4 ms·
Nice graphs, but I have to question if the numbers are accurate. Let's take UK stats as an example - good healthcare, good coverage of testing, moderate panic l
by muzani 7y ago
Nice graphs, but I have to question if the numbers are accurate. Let's take UK stats as an example - good healthcare, good coverage of testing, moderate panic levels.
11,658 cases as of writing. 578 deaths, 135 recoveries. 163 in serious condition.
1.4% critical, 4.7% deaths, that's not too bad.
But what worries me is that statistic with 578 deaths and 135 recoveries. This is probably because there's a lot of unreported cases, maybe 10,000 people feel sick, stay at home, don't want to tell anyone, and a portion of those die because it's too late, or have an asthma attack classified as Corona. But it looks like a 80% mortality rate from this really pessimistic angle. What am I missing here?
- cycrutchfield 7y agoRecovery rates are not uniform, and more ill patients die faster than well patients recover. #deaths/(#deaths + #recoveries) will overestimate CFR, and #deaths/#cases will underestimate CFR. The final result will be somewhere in the middle, around 1-1.5%, unless the hospital system gets overloaded in the UK.
- oizin 7y agoCalculating the mortality rates as deaths/(deaths+recovered) will give you a biased result for an ongoing epidemic.
- rumanator 7y agoIt's a deaths/infections ratio. What's biased about that?
- irishsultan 7y agoThe number that worried the OP was deaths/(deaths + recovered), that's different from deaths/(deaths + recovered + ongoing cases).
- david_draco 7y agoThe temporal dimension. Comparing the deaths now to the infected now doesn't make a lot of sense. (I would question whether the UK has good coverage of testing.)
- irishsultan 7y agoNumber of deaths is a lagging indicator, but number of recoveries lags even more.
- jspash 7y agoI'm not sure I agree with "good coverage of testing". As of today (27th Mar) there have been roughly 100,000 people tested out of 66,440,000. That's a mere 0.015% of the population tested. I think that's around 1 out of every 6,600 people (unless my maths are wrong). They aren't even testing all people with symptoms yet here. Only if they are severe or the patient is high risk.
- muzani 7y agoYeah, it was hard to pick something at random. But I figure it was better than, say, Brazil or US.
- DanBC 7y ago> good coverage of testing, The UK is only testing people admitted to hospital for suspected covid-19, and it's not testing all of them.