3 ms·
My reaction is: So? As a fan of both Tolkien and Evangelion, I find this sentiment to be pointless and tinged with misplaced agression. You wonder why you sho
by stcredzero 16y ago
My reaction is: So?
As a fan of both Tolkien and Evangelion, I find this sentiment to be pointless and tinged with misplaced agression.
You wonder why you should care about Tolkien? Why should we care that you care?
- chc 16y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to say. The fact that you're a fan of JRR's work and Evangellion means Chris Tolkien should be able to bully whomever he feels like? That doesn't make any sense, but I don't know how else to read your comment.
- stcredzero 16y agoNo, this is entirely wrong, and it shows some small-minded thinking on the part of readers. (1) (And I dont' care how much Karma that burns.) I object to the content and tone of the button. Whether or not I support Chris Tolkien's actions is immaterial to that. I do not support it, and I support the button maker's freedom of speech. But I also feel compelled to speak out, that the message itself is snide and stupid. Really, do we need to encourage the fragmentation of fandom? (1) - Whether you support someone's freedom of speech, and whether you think much of what they're saying are entirely separate. Please use your brains and comprehend principles and get beyond simple tribal loyalty.
- Confusion 16y agoThe discussion concerns the behavior of the Tolkien estate. Your 'so?' will only be interpreted as concerning that behavior. We aren't psychically empowered to understand you are expressing a sentiment about the sentiment expressed by the button that triggered the behavior of the Tolkien estate.
- stcredzero 16y agoWe aren't psychically empowered to understand you are expressing a sentiment about the sentiment expressed by the button that triggered the behavior of the Tolkien estate. Yes, I've been long aware that the esoteric power of reading comprehension is beyond the reach of many net denizens' psyches. (That's a drink in the stcredzero drinking game.) How about this for a clue -- I referred directly to the button's content.
- Confusion 16y agoUnfortunately, the button's content is not what this article and the subsequent discussion is about: the article is about the behavior of the Tolkien estate and your response will be interpreted as relating to that. In that light, your argument makes little sense, as chc pointed out, but that is not generally a reason to consider a different interpretation. You should realize that most people don't know you're a guy that usually tends to post arguments that makes sense. You may as well be one of the many silly people that does post this kind of nonsensical argument, trying to argue the Tolkien estate is allowed to behave this way because you feel what they targeted was wrong anyway. Subsequently insulting the intelligence of readers is uncalled for and fails to acknowledge a possible failure on your side. I would argue this is not about our reading comprehension: you failed to make clear that you were deviating from the subject under discussion to make some remarks about a related issue, because you were assuming people would understand that you were not arguing in favor of Tolkien's behavior. That assumption has been proven unwarranted: people don't understand that you won't argue nonsensical things. Which is entirely understandable, considering the amount of people that do argue nonsensical things.
- stcredzero 16y agotl;dr - We didn't think about your comment. We assumed you were taking a side. You didn't spell it out for us. We didn't bother to find an interpretation that would make sense. tl;dr^2 - We are lazy and have poor reading comprehension. I'm very sorry, if it taxes your imagination that someone would want to talk about what was written on the button. It's not like that would be at all relevant to the article, I guess. (My apologies to the sarcasm impaired.)