5 ms·
Tar sands oil is now trading at $6.6/barrel. This is going to be a disaster for the Canadian petro-provinces. While much of this price collapse has been driven
by vkou 7y ago
Tar sands oil is now trading at $6.6/barrel.
This is going to be a disaster for the Canadian petro-provinces. While much of this price collapse has been driven by OPEC, the COVID-depressed gasoline demand is here to stay for at least a few months.
- eloff 7y agoAlberta was already in bad shape before this, with huge sections of Calgary downtown empty, 20% unemployment in rural areas. Now add an oil price collapse and coronavirus shutdown of large parts of the service sector. Very hard times for Alberta ahead. In the oil bust in the first half of the 1980's people would sell their homes for a dollar just to get away from the mortgage because it was completely underwater. I fear we may see those days again in Calgary. I was born there during those days, which I don't remember, but I do recall the stories people told of it while I was growing up.
- vkou 7y agoWith the economics of the tar sands, the entire province has been doing the equivalent of margin trading, to make ends meet, for the past two decades. Tiny swings in price either bring a moderate windfall, or utter ruin. It's not a great way to run your economy.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>the entire province has been doing the equivalent of margin trading, to make ends meet, for the past two decades. Tiny swings in price either bring a big windfall, or utter ruin. >It's not a great way to run your economy. Sure, but what other way do they have to run their economy? Without monumental government effort to keep prices stable grain (and grain derived products) isn't much better.
- vkou 7y agoAlberta used to be a cattle province[1][2], before the petro-firms trampled all over farmer rights, and imported a million people to work the tar sands/support the people who worked the tar sands. Just because you've destroyed the ring, you can't really go back to the Shire, but Alberta's choices in the 21st century are either a return to agriculture, and mass emigration, or a transition to exporting professional services. [1] Ironically, while the price of oil plummets, the spot price for beef is up 20% since the start of this crisis... Although, the price of beef futures is dropping a bit. [2] Edit: I'm aware that agriculture employs a small number of people (1.5-2% of the population, but so does oil extraction - only 0.3% of the population directly works in the tar sands - everyone else supports them.) Like any other industry, it has a large supporting industry of suppliers, truckers, etc. It's not nearly as lucrative as oil, but it's a living.
- eloff 7y agoAgriculture employs about 1.5% of the population of Canada according to the world bank. It's heavily automated and while crucial, it will never be able to employ a large fraction of the population. You can't wind the clock back to the 1900s without undoing all the gains made in the last century. Alberta needs to look to Norway and Dubai for how you diversify away from oil in earnest.
- LeoTinnitus 7y agoWhile it's not realistic, I guarantee that if you initiated the homestead act again in the US, people would do it. Free land and basically full autonomy? I'm 100% certain there is a sizeable chunk of those types in the US and Canada that would make that trade. The reason the homestead act died was cause businesses lobbied the government to get rid of it so as not to give lower income types a choice. They had to work in their factories to survive.
- eloff 7y agoMost of the land you could do that with is agriculturally unproductive. Which is why it's federal land to begin with. Some of it is natural parks, and I don't want to see that turned to agriculture. I really don't think it's that simple at all.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoBit of a dead horse here, but they could have done a sovereign wealth fund, Norway-style. Would have helped with the secession plans too, back when those were being taken seriously. Armchair quarterbacking I know, but the trouble seems to be that when Alberta has any money at all, oil is the most profitable thing to invest in so that's where the money goes. Investing in uncorrelated assets would level out some of those crazy swings. Then again, most Albertans I worked with kind of liked the crazy swings. As I'm a bluenoser that was during a boom time of course, so I've no idea how they feel about it during the lows.
- jonathannorris 7y agoYea it's bad, Alberta has been trying and failing to diversify their economy for 50 years: https://business.financialpost.com/commodities/energy/after-50-years-of-trying-to-diversify-its-economy-alberta-is-still-stuck-on-oil https://business.financialpost.com/commodities/energy/after-...
- nostrademons 7y agoIsn't this what the primary futures markets are for? As an oil producer, you lock in a price for the oil that you know you're going to produce in 3 or 6 or 12 months. Let a financier in some big city take on the risk that the price might be higher or lower, where they can hedge it against other investments.
- thechao 7y ago> people would sell their homes for a dollar just to get away from the mortgage That's not how mortgages work in the USA — or any other country I've heard of! Usually, the way a mortgage works, is that you owe the lender the money, and the house is the collateral asset. Divesting yourself of the asset usually requires you to pay off the balance of the mortgage on sale.
- llukas 7y agoNot in non recourse states. (https://homeguides.sfgate.com/happens-give-keys-back-mortgage-company-54780.html https://homeguides.sfgate.com/happens-give-keys-back-mortgag...)
- thechao 7y agoThat's walking away from a mortgage. The GP said "people would sell their homes for a dollar just to get away from the mortgage". The sale of the asset doesn't let you discharge the mortgage in a non-recourse state: you give the house to the lender in lieu of paying the loan. (And declare bankruptcy!)
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoI'm not certain, but I gather in this case the person who bought the house for a dollar would also take over the mortgage. Canadains are weird around home ownership, our markets don't behave like other developed countries'
- the8472 7y ago> This is going to be a disaster for the Canadian petro-provinces. If the pitch stays in the ground it'll be good for the environment which ultimately is good for people too. Just on longer time horizons.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoAnd it likely forces some form of UBI for the oil industry evaporating. This is only fair to Alberta, considering how much they’ve contributed to Canada’s GDP over the last two decades.
- richk449 7y ago> This is only fair to Alberta, considering how much they’ve contributed to Canada’s GDP over the last two decades. Is contributing to GDP something you get "credit" for? Or put another way, does someone living in Toronto get any benefit from this increase in GDP?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nogabebop23 7y ago>> does someone living in Toronto get any benefit from this increase in GDP? As someone living in Alberta your comment answers a question we ask each other frequently: Do people outside of Alberta understand the benefit they've enjoyed from energy revenues over the past 20 years? Your comment suggests NO, but I'm not sure where you are located. Canada has a massive transfer payment process from "Have" provinces to "Have Not". This is not something as academic as "overall GDP increase" but is BILLIONS of actual dollars that Alberta has contributed during all the good times that were then redistributed to other Canadians, just like people living in Toronto. Not to over-emphasize the point, but I'm talking cold hard cash literally taxed from one province and given to the others, with the Federal government taking their vig during the transfer. If you're not Canadian it's unlikely you are aware of the direct positive impact this has had on the entire nation. If you are Canadian and unaware of the relative value of transfer payments... well, this accounts for a huge amount of the alienation the Western prairie provinces are feeling. This is an issue outside of the debate around where our energy comes from. The reality is a huge part of the entire country's expenditures has been financed by oil and gas revenues for a large part of the past 20 years.
- ohiovr 7y agoTemporary until Saudi Arabia folds.
- SaxonRobber 7y agoThis is wishful thinking
- ohiovr 7y agoWell thinking that oil will go back up might be but Saudi did this this exact same thing before.
- vkou 7y agoEven if you think the Kingdom of Saud will explode tomorrow, whatever despot/warlord/theocracy/hippy commune that will arise to replace it will keep pumping that oil out of the sand. Waiting for Saudi oil to go away is magical thinking.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoDon't say that too loud. Trump might get ideas that'll make the 8 years under Bush jr look like a playground spat.
- sxcurry 7y agoCareful now, calling it "tar sands" instead of "oil sands" is a big no-no in Canada. They don't want the world to know just how dirty it really is.
- tathougies 7y ago> While much of this price collapse has been driven by OPEC, the COVID-depressed gasoline demand is here to stay for at least a few months. This is why OPEC is doing this. They're trying to put American and Canadian firms out of business. They saw the COVID opportunity, and they seized it.
- SaxonRobber 7y agoIt was actually motivated by competition from Russia.