All judges of health are subjective obviously, and while HN has flaws I would judge it to be, yes. The main thing I would point to justify that it is healthy i

All judges of health are subjective obviously, and while HN has flaws I would judge it to be, yes. The main thing I would point to justify that it is healthy is that the vast majority of the comments are informed, well written and productive. They add to the information in the linked article, and provide insight from multiple points of view.