5 ms·
The NYT published a simulator yesterday that shows infections/deaths over time according to lockdown lengths: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/25/op
by crazygringo 7y ago
The NYT published a simulator yesterday that shows infections/deaths over time according to lockdown lengths:
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/25/opinion/coronavirus-trump-reopen-america.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/25/opinion/coron...
The first two graphs show the incredibly dramatic reduction in infections and deaths if we lock down for 2 months as opposed to just 2 weeks.
But what scares me is the sudden uptick at the end of the period shown. And the article addresses it:
> A skeptic will note that these measures don’t seem to prevent a surge in infections so much as delay them (in some cases so that the impact is pushed beyond the period that this model tracks). There’s something to that: We may see a resurgence whenever we let up, at least until we have a vaccine or herd immunity.
But this is what scares me. Whenever the lockdown ends, it's almost like we're back to square one.
Yes, of course we have time to manufacture more ventilators and masks and everything else. But I don't think anyone's contemplating a year-long lockdown until a vaccine might be ready.
So somebody correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't developing herd immunity seems like the only realistic scenario here? Which basically means just enough lockdown to "flatten the curve" but then essentially give the virus free reign -- accepting that people will die, but still saving many more lives than right now (because enough ventilators, etc.).
Yet virtually nobody seems to be talking about this -- about herd immunity, about how there's zero chance of a lockdown eradicating the virus, about coming to terms with what "flattening the curve" really means and when we decide it's been flattened enough.
I suppose that's where the national conversation will have to go in the next couple weeks/months... but it seems better to be having it up-front.
- comicjk 7y agoJust because people are out and about doesn't mean we have to go back to the old value of R. In order to make easing lockdown viable, we need to reduce R for people outside, in every way we can afford. Masks for everyone, of the highest quality we can manage without hurting healthcare. Continue distancing. Constant surface cleaning and air filtration. Mass antibody tests, so we know who has already had it. With all of this, and lockdown for critical outbreak areas, we should be able to keep the curve under control.
- mcnamaratw 7y ago"Yet virtually nobody seems to be talking about this -- about herd immunity, about how there's zero chance of a lockdown eradicating the virus, about coming to terms with what "flattening the curve" really means and when we decide it's been flattened enough." To me this seems like what everyone is talking about all the time.
- crazygringo 7y agoI don't think so -- my impression is that most people are under the impression that we flatten the curve, end the lockdown, and the end result is that most people will not ever get the virus and it will no longer be a problem. I don't see people acknowledging the fact that a large percentage of people, if not a large majority of the population probably, are eventually going to get it. Right now what people are talking about is "lockdown now" and "we don't know when it will end". Not about when the right time is for it to end, or the reality that there will obviously be a surge in cases once it does. (Assuming that the virus doesn't spread to large/majority percent of the population during lockdown anyways.) I think most people are hoping a vaccine will show up in a month or something and that will fix things. When the reality seems to be that a vaccine is something like a year away.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mcnamaratw 7y agoThe message is going out. I don't know whether it's getting to people. It would help if the main news story were supporting the medical and public health responses to the pandemic. Instead 80% of the press seems to believe that the main story right now is to keep on signaling which side they're on in the political food fight.
- ohyes 7y agoLockdown is entirely about trying desperately to not overwhelm the healthcare system. Do not confuse it with eradication of the virus. If the healthcare system gets overwhelmed you end up with a much higher mortality rate and secondary deaths because treatments for things that would not have been life threatening are no longer are available.
- pdonis 7y ago> Whenever the lockdown ends, it's almost like we're back to square one. The part they're not telling you is that that conclusion is not an output of the model. It's an input to the model. The model tells you cases will surge up again after lockdown ends because that assumption was put into it. More precisely, the underlying assumption is that, even if you get to the point where there are no new cases and you've waited long enough that the incubation period has passed, so everybody who was exposed to the virus is either symptomatic and being quarantined or asymptomatic and has no issues, it is still possible for new people to get infected. But if the incubation period has passed and everyone is either quarantined or asymptomatic, how is anyone new supposed to get infected? The people who are symptomatic are quarantined, so they can't, and the people who are asymptomatic shouldn't be contagious any more, because the incubation period has passed. Yet the computer models predict new cases. So the models are assuming that somehow people can be exposed to the virus, never develop symptoms, but stay contagious indefinitely. That doesn't seem to be a realistic assumption.
- crazygringo 7y ago> But if the incubation period has passed and everyone is either quarantined or asymptomatic, how is anyone new supposed to get infected? Because that's obviously an unrealistic assumption. Realistic lockdown still has tons of people mixing at the grocery store, at the doctor's or hospital, with all the essential services. During lockdown tons of new people are getting infected constantly. There's zero way to bring that down to zero. Lockdown is just about reducing it. And of course, even if a single country managed to achieve the impossible and bring it to zero -- somebody from another country is going to visit at some point and reintroduce it.
- selimthegrim 7y agoAsymptomatic people can transmit - you can have a small minority be responsible for the majority of new cases
- pdonis 7y ago> Asymptomatic people can transmit For how long? If I was exposed to the virus last week and am asymptomatic, will I still be contagious in another week? A month? A year?