9 ms·
Yes and no. I think it's better in terms of overall "health" (content, toxicity, moderation, privacy, spam) than other, more popular forums (e.g. Reddit), but
by paxys 7y ago
Yes and no.
I think it's better in terms of overall "health" (content, toxicity, moderation, privacy, spam) than other, more popular forums (e.g. Reddit), but that could just be directly because of its small size and relatively niche appeal.
My biggest problem is that it stopped being a community for tech entrepreneurs a long time ago. Everyone is now bearish on everything by default. Every idea is pointless. Every new product is useless. Every company is evil. There's no point building or launching anything. It's just people complaining about everything rather than improving things and building the future.
- ahelwer 7y agoI don't think this is a problem. The greatest concentration of wealth in this cycle has been around mass surveillance & behavior modification. Gone are the days of Google viewed naively as some happy-go-lucky do-no-evil org. We are all as software engineers forced to grapple with the consequences of our work. Optimism is, basically, uncalled for. Why should I be enthusiastic about another VC-backed company set up to spy on & manipulate me? I disagree with your implied dichotomy between "complaining" and "improving things and building the future" - when everyone who is "building the future" is chasing the exact same surveillance-capitalist business model, what do you propose our reaction should be?
- omarchowdhury 7y agoWhy do you think it's like this? Are those left expressing the nihilism of the rejected? Surely, the successful (the kind of success that YCombinator strives for) are eternally optimistic.
- callmeed 7y agoI blame it in part on "hot take culture". From sports to politics to business to tech, it has become an unfortunate part of public discourse. Think of it like contrarianism or playing devil's advocate to the extreme. I don't know the cause, perhaps some see it as the only way to stand out when its so easy to publish your thoughts. Maybe its yet another negative externality from social media. It's easy to spot in comments, posts, and articles–they have titles like: "... is actually bad" "... is actually good" "... considered harmful" "Actually, ... " "No, you don't ... "
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 7y agoI can think of two answers. (1) The "senior" members do not set a good example, to say the least. People who have spent ten years honing their rhetorical skill and accumulating karma/fans so that their comments float to the top of every thread have a disproportionate influence on the overall tone. Too many of those seem to think their own startup idea from ten years ago was the absolute bees' knees, therefore anything else must be lame by comparison, and they're eager to say so at every opportunity. (2) A lot of newer members have grown up (professionally) at FAANGs that are very opinionated in their own way, which is quite contrary to how startups work, and they are accordingly skeptical of anything startup-related. Put those together and a torrent of negativity is pretty much inevitable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- billmalarky 7y agoYour last point speaks to me. I've become a bit disillusioned with how negative HN seems to have become. Yes I'm well aware this has long been an issue (see: famous HN post from Drew Houston announcing DropBox), but it feels amplified these days. Maybe it's a sign of the times. There are certainly a lot of issues in todays world that seem to be increasing cynicism, but I'll see new tech posted on HN that is incredibly exciting only to see a bunch of comments tearing it to pieces over nit picks. It's like the community has lost ability to hold vision and have excitement for potential. New creations are full of problems -- there hasn't been time to iron out the wrinkles -- but a lot of HN comments expect perfection from the get go and when they don't see it they rip the creation to shreds. It's demoralizing.
- seppin 7y agoIn most communities, the more skeptical you sound the "smarter" people think you are. Optimism is native and therefore stupid. Sadly that mentality has found its way here.
- drstewart 7y agoI agree with this. Some communities have taken this so far to be completely toxic (again, reddit). HN isn't that bad yet, but it's sad that people conflate cynicism with being "realistic" or "knowledgeable and worldly".
- seppin 7y agoI've noticed this in the EU/US divide. Anything pessimistic in Europe is deemed smart and cool, and Americans are looked upon as native as dumb for their general optimism. Then again Europeans also hate how much "moaning" goes on amongst themselves. Honestly it's easy to be down on everything all the time, try being an optimist these days. Not exactly easy.
- friendlybus 7y agoIt’s easy to find something to criticise, knowing what’s good about something or adding a constructive thought requires knowledge of the problem your product is trying to solve or the tech behind it. Fewer people have the latter.
- smolder 7y agoIt does skew heavily toward complaining. I think part of reason is that people feel more compelled to comment over gripes than to express appreciation. When I see something I like, I usually upvote and move on. If I see a problem with something I'm reading I will often comment. Despite that there's quite a lot of positive content and conversation that I would miss if I stopped reading and participating. Even the negative can be informative and valuable.
- raphlinus 7y agoI would generally agree but think it's a bit better than this. The thing that makes HN remarkable is that there are often top subject matter experts participating in discussion. Just to pick one example of many, Walter Bright often participates in discussions involving the D language or related topics. Similarly, this is the place where valuable discussion and insights around WebGPU have been shared, even though some of that discussion is in the form of complaints ("Apple is trying to sabotage a SPIR-V based approach"). I don't think the better health is just because of smaller size and niche appeal, I think the reach of HN is considerable. I think we really do need to thank the tireless moderation work of dang and others for that.
- TheDesolate0 7y agoTo be fair, it's easy to be a leader in your field of 22. ;-p Sorry, I couldn't resist.
- stronglikedan 7y agoThere are dozens of us! DOZENS!
- raphlinus 7y agoI get your joke, but want to push back on it. First, insight from D is relevant for many other topics. Second, if this forum gathers leading experts in a wide range of niche specialties (which I believe it does), that is a remarkable achievement and one that cannot be claimed by most other discussion groups.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- smoyer 7y agoInteresting perspective - I never really thought about the tone of my comments. I've always played "the devil's advocate" because it's the way that the smaller start-ups I was involved with stay alive. I'm going to make sure that I praise good ideas first ... and then perhaps warn of potential pitfalls. Sorry if I participated in turning HN into a downer. As an aside, I don't read HN that way. Even when there's a pessimistic tone, I often read right through it and think to myself "that's some good advice". It will be interesting to see whether we become more bearish simply due to the COVID-19 environment we're all working in now.
- zizee 7y ago> I'm going to make sure that I praise good ideas first This is something I am trying to do in real life as well (although I don't always succeed). For some reason it's really easy for me to open my mouth to talk about weakenesses/problems with things, but it's not as natural to highlight the positive aspects. I also try to say aloud my positive thoughts about people when they pop in my head instead of keeping them to myself.
- smoyer 7y agoI've also been handwriting small thank you notes and "kudo cards" the last few years ... it just never occurred to me that people here needed the same type of validation as those I interact with IRL.
- JohnL4 7y agoPragmatic stuff first, then emotional. :-) Pragmatic: when hearing praise, my thoughts are sometimes, "yeah, yeah, cut to the chase." I guess you gotta read your audience. Emotional: It IS easy to be negative. We also tend to over-experience/over-perceive the negative, which (partially) is how we get over-reaction to criticism or advice, even when asked for. And sometimes we really just want validation. I guess you gotta, uh, read your audience.
- ksj2114 7y agoI agree. Indie Hackers is more positive IMO
- jsonne 7y agoCynicism is easy and for whatever reason in the cultural zeitgeist tearing down other people/ideas/things is seen as being an intellectual.
- trophycase 7y ago"for whatever reason" I think part of the reason is that business has co-opted optimism and positivity. To the point where being positive seems to not be genuine. Furthermore, I think if the 80s-00s have taught us anything, it's that technology and business aren't going to fix the core problems us in the first world are facing currently... trust, community, health, environment, stress, etc. especially considering these are mostly problems caused by technology and business.
- jsonne 7y agoI'm not narrowly talking about business or technology. It seems endemic that lazily poking holes in things while offering no viable counterpoint is the defacto mode of many pseudo-intellectuals. It's saddening.
- zzzcpan 7y agoThis fake looking optimism and positivity is HN's own policy though. They are not moderating out shallow positivity and praise, like they do negativity, and even tried to actively push people to be positive at some point. This is might be the reason why negativity looks genuine, i.e. too much non-genuine positivity.
- rezeroed 7y agoBut are you still passionate? I think the industry has matured and lost its fun and sense of adventure. Once upon a time captain crunch and blue box, war dialling, or office-wide unreal ctf at the end of the day; now we have sprints, OKRs, and codes of conduct. It's becoming accountancy.
- bawolff 7y agoSometimes i feel like its a bit polarized. On one side you have people being cynical about everything but then you get the opposite people who are supportive of everything and upset at the slightest cyncism. The tech industry is full of silly ideas. If someone says they made an app for taking pictures of unpopped popcorn kernels, i think its fair to ask "why would anyone want this?"
- braindead_in 7y agoIt is the age of tech-nihilism after all.
- newfangle 7y agoI wonder how many people on hn can code hello world.
- NateEag 7y agoI'd think most. I'm definitely not one of the more talented people here, but off the top of my head... Python 3: print('Hello, world!') JS: console.log('Hello, world!') Bash: echo 'Hello world!' PHP: Hello, world! C: #include <stdio.h> int main() { printf("Hello, world!"); } On my phone, so I couldn't swear they're perfect. Been a decade since I wrote any C, particularly. My point is just that Hello World is really easy.
- tehjoker 7y agoSkepticism was a big jump in intellectual development when religion dominated and you're seeing a similar reaction now. Pieces of technology that make our lives easier without taking something else from us (such as privacy) or punishing workers (gig services stealing tips) are so rare. Better tech is possible, but profit seeking seems not to be able to deliver it.
- chx 7y ago> Every new product is useless. Most new products fall in two categories: bros trying to recreate mommy hotel by introducing new and new ways to exploit poorer people but since it's an app it's not seen as bad as hiring servants. The other is just pure rent seeking. Products genuinely creating value and making the life of normal people are extraordinarily rare.
- NathanKP 7y agoI've been on HN for 11 years now, and each year its been more negative. At some point the best way to get upvotes turned into "say something pedantic that contradicts the parent post or criticizes it." This is a big part of the reason why I dialed my contributions way back, and I've heard the same from many other great people in the IRL tech community that I respect. Unfortunately each time a positive person stops contributing on HN it just leads to the site becoming more negative. It is a vicious cycle.
- conanbatt 7y agoThere is also a very strong anti-capitalist trend. Anti-funding, anti-money, anti-profits. This is bonkers for a startup-community.
- dang 7y agoThat's because it's not just a startup community. It's an amalgam of many subcommunities, including (in no particular order) startup founders/employees, bootstrappers and freelancers, open-source hackers, academics, internet culture / forum mavens, activists, and many more. I think it's probably true that the anti-startup voices have grown, but that's also reflective of larger social trends.
- SturgeonsLaw 7y agoThe namesake original hacker culture tended to have a solid anti-establishment streak and valued accumulation of knowledge over material goods, and I think that's still highly represented among the community here
- xwdv 7y agoEvery positive comment is pretty much the same, but every negative comment is negative in its own way. There is no point in positive comments. You know what they’re going to say and they rarely add anything that the article didn’t already express. Negative comments are more intellectually satisfying to unpack.
- sankalpb 7y agothanks, do you see this pattern ('it's just people complaining about everything rather than improving things and building a future') as indicative of HN? for you, is this a result of endogenous or exogenous forces? both?
- ziedzic 7y agoThis couldn’t be more accurate. I have also heard the same from at least 3 others irl. But this is a general trend I’ve noticed every year with every community on the internet.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt somewhat annoys me when people call HN small or niche or similar. It's a common sentiment and I'm rather baffled by it. Reddit as a whole is huge. I think of Reddit like a megalopolis, not a community. I think some of the subreddits are communities. It would be sort of like a strong neighborhood association within a really big city. The neighborhood or neighborhood association can have a strong sense of local community. The city as a whole probably cannot. HN gets about 5 million unique visitors per month. It's the largest forum I consistently participate in. I'm not personally aware of any other "tech" forums that are larger. For example, Lobste.rs is much smaller. And that's one of the names I hear the most. According to this source, there are currently 58 subreddits with more than 5 million subscribers: https://redditmetrics.com/top https://redditmetrics.com/top Some of them are for STEM topics and maybe Data Is Beautiful is sort of like HN, but I'm not seeing anything obviously aimed at programmers the way HN is somewhat positioned. (Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.) Facebook is also huge. I want to say it's got like a billion users. But it's not a community of a billion people. It's a bunch of individuals with a curated list of "friends." There are Facebook groups. That's where you would look for "communities" on Facebook. I have no data on them and I'm not going to look. I would be curious if anyone else can even name any other online communities with at least 5 million members that aren't on either Reddit or Facebook. From where I sit, HN looks quite large and looks to me to be possibly one of the largest tech communities. I welcome any data that suggests otherwise.
- paxys 7y agoWhy compare subreddit subscribers to HN viewers? Reddit overall has over half a billion monthly users, most of them likely visiting the top few subreddits. There is really no comparison when talking about scale. Numbers for Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, StackOverflow, LinkedIn etc. are even higher. And then there are all the non-US ones. Relative to these HN can be considered small.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoHN is a single unit. It doesn't have sub communities the way Reddit and Facebook do. So I think individual subreddits are a more similar basis of comparison than Reddit as a whole. I personally mostly participate on Reddit in relatively small communities with, say, 20k subscribers or 80k subscribers or a lot less than that. There are different mods for different Reddits. If you don't get along well with one Reddit, you can go elsewhere. There can be membership overlap but you aren't necessarily subject to the "I shot the sheriff" phenomenon where no amount of trying to behave and fit in is ever enough because one or more of the mods has it in for you. I have been on the receiving end of that. Such experiences help shape my conceptualization of the problem space and how to define a "community unit." LinkedIn seems to be akin to Facebook in how it works. Twitter is extremely different in how it gets organized. I don't think it compares at all to things like HN or Reddit. I'm not really familiar with Pinterest or StackOverflow.
- mwfunk 7y agoI think that's just the fate of every online forum. It's comment entropy, and it's inevitable anywhere, everywhere, always. You saw it with Usenet in the '90s (especially after Eternal September struck), you saw it with Slashdot in the late '90s, and you see it just about anyplace really. The bigger a community is, the more diluted it gets, and the more comment bike shedding happens: people posting for the sake of posting, and not putting any more thought into what they post than they do in most casual conversations (or even less thought), etc. What happens when a forum or medium expands to basically the entire population? Twitter, at least for people who read both popular posts and reply chains that those posts inspire. It makes Eternal September look like a book club full of the world's most articulate English professors sipping tea and politely conversing about complex plot points while taking care not to say things that could be misinterpreted or incorrectly seen as a personal attack on someone else. When people post good things (not necessarily positive things, but at least negative things that spark good conversations), those posts may or may not inspire other good posts. They probably won't inspire bad posts, worst case is that they don't inspire any responses but that's OK- good posts stand on their own and not everything needs to be a conversation. Similarly, when people post bad things (not necessarily negative things, just things that spark bad conversations), it will hardly ever inspire good posts in response, but it's very likely to inspire many more bad posts. So, good posts inspire more good posts, bad posts inspire more bad posts, but IME bad posts are like 10-100x more likely to spark followups. Going back to Usenet, you could have the greatest newsgroup in the world, but it could all collapse due to an influx of shitty posting from a teeny tiny subset of the people reading the group. It's like a virus that infects a forum. The bad posts explode in response to each other, the good posters slowly drift away altogether, and all of a sudden you find yourself in Slashdot or Usenet circa 1999. It's basically nothing but people insulting each other or using bad faith arguments or just writing at great length about how much they think stuff sucks.
- ethbro 7y agoThe greatest loss to an online community is when an informed, thoughtful, pleasant person decides they're not going to post anymore. That should be the single endpoint that every community optimizes itself to avoid. Because typically, they have better things to do. And once they decide to leave, they're not coming back. And once the ratio of those folks : total users drops below a certain point, there's no coming back.
- soheil 7y agoIt'd be interesting to run an experiment with different cohorts that joined HN at various times to see if the rise in negativity is due to fundamental shift of opinion in all users of HN or any specific "generation" of HNers.
- gumby 7y agoFWIW I don't feel that at all. Negative comments: sure. Trivializing comments, sure. Also praise.
- tptacek 7y agoI think I agree with this. My friend Dave took a detour into cooking school in between startups, and used to talk about the difference between the NYC restaurant scene (he lived in Manhattan) and the Chicago scene, about how Chicago had a scene focused on building things up and being excited for new stuff to happen, and NYC had kind a vicious, competitive, cynical scene. I usually think of HN as an NYC-style scene, not a Chicago scene. (I'm sure the phenomenon isn't unique to Chicago, but rather shared among all major cities that aren't NYC or LA). But most of HN doesn't work in startups; something like half of it isn't in the US. Without explicit norms-setting that HN seems loathe to do, it's probably not reasonable to expect the kind of enthusiasm you're talking about.
- lawtalkinghuman 7y agoI agree. HN should have been more supportive of bold, innovative and disruptive entrepreneurs like Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos, and Billy McFarland of Fyre, rather than just criticising them all the time.