3 ms·
The thing is, South Korea (and many other Asian countries cited as having handled COVID19 relatively well, such as Taiwan, HK, Singapore, Japan) have all learne
by mschuster91 7y ago
The thing is, South Korea (and many other Asian countries cited as having handled COVID19 relatively well, such as Taiwan, HK, Singapore, Japan) have all learned from the 2003 SARS epidemic and others, while the Western countries did not. This is not just in terms of politics/preparation to disasters, but also in the civilization - in Asia even the most radical and extreme measures are accepted by the population as everyone there knows what a pandemic can cause, while in Germany people are having "corona parties" and there have been numerous incidents of people spitting or coughing at other people.
Additionally, in many Western countries healthcare systems have been wrecked by neoliberalism profit-first ideology (Germany, UK), by austerity following the 2008 financial crisis (Italy, Spain, Greece) or by decades of incompetency (USA), combined with the end of stockpiling of critical assets such as face masks, gloves and other PPE after the end of the Cold War.
The key point of "shutting down" is to avoid overloading the healthcare systems, or at least to try to limit the overloading.
- rfoo 7y agoAlso there was MERS in South Korea (2015), people remember what happened 5 years ago much better than what happened 17 years ago (SARS).
- luckylion 7y agoIt might have something to do with people remembering a previous disease outbreak, it might also be primarily a question of how collectivist vs individualist the societies are and how strongly the population follows government suggestions/orders. Considering that, you'd expect South Korea or Japan to do better than Germany, Germany to do better than the US or Italy. And even within Germany, you'd expect large cities to do worse, with Berlin leading the charge. Would Hamburg be affected as much if it wasn't for their holidays falling right into that time?
- tooltalk 7y ago> in Asia even the most radical and extreme measures are accepted by the population as everyone there knows what a pandemic can cause, Well, yes and no. They might have been more willing to accept that 30-40 years ago, but definitely not these days. They've been always known for militant labor unions, religious fanatics, and political extremism -- the last two attributed to the outbreak in South Korea this time around. There are still religious groups defying the gov't's plea not to hold mass services in South Korea today. > in many Western countries healthcare systems have been wrecked by neoliberalism profit-first ... South Korea suffered a much smaller coronavirus, MERS, not too long ago and they found out that they were awfully unprepared for a public health crisis of that scale (only 130+ were infected and 30+ death), so they spent the next several years preparing for the "next" crisis. Their gov't removed all potential legal/legislative barriers that had hindered their response last time around and private biotech companies started working on reagents and the medical infrastructure almost as soon as the outbreak in Wuhan became known.