being a productive team player isn't about being able to impress a random person in an unstructured conversation - it's about knowing how to behave productively (combined with the willingness to do so, which unfortunately is contextual and virtually impossible to directly observe) in a wide variety of challenging situations.