2 ms·
As I noted, there are many ways to use "the". You're correct that the rule I gave doesn't cover most of them. You're mostly wrong in the details: > Now, the Pr
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
As I noted, there are many ways to use "the". You're correct that the rule I gave doesn't cover most of them. You're mostly wrong in the details:
> Now, the President wasn't part of your conversational context, in fact there was no conversational context, nor any context with the speaker.
This is very wrong; the President, like all proper nouns, is part of the conversational context. You may validly assume that your listener knows the identity of "the President" in the same way you assume that they know the meaning of the word "outside". For this reason, all proper nouns, arthrous [= marked with "the"] or not, are always definite.
Some English proper nouns are arthrous and some aren't; there is no rule governing this.
> But "a President is outside!" is clearly wrong.
It's not ill-formed in any way[1], though it raises some questions about how you know there's a president out there without also knowing which president it is. But more importantly, I restricted my comment to cases where "the" contrasts with "a", and this is not such a case. "The President" and "a president" are not parallel formations.
[1] If you insist on capitalizing President [referring to a specific known individual], then it is indeed ill-formed. Proper nouns are definite and "a" is indefinite.