2 ms·
> Whenever the lockdown ends, it's almost like we're back to square one. The part they're not telling you is that that conclusion is not an output of the model
by pdonis 7y ago
> Whenever the lockdown ends, it's almost like we're back to square one.
The part they're not telling you is that that conclusion is not an output of the model. It's an input to the model. The model tells you cases will surge up again after lockdown ends because that assumption was put into it.
More precisely, the underlying assumption is that, even if you get to the point where there are no new cases and you've waited long enough that the incubation period has passed, so everybody who was exposed to the virus is either symptomatic and being quarantined or asymptomatic and has no issues, it is still possible for new people to get infected. But if the incubation period has passed and everyone is either quarantined or asymptomatic, how is anyone new supposed to get infected? The people who are symptomatic are quarantined, so they can't, and the people who are asymptomatic shouldn't be contagious any more, because the incubation period has passed. Yet the computer models predict new cases. So the models are assuming that somehow people can be exposed to the virus, never develop symptoms, but stay contagious indefinitely. That doesn't seem to be a realistic assumption.
- crazygringo 7y ago> But if the incubation period has passed and everyone is either quarantined or asymptomatic, how is anyone new supposed to get infected? Because that's obviously an unrealistic assumption. Realistic lockdown still has tons of people mixing at the grocery store, at the doctor's or hospital, with all the essential services. During lockdown tons of new people are getting infected constantly. There's zero way to bring that down to zero. Lockdown is just about reducing it. And of course, even if a single country managed to achieve the impossible and bring it to zero -- somebody from another country is going to visit at some point and reintroduce it.
- selimthegrim 7y agoAsymptomatic people can transmit - you can have a small minority be responsible for the majority of new cases
- pdonis 7y ago> Asymptomatic people can transmit For how long? If I was exposed to the virus last week and am asymptomatic, will I still be contagious in another week? A month? A year?
- selimthegrim 7y agoUntil you seroconvert I guess, I don’t think there are prodromes and shedding like herpes
- pdonis 7y ago> Until you seroconvert I guess Ok, so how long is that?
- pdonis 7y ago> Realistic lockdown still has tons of people mixing at the grocery store, at the doctor's or hospital, with all the essential services. That's not what "lockdown" meant in China. In China it meant people getting welded inside their homes, no mixing of people in public, nothing functioning anywhere even close to normal. If the NYT is defining "lockdown" the way you describe, then they're just redefining the word to suit their agenda. What you're describing is more like the UK "mitigation" strategy, where you don't try to contain the virus, you just try to slow down the growth so that everybody eventually gets infected, but at a slow enough rate that the health care system can cope. But if that's the strategy, we're talking a year at least, not two months. To be clear: I'm actually not in favor of "reopening America" in two weeks, come what may. We have to see how things develop, and I doubt things will have developed in two weeks to the point where most Americans feel comfortable relaxing social distancing. But nobody knows enough about what's going to happen to make confident predictions, either that there will be a massive upsurge if we go back to normal, or that there won't. By saying "Here's what happens if we do", NYT is being hugely overconfident, and they shouldn't be. They should be honest and say that nobody really knows at this point how things are going to develop, and encourage people to exercise common sense and not expect any Authoritative Expert to tell them what to do or how things are going to play out.